Votes Round 21, 2023: St.Kilda v Carlton

[George]

Max 5, 15 to distribute

 

[Munga]

Difficult to give votes when they packed up at half time.

5 Wilkie
3 Crouch
2 Sinclair
2 Butler
1 Owens
1 Marshall
1 Clark

 

[Veer Right]

5 Wilkie - Did his job
4 Wood - Wasn't perfect but tried all game
3 Crouch - First three quarters
2 Marshall - First half
1 Butler - Solid

 

[borderbarry]

5. Wood
4 Crouch
3. Wilkie
2. Battle
1......Marshall His first half was very good.

 

[Brains Trust66]

5 Wood
5 Wilkie
3 Marshall
2 Crouch

 

[The Punter]

5 Wood
4 Wilkie
3 Crouch
2 Battle
1 Webster

 

[MCG-Unit]

5 - Wood
3 - Wilkie
2 - Marshall
2 - Crouch
2 - Sinclair
1 - Clark

 

[gringo2011]

5 Wood
4 Wilkie
3 Crouch
2 Battle
1 Webster

Was about to post exactly the same list.

Wood 5
Wilkie 4
Crouch 3
Battle 2
Webster 1

 

[Sainttony]

5 Wilke
4 Battle
3 Wood
2 Marshall
1 Caminitti

 

[Rocky Stevo]

Wood 32 possies.
But forget the massive turnovers, 11 of them.
He was an extra Blue

 

[borderbarry]

I think one of the reasons the Saints fade out after half time is that Marshall tires. WHile he is going well early in games so is the team. He needs more support. Time to give Heath a run.. Caminiti is not up to the job in the ruck.

 

[MCG-Unit]

Wood 32 possies.
But forget the massive turnovers, 11 of them.
He was an extra Blue

Still stats show 24 effective disp
773 MG - most on ground
14 marks - most on ground

 

[Munga]

Still stats show 24 effective disp
773 MG - most on ground
14 marks - most on ground

I didn't look at his stats, just his influence on the match. Unfortunately the turnovers were numerous and horrendous. I'm a big Wood fan, but no votes from me this week.

You can't just take 24 effective disposals on face value. 24 effective and 3 or 4 ineffective, that's a tick. 24 effective and double figure ineffective, there's more harm than good there on the turnovers. He still did well in other aspects, but too much hurt us. He knows it, he'll bounce back.