Prediction Round 22 selection

[jmac70]

So this thread is about your prediction for what the team will look like by round 22. Of course it will depend on where you think we will be as a club. My selection is based on the scenario that we miss finals and have an interim coach. I have included an injury list of players I feel will be unable to finish the year. I have also included a VFL list of players who may either be too old, still developing or delist potentials.

B: Howe Keeffe Ramsay
HB: Scharenberg McLarty Maynard
C: Aish Treloar Sidebottom
HF: Fasolo Mayne Crisp
F: Brown Moore Daicos
Foll: Grundy Pendlebury Treloar
Int: Adams De Goey Smith Hoskin-Elliott

Inj: Reid, Wells, Varcoe, Broomhead, Sinclair, Elliott, Langdon

VFL: Goldsack, White, Blair, Dunn, Greenwood, Oxley, Phillips, Crocker, Kirby, Wills, Sier, Cox, Schade (sorry TG), Thomas, McCarthy, Mackie, Lynch.

 

[Horaceg]

So this thread is about your prediction for what the team will look like by round 22. Of course it will depend on where you think we will be as a club. My selection is based on the scenario that we miss finals and have an interim coach. I have included an injury list of players I feel will be unable to finish the year. I have also included a VFL list of players who may either be too old, still developing or delist potentials.

B: Howe Keeffe Ramsay
HB: Scharenberg McLarty Maynard
C: Aish Treloar Sidebottom
HF: Fasolo Mayne Crisp
F: Brown Moore Daicos
Foll: Grundy Pendlebury Treloar
Int: Adams De Goey Smith Hoskin-Elliott

Inj: Reid, Wells, Varcoe, Broomhead, Sinclair, Elliott, Langdon

VFL: Goldsack, White, Blair, Dunn, Greenwood, Oxley, Phillips, Crocker, Kirby, Wills, Sier, Cox, Schade (sorry TG), Thomas, McCarthy, Mackie, Lynch.

i hope you're totally wrong

Keep the faith, predicting worst case scenario seems a little defeatist. Every year is a new year...... Go Pies 2017

 

[jmac70]

i hope you're totally wrong

Keep the faith, predicting worst case scenario seems a little defeatist. Every year is a new year...... Go Pies 2017

It's just one possible result. The idea is that people can post different scenarios.

 

[Countrypie]

I'm quite bullish about the development of the side this year and hopeful about our injury situation.
Hopefully this team will be cementing its spot in the 8 come round 22 I've named a traditional team sheet

B. Ramsay Dunne Maynard
HB Varcoe Reid Howe
C Wells Adams Sidebottom
HF WHE Moore Mayne
F Faz Cox Elliott
R Grundy Pendlebury Treloar

Int De Goey, Sharenberg, Crisp, Aish or Sinclair
Inj Broomhead, Greenwood Langdon, Keeffe

Notes: 1/ There are half a dozen players that can slip in or out of the last three or four spots
these include the interchange players listed as well as Broomhead, Greenwood, Langdon possibly Thomas and Blair

2/ Jesse White will start the season as the 2nd key tall, but by season's end Cox will have gone past him. I expect Cox to continue to improve at the rate he has and will cause a lot of headaches for opposition teams in the 2nd half of the season.

3/ Realistically any of the players named could comfortably fit into a best 22

4/ Brown and probably Daicos will get some senior time this year but probably won't be in best 22 calculations at the business end of the season
5/ I'm a perennial optimist

 

[Buckley is my hero]

It's just one possible result. The idea is that people can post different scenarios.

No problem posting different scenarios, but why the extreme pessimism when we have recruited well and the players are firing on the training track?

 

[DaVe86]

I'm just hoping scharenberg, Ramsey and broomhead can break in. If we end up with those guys getting fit and cementing a place then it will be a huge positive

 

[jmac70]

No problem posting different scenarios, but why the extreme pessimism when we have recruited well and the players are firing on

I don't think I was being that pessimistic.

 

[doodles98]

Round 22 2017 side prediction:

Injury list: Moore, WHE, Langdon, Sinclair, Kirby, Daicos, Phillips

FB: Maynard Dunn Ramsay
HB: Howe Reid Scharenberg
C: Crisp Pendles Wells
HF: Mayne White Sidebottom
FF: Elliot Cox Fasolo
R: Grundy Adams Treloar

I: Wills Degoey Aish Varco

E: Smith Greenwood

Ladder position: 9th
Coach: Buckley

End of 2017 delistings and retirements:
Blair, Goldsack, Sinclair, Langdon, Phillips, Thomas, Broomhead (trade)

 

[vjknight]

My selection is based on the scenario that we miss finals and have an interim coach.

you mean i have to wait til after round 22 to hear ratten is coach ?

