Trades Round 20 trades, first week of finals.

(Log in to remove this ad.)

go you pups

Hall of Famer
Jun 27, 2013
42,990
38,257
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
Other Teams
Tottenham Hotspur, SSC Napoli, ESH
Some really stinky defenders going around

Got 2 trades left

Can bank 162k for my last trade (likely injury trade) if I go Witherden to Birchall, seriously don't think many others will outscore Birchall by much

Only problem with Birchall is he might need another rest though

Otherwise it's Hately/Bewley to Snelling and Witherden to best available 600-650k range and no more trades
 

Agechamp

Club Legend
Feb 25, 2018
1,777
667
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Some really stinky defenders going around

Got 2 trades left

Can bank 162k for my last trade (likely injury trade) if I go Witherden to Birchall, seriously don't think many others will outscore Birchall by much

Only problem with Birchall is he might need another rest though

Otherwise it's Hately/Bewley to Snelling and Witherden to best available 600-650k range and no more trades
Defenders are horrible..

I'm thinking houli in but he's so unpredictable.
Then I cop a Stewart today.
 

TheRednWhite

Norm Smith Medallist
Jan 27, 2017
5,261
3,689
AFL Club
Sydney
Some really stinky defenders going around

Got 2 trades left

Can bank 162k for my last trade (likely injury trade) if I go Witherden to Birchall, seriously don't think many others will outscore Birchall by much

Only problem with Birchall is he might need another rest though

Otherwise it's Hately/Bewley to Snelling and Witherden to best available 600-650k range and no more trades
agree, if you can't get to Whit then it's slim pickings. I would go the Birchall route over guys like Salem and Houli. Maybe ZWilliams is the most trustworthy at that price. I liked the look of Hunter Clark as a cheaper option though, has a good role playing mid, tackles well. Clark would be better than Birchall but maybe it's best to keep one trade up your sleeve.
 

Jackfrost

Club Legend
Sep 20, 2007
2,132
1,056
Perth
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Swan Districts
My backline needs work and I've got Ellis and Sicily I need to turf with the double chance in my cash league. Gone Quaynor>Watson for backline cover and Ellis>Crisp but am almost lured by Simpson.
Leaves me with a backline of Lloyd, Whitfield, Laird, Sicily, Crisp and Birch.

Sent from my SM-G973F using Tapatalk
 

Agechamp

Club Legend
Feb 25, 2018
1,777
667
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
walsh is going, but who to? i have 338k before his trade (Clarke to Snelling). will leave me 1 left.

zorko
gaff
brouch
jelly
other??
Screen Shot 2019-07-29 at 5.19.05 pm.png


Edit, or if I just got Walsh to 716,700.

Leaves me with 2 trades then.
Rules out zorko by 15kish.
 
Last edited:

HolyRioli

Norm Smith Medallist
May 17, 2009
7,409
4,241
Perth
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Other Teams
Leeds Utd
Ziebell -> Dusty, looking for a bit of a unique in finals. Should smash Melbourne this week and hopefully get me the week off.

Only other trade I'm looking at is Blakely to Hunter Clark, but I'll probably save the trades (2 left after the above)
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Bender571

Norm Smith Medallist
Sep 26, 2007
5,267
4,561
Perth
AFL Club
Fremantle
I want to move on Sicily and Westhoff. I can trade them for any combination of available players except Crisp and Billings/Marshall

Possible defenders - Houli, Crisp, Stewart, Williams
Possible Forwards - Billings, Marshall, Greene, Daniel

717799
 

Agent93

#RebelforLife
Sep 10, 2010
15,624
18,505
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Toronto Maple Leafs
Reckon I might go Guthrie to Snelling via Answerth, and Ziebell to Zorko via Kelly leaving me $300K for my last trade.
 

kingdidi

Debutant
Aug 15, 2008
64
59
Perth
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Leeds United
I am thinking of trading in Toby Green. i am worried that he might go back to the forward line once J Kelly returns from injury.

Is he likely to keep his current role for the rest of the season?
 

Agechamp

Club Legend
Feb 25, 2018
1,777
667
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
I am thinking of trading in Toby Green. i am worried that he might go back to the forward line once J Kelly returns from injury.

Is he likely to keep his current role for the rest of the season?
Literally just watching Cameron now and he's saying he'll stay mid for this game at least but they like him at the hff role.
 

Agechamp

Club Legend
Feb 25, 2018
1,777
667
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
So I think I've decided on.

Logue to Frederick (just to give me duurs cover in def if I need)
Walsh to zorko (would have loved to go just Walsh to zorko but I was like 10k short)

Thoughts?
Screenshot_20190730-193556_Dream Team.jpg
Screenshot_20190730-193607_Dream Team.jpg
 

TheRednWhite

Norm Smith Medallist
Jan 27, 2017
5,261
3,689
AFL Club
Sydney
So I think I've decided on.

Logue to Frederick (just to give me duurs cover in def if I need)
Walsh to zorko (would have loved to go just Walsh to zorko but I was like 10k short)

Thoughts?
View attachment 718084View attachment 718085
that's a great team, midfield is elite. Not one spud in sight, amazing.
Just wanted to do a comparison to my team (currently with 3 trades left)
Defence
You: Whit, Stewart, ZWilliams
Me: Crisp, Sicily/Guthrie, Duurs

Mid:
You: Treloar, Zorko, Duncan, Rocky
Me: Brouch, Gaff, Murphy, Sloane

Ruc
You: ROB
Me: Gawn

Fwd
You: Marshall, Heeney
Me: Billings, Worpel

It's obvious you've got nearly the best possible defence and midfield, whereas I've gone for cheap premos that turned out to be duds (Sicily, Guthrie, Sloane, Murphy?). Amazing how much better your team is when the only real edge I have over you is Gawn>ROB and even that isn't a big advantage. Just shows how influential ROB has been and what a major disaster it was to miss out on getting him. I should have got ROB when he was at his bottom price and same with Marshall....2 super cheap options that turned out to be keepers. Team would have been miles better if I saved the cash there, would have allowed me to get the expensive but reliable uber premos like treloar, duncan, whitfield.
 

Agechamp

Club Legend
Feb 25, 2018
1,777
667
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
that's a great team, midfield is elite. Not one spud in sight, amazing.
Just wanted to do a comparison to my team (currently with 3 trades left)
Defence
You: Whit, Stewart, ZWilliams
Me: Crisp, Sicily/Guthrie, Duurs

Mid:
You: Treloar, Zorko, Duncan, Rocky
Me: Brouch, Gaff, Murphy, Sloane

Ruc
You: ROB
Me: Gawn

Fwd
You: Marshall, Heeney
Me: Billings, Worpel

It's obvious you've got nearly the best possible defence and midfield, whereas I've gone for cheap premos that turned out to be duds (Sicily, Guthrie, Sloane, Murphy?). Amazing how much better your team is when the only real edge I have over you is Gawn>ROB and even that isn't a big advantage. Just shows how influential ROB has been and what a major disaster it was to miss out on getting him. I should have got ROB when he was at his bottom price and same with Marshall....2 super cheap options that turned out to be keepers. Team would have been miles better if I saved the cash there, would have allowed me to get the expensive but reliable uber premos like treloar, duncan, whitfield.
To be fair, I started with the likes of Seb Ross, Rocky has been in and out twice, jelly came in then out, cogs, brayspud.

I left my defenders until the end as they are mostly average. But started with bsmith and zwilliams.

I'm also lucky I held Dunkley, Heeney and Whitfield

Been super lucky with rookies like Miers, setters, rob.

1 trade will be for rob to gawn if I need him
 

Top Bottom