Round 2 Trades

[Didstar]

is Milera to Papley too knee jerk? Scores aside Milera 178k to Papley 109k would help a lot.

Unless you have multiple rookie corrections to make, there's no point going early in round 2. best to wait till just before the price change. Milera could come out with the ton and papley going sub 40. You never know what will happen week to week.

 

[SterlingArcher]

More than likely he will never score another hundred in his career.

He could be F6, he could also be Taylor Hunt MkII

 

[Crawb]

is Milera to Papley too knee jerk? Scores aside Milera 178k to Papley 109k would help a lot.

I'm still backing Milera to play and average more. He had a dud game, which happens. Better to do it in Round 1 rather than Round 3. Papley played his best and probably won't play that well again. If they perform similarly next week I might consider a correction trade - but only then. Certainly not now.

 

[Underarm]

There should be better targets for trade than Milera out I would imagine.

 

[Footy_Fan2007]

Is it worth keeping all premos for another round? Laird and Greene have been pretty bad.

(Definitely doing Milera to Papley)

Laird was far from bad.....

 

[Me Myself and I]

Is it worth keeping all premos for another round? Laird and Greene have been pretty bad.

If Laird was bad and still scores 90 I'll take that for a defender.

 

[ROFL]

Steele and Seedsman disappointed (my 2 damn mid priced PODs)
I've got No BenKen or Oliver or weiters

Maybe Steele --> BenKen
Essendon rook --> Weitering
???
Or Seedsman --> Weiters
Steele --> premo FWD

Who has best JS out of the 2 Melb rookies?? I can't bring in Oliver for Steele as no fwd/mid dpp

 

[nameless]

A lot of 80s, 90s from my players, which isn't enough to trade out.

Got all the rookies, so unless Dunkley kills it I won't be making any moves there.

 

[harrylano]

Milera to Papley

and

Greene to 510k forward

Thoughts?

papley will be dropped

 

[nameless]

papley will be dropped

No he won't

 

[Jiska]

papley will be dropped

 

[The Lemon]

I'm thinking hard about Milera to BenKen too. Flashy half forward to a gut running mid isn't the worst option.

Am glad I have Papley , even if he was on the bench. Can't see him getting dropped after last night.

Might dump McCarthy too for Papley. No way Linc does anything

 

[Daniel McL]

Am happy with my rookies I have so the only trade I may do is Gresham out (perhaps if he isn't named next week) for a cheaper mid rookie and then McCarthy in FWD line upgrade to Ben Ken

Otherwise no trades for me this week barring injury. Fyfe has been poor but you don't trade him after 1 bad game.

So yeah not so much trades for me more just moving rookies like Papley on field.

 

[Krujan]

Milera to Papley

and

Greene to 510k forward

Thoughts?

What's with the new username Judd_Magic?

 

[Krujan]

Am happy with my rookies I have so the only trade I may do is Gresham out (perhaps if he isn't named next week) for a cheaper mid rookie and then McCarthy in FWD line upgrade to Ben Ken

Otherwise no trades for me this week barring injury. Fyfe has been poor but you don't trade him after 1 bad game.

So yeah not so much trades for me more just moving rookies like Papley on field.

McCarthy hasn't even played yet and you're planning on trading him out next week. And a Geelong supported to boot. Have some faith in your young gun FFS

 

[The Lemon]

What's with the new username Judd_Magic?

He's no Yze_Magic

 

[Daniel McL]

McCarthy hasn't even played yet and you're planning on trading him out next week. And a Geelong supported to boot. Have some faith in your young gun FFS

Haha I know I know I'm sorry McCarthy will stay in forward 50 most of game so I was just thinking Ben Ken as he gets more midfield time but yeah I wasn't fully sold on that idea, only if McCarthy gets an injury perhaps or I do that trade before around 3 if Ben Ken gets another 100 & McCarthy has gotten 2 scores of 40-50's or something

 

[KardiniaPark]

Melbourne have Essendon next week , he'll go back to back

I was a bit unkind, I watched the game this morning and he was very good. He struck me as being a selfish dwarf at Collingwood, his game seems to have come a long way. But he's still a dwarf.

 

[P_Cripps]

Made up my mind now. No rookie trades. Greene to Merrett. Merret scored 127 when they lost by 10 goals which shows he can win his own ball. Not knee jerk, logical.

 

[KardiniaPark]

Made up my mind now. No rookie trades. Greene to Merrett. Merret scored 127 when they lost by 10 goals which shows he can win his own ball. Not knee jerk, logical.

'Not knee jerk'

 

[WatWouldCyrilDo]

M. Brown to one of Lonergan, BSmith, Sheridan. Just not sure who.......??

 

[Bob81]

Not liking my Tippett selection, 32 hit outs for 82 points in a spanking.

CD ruck scoring is starting out the same as last year.

Im not sure if they take points off for dropping chest marks in the goal square, if they do then that nay explain it cause he dropped 4 or 5 last night.

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk

 

[P_Cripps]

'Not knee jerk'

Greene wasn't attending centre bounces, was hovering around the outside of packs and kicked 1.1 with 1 out on the full. The only reason I selected him was for his centre bounces.

 

[SterlingArcher]

Anyone considering Jarrad Waite? 20 and 3'd, so he's basically Leigh Matthews tier form right now. Only logical to get him in this very week.

 

[Flandersss]

Anyone considering Jarrad Waite? 20 and 3'd, so he's basically Leigh Matthews tier form right now. Only logical to get him in this very week.

Short answer, yes.