 

[Soups]

Predicting injuries is terrible

 

[mike123]

FB: Matthew Scharenberg ~ Sam McLarty ~ Jackson Ramsay
HB: Daniel Wells ~ Ben Reid ~ Jeremy Howe

C: Travis Varcoe ~ Taylor Adams ~ Adam Treloar
R: Brodie Grundy - Scott Pendlebury ~ Jordan De Goey

HF: Alex Fasolo ~ Jesse White ~ Steele Sidebottom
FF: Mason Cox ~ Darcy Moore ~ Jamie Elliott

B: Kayle Kirby ~ Jack Crisp ~ Brayden Maynard ~ Tim Broomhead

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Drop Grundy after four rubbish games in a row. Blair can ruck.





Wait what's this thread actually for?

 

[mike123]

2/ Jesse White will start the season as the 2nd key tall, but by season's end Cox will have gone past him. I expect Cox to continue to improve at the rate he has and will cause a lot of headaches for opposition teams in the 2nd half of the season.

The 2nd key tall 2nd ruck role doesn't work.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

I'm tired, didn't sleep much....

Greeted by,

Yet another something has happened so it's another coaching thread...

 

[mike123]

I'm tired, didn't sleep much....

Greeted by,

Yet another something has happened so it's another coaching thread...

Ran out of arguments for Buckley I see...

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Ran out of arguments for Buckley I see...

Them or me?

I'm cool with Nathan, I don't have any issues.... I think I've made that very clear, from my point of view.

After a while the hampster wheel will be brought out....

 

[mike123]

Them or me?

I'm cool with Nathan, I don't have any issues.... I think I've made that very clear, from my point of view.

After a while the hampster wheel will be brought out....

You

You've made that very clear, you never mention why though it's always I'm cool with Buckley then some deflection followed by a jab at supporters merely questioning the great man.

 

[doodles98]

Predicting injuries is terrible

I know but Jmac went there and I just followed his lead.

 

[Countrypie]

The 2nd key tall 2nd ruck role doesn't work.

See note 5 "I am a perennial optimist"

 

[McOrist]

My round 22 team:

B: T Goldsack H Schade L Dunn
HB: M Scharenberg S McLarty L Mackie
C: J Aish T Adams J Thomas
HF: T Broomhead M McCarthy T Langdon
F: B Crocker E McGuire T Phillips
R: B Grundy B Sier
Ro: C Brown
Int: M Lynch J Daicos K Kirby J Blair
Coach: M Malthouse

This is based on my prediction that the entire senior squad and coaching staff that were in Adelaide for the round 21 game v Port Power will come down with cryptosporidosis and diarrhoea from drinking the Adelaide water.

Note:
Scharenberg , Aish , Broomhead and Grundy are all fit to play -being from Adelaide, they have a natural immunity to the water .
Taylor Adams is available to play, having completed his 20 week suspension for striking Bob Murphy in round 1.
E McGuire made a "Captain's call" and named himself at full forward. Just the man we need in a crisis.
M Malthouse to step in and help out his good mate Bucks.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

You

You've made that very clear, you never mention why though it's always I'm cool with Buckley then some deflection followed by a jab at supporters merely questioning the great man.

Is that right? A jab you say?
Ok then, perception is interesting.
But thank you for your concern

 

[mike123]

Is that right? A jab you say?
Ok then, perception is interesting.
But thank you for your concern

No worries

 

[THATSGOLD]

So this thread is about your prediction for what the team will look like by round 22. Of course it will depend on where you think we will be as a club. My selection is based on the scenario that we miss finals and have an interim coach. I have included an injury list of players I feel will be unable to finish the year. I have also included a VFL list of players who may either be too old, still developing or delist potentials.

B: Howe Keeffe Ramsay
HB: Scharenberg McLarty Maynard
C: Aish Treloar Sidebottom
HF: Fasolo Mayne Crisp
F: Brown Moore Daicos
Foll: Grundy Pendlebury Treloar
Int: Adams De Goey Smith Hoskin-Elliott

Inj: Reid, Wells, Varcoe, Broomhead, Sinclair, Elliott, Langdon

VFL: Goldsack, White, Blair, Dunn, Greenwood, Oxley, Phillips, Crocker, Kirby, Wills, Sier, Cox, Schade (sorry TG), Thomas, McCarthy, Mackie, Lynch.

So you are saying Goldsack White Blair Dunn Greenwood are past it.

 

[THATSGOLD]

I'll be surprised if Hoskin Elliott can get through the whole year uninjured.

 

[doodles98]

I'll be surprised if Hoskin Elliott can get through the whole year uninjured.

so are you saying he's a big dud?