Remove this Banner Ad

Opinion Round 2 Changes vs. Geelong

  • Thread starter Thread starter YelloMit
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Out:
Suban
Mayne possibly ( weather pending)

In:
Muzungu
Taberner ( see above re weather )

Macca and Johnson are in for a tough assignment next week, need ibbo to lift with some more interception work.
 
Functioning forward line please. Missing all night until last quarter (mainly after Mayney went off :( )

Mayne needs to earn CHF/FF, or give it to Tabs.

Walters is not a leading target.
Mayne rolled his ankle in the first quarter and thereafter could hardly chase. Hopefully it will only be minor damage and he won't spend another season under an injury cloud.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Outs
Mayne, Suban
Ins
Taberner, Mzungu.
Sub-De Boer
Yep, this. We really need that extra tall forward. Bombing into the forward 50 isn't a great strategy when your smalls are having to lead. They should be up back mopping up the spoils.
I thing DeBoer's making a decent sub at the moment. He comes on with plenty of power.
 
Yep, this. We really need that extra tall forward. Bombing into the forward 50 isn't a great strategy when your smalls are having to lead. They should be up back mopping up the spoils.
I thing DeBoer's making a decent sub at the moment. He comes on with plenty of power.

You would think that Clarke could play that second tall... but he often drifts up to the ball, often its a throw in or a large pack coming out of defence. Its that quick kick out of that congestion / area that we need that second big tall at least putting the ball to ground. Too often tonight it was waltzed out with very little pressure.
 
I reckon the MRP will be on Fyfe after this http://streamable.com/lutr - as you can see a Port player got severe bodily injury from the way he recklessly kicked the ball and needless to say that the MRP will rub him out for at least 8 weeks. Absolute thug.

Besides that, maybe take Suban out - I wasn't exactly impressed by him as an opposition supporter (as in, I didn't abuse him enough while watching).
Don't worry. Half of greater Fremantle abused him profusely throughout the game for you.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Our problems were less those that will be solved by replacement players (though Gu will be a big in) than those that will be solved by the same players executing better. We saw in the last quarter that Mundy, Hilly, Pav and Sandi lifted - if they (plus Ballas, Zaarke, Lukey and Barlow) can play like that for four quarters then we will have a fair shake against Geebung. If Mayne is out I'm not sure who comes in - maybe Croz or Weller? Gu in for Suban I think. Hopefully Deboer starts, I think in games in Victoria he is at his best when playing three quarters...

We really, really miss Dawson and Silvagni.
 
Without Dawson, Tommahawk worries me. Now Geelong have added Mitch Clark and Rhys Stanley (only plays well against us) they will stretch us for height.

McPharlin has traditionally struggled against Tommahawk however he pantsed Cloke round 1 last year when I thought the same thing.
 
Without Dawson, Tommahawk worries me. Now Geelong have added Mitch Clark and Rhys Stanley (only plays well against us) they will stretch us for height.

McPharlin has traditionally struggled against Tommahawk however he pantsed Cloke round 1 last year when I thought the same thing.

Yep, I think Elvis, MJ and Ibbo will have their work cut out for them against the Geebung boyos. We definitely need much better tackling in the midfield if we are to have a decent chance at Sleepy Hollow.

Wouldn't surprise to see Tanner Smith or Alex Pearce named in the 25, if they give a bit of extra effort at training who knows - wouldn't be the first time Roscoe has taken a flier on a younger player.
 
Yep, I think Elvis, MJ and Ibbo will have their work cut out for them against the Geebung boyos. We definitely need much better tackling in the midfield if we are to have a decent chance at Sleepy Hollow.

Wouldn't surprise to see Tanner Smith or Alex Pearce named in the 25, if they give a bit of extra effort at training who knows - wouldn't be the first time Roscoe has taken a flier on a younger player.

Tanner can't play, he's on the rookie list.
 
Tanner can't play, he's on the rookie list.

I'm assuming that Mora will go to the LTI and Tanner will be the special someone who will be upgraded to take the LTI rookie spot.

NOTE - I do hope I am wrong and Mora bursts back in round four for Peel.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Mzungu is always best 22 and will come in, who comes out... maybe C Pearce, but depends on the roles the coach needs filled. I'd swap Mayne for Taberner, an extra marking forward would be very useful right now. Mayne tried hard tonight, but didnt do enough to keep his spot IMO. We have to reward good form in the WAFL, Peel won by 60+ points, so reward those who were most influential in that game.
 
Quite liked De Boer's game in the bit that he got on the field. Wouldn't mind seeing him run with Selwood next week.

Ibbo needs to get his head to the speed of the game before the fourth quarter if he wants to keep his place when Dawson is available.
 
You would think that Clarke could play that second tall... but he often drifts up to the ball, often its a throw in or a large pack coming out of defence. Its that quick kick out of that congestion / area that we need that second big tall at least putting the ball to ground. Too often tonight it was waltzed out with very little pressure.

Still don't understand why Sandi didn't play forward
 
Still don't understand why Sandi didn't play forward

Ross was asked whether he would before the game. He explained that Sandi's neural hammy complaint in the offseason restricted him and they would be protecting him. He added that spending time forward and having to bend over at ground level would place him at risk of doing a hammy. The big fella's dominance with the tap work last night and giving us first use was telling especially with Lobbe ruled out.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom