Round 3 Captain Selections

[catters078]

What about Fyfe as a unique pick?

in Subi v the lions who arent really accountable vs midfielders.

 

[J Squad]

Going Andy Swallow - cats dont tag that well without Lingy, Swallow still scored 128 last week even though he hardly got a touch compared to heaps of others.
Praying Heath Hocking does a number on GAJ. Wellingham to get either Judd or Murphy (probably Murphy)

Hmmm, I wonder who blanketed Mitchell after half time?

 

[dlanod]

What about Fyfe as a unique pick?

in Subi v the lions who arent really accountable vs midfielders.

Too late now, but we did bring in Raines who's our designated tagger.

More likely to go to Hill than Fyfe though, you'd imagine.

 

[Starlin Castro]

Went with Goddard, supposedly raining at GC tomorrow night and a POD could work here.

 

[SaintsManMat]

i bet those who took Pendlebury as their captain are happy 2nite

 

[toxic]

Hmmm, I wonder who blanketed Mitchell after half time?

Hmmm, if I recall Mitchell scored 140 odd, I reckon most would take that from a captain..

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

hahah dude at work...top 20....pendles captain!

hahahah sucked in

 

[Jbomb967]

Picked Ablett as my first player in Feb, set him as captain and promised myself I wouldn't change for the whole season. With 5 mins before lock out, changed to Pendles because he scored well in a tough game against the hawks. Then changed back to Ablett with 1 min before lock out in sticking to my promise (not to mention the suns get pumped every week and he still scores over 120 consistently)... Happy days!

 

[Ducky Tie]

Hmmm, if I recall Mitchell scored 140 odd, I reckon most would take that from a captain..

Did you even read his/her's post? Quite clearly they said "I wonder who blanketed Mitchell after half time?". Mitchell had 23 disposals at half time before Geelong put Taylor Hunt on him(I'm quite sure it was him but not 100% sure). Mitchell then only had 7 disposals in the second half. Therefore Geelong can tag well without Ling.

 

[Escobar123]

Went with Pendles

From now on GAJ perma captain every week

 

[toxic]

Did you even read his/her's post? Quite clearly they said "I wonder who blanketed Mitchell after half time?". Mitchell had 23 disposals at half time before Geelong put Taylor Hunt on him(I'm quite sure it was him but not 100% sure). Mitchell then only had 7 disposals in the second half. Therefore Geelong can tag well without Ling.

Yes I read the post, so if I take your theory, stan magro tagged Kevin bartlett well, for 90 mins magro held him, shame he kicked 7 goals in the other 20 mins. Tagging effectively is a 4 qtr job, like carazzo did last nite.

 

[IDIG]

GAJ against my boys which I'm not particularly comfortable with but pendles proved last night why only one man can be trusted.

On a sidenote one of the sce boys in my league had pendles as skipper. Ouch!

 

[Ed_Gein]

Have both Ablett and Pendles, but seriously considering Deledio against the Dees. Scored 140 odd last week in a loss against the Pies. 150+ wouldn't surprise this week.

i considered deledio as a great unique option. but left it on ablett. hate taking it off him as it more than likely ends up in me getting burnt.

 

[Ducky Tie]

Yes I read the post, so if I take your theory, stan magro tagged Kevin bartlett well, for 90 mins magro held him, shame he kicked 7 goals in the other 20 mins. Tagging effectively is a 4 qtr job, like carazzo did last nite.

Again your not reading the posts. Taylor Hunt was not on Mitchell before half time. Mitchell was never on top of Hunt. I'm not disputing he had a great first half, but in the first half, he was head to head with a cats mid. Also, by your logic, Bartel didn't do a good job on Lenny in the 09 grand final because he didn't beat him all four quarters even though Bartel wasn't on Lenny for the first quarter when Lenny was dominating.

 

[fairdinkum]

Only seven people (incl me) went with Goddard?

Could be my week this week...

 

[warney7]

Had locked in Ablett, but then right at the last minute I looked that stupid supercoach preview thread and changed to Pendlebury.

Brilliant, an absolute effing masterstroke!

 

[Super Hans]

I'm the only person who went Boyd (and over Gazza, risky!), c'mon Matty! Return the faith!

 

[Double the Fist]

Had locked in Ablett, but then right at the last minute I looked that stupid supercoach preview thread and changed to Pendlebury.

Brilliant, an absolute effing masterstroke!

LOL @ your pain

I think I went Sandilands actually instead of Lids

 

[ThePezDispenser]

haha, Pendles worst score since round 17 2008.

Very stiff for those that had him captain.

 

[warney7]

haha, Pendles worst score since round 17 2008.

Very stiff for those that had him captain.

I'm glad I can feel a part of this rare 'achievement'

 

[NSWCROW]

This guy......

 

[MightyMark]

This is why I perma Captain Ablett!

 

[Shade]

This is why I perma Captain Ablett!

Yup

never change it

 

[shurg123]

I need to punish myself in someway for putting Stanton captain over Ablett. Any suggestions? Major SC nerd rage going on at the moment, don't think I'll even get to 2k...

 

[MattAKA]

I'm the only person who went Boyd (and over Gazza, risky!), c'mon Matty! Return the faith!

140 not to bad if ablett didnt exist