AFLW Round 3 Discussion - 2020 AFLW season - Teams in OP

Clems Knee

Norm Smith Medallist
Aug 15, 2009
7,826
14,731
Perth
AFL Club
Fremantle
Fair but I don't think you can justify listing 4 or 5 of your best 5 from the game as being from the losing side.
With the defender balance I agree but then Bowers shouldve been up there.
One of the coaches gave all his votes to players from the losing side. The other coach only chose Hayley Miller as the third best player and the rest from the losing side.
Meanwhile, Seth from Fremantle made it into the Team of the Week.
 

GC2015

Club Legend
May 27, 2013
1,580
1,688
AFL Club
Gold Coast
Coach Votes - Leaderboard
30. Jaimee Lambert (COLL)
22. Jamie Stanton (GCFC)
21. Ebony Marinoff (ADEL)
20. Madison Prespakis (CARL)
18. Kate Lutkins (BL)
Does this mean Jamie Stanton is likely sitting in second place for the league best and fairest award right now?
 

Teen Wolf

Club Legend
Jul 5, 2011
2,810
4,164
Melbourne
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Rancho Carne Toros
Does this mean Jamie Stanton is likely sitting in second place for the league best and fairest award right now?
With AFLW umpires, who knows. Below is the top 10 or so finishers in the coaches' votes from the last two years (don't think they did it in 2017), and in brackets is how that player performed in the league B&F.

2019
1st: Phillips (1st, 19 votes)
2nd: Bowers (=4th, 7 votes)
3rd: Marinoff (=12th, 5 votes)
4th: Conti (=4th, 7 votes)
5th: Paxman (3rd, 8 votes)
6th: Prespakis (=12th, 5 votes)
=7th: Blackburn (=7th, 6 votes)
=7th: Hooker (2nd, 11 votes)
9th: Bruton (=7th, 6 votes)
=10th: Davey (=7th, 6 votes)
=10th: Kearney (=21st, 3 votes)

2018
=1st: Kearney (1st, 14 votes)
=1st: Randall (=5th, 6 votes)
3rd: Blackburn (=5th, 6 votes)
4th: Lutkins (=29th, 2 votes)
5th: Hooker (=2nd, 9 votes)
6th: D. Pearce (=5th, 6 votes)
7th: Gum (=2nd, 9 votes)
8th: Frederick (=5th, 6 votes)
=9th: K. Antonio (=29th, 2 votes)
=9th: O'Dea (=29th, 2 votes)
11th: E. Antonio (did not poll any votes)
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

GC2015

Club Legend
May 27, 2013
1,580
1,688
AFL Club
Gold Coast
With AFLW umpires, who knows. Below is the top 10 or so finishers in the coaches' votes from the last two years (don't think they did it in 2017), and in brackets is how that player performed in the league B&F.

2019
1st: Phillips (1st, 19 votes)
2nd: Bowers (=4th, 7 votes)
3rd: Marinoff (=12th, 5 votes)
4th: Conti (=4th, 7 votes)
5th: Paxman (3rd, 8 votes)
6th: Prespakis (=12th, 5 votes)
=7th: Blackburn (=7th, 6 votes)
=7th: Hooker (2nd, 11 votes)
9th: Bruton (=7th, 6 votes)
=10th: Davey (=7th, 6 votes)
=10th: Kearney (=21st, 3 votes)

2018
=1st: Kearney (1st, 14 votes)
=1st: Randall (=5th, 6 votes)
3rd: Blackburn (=5th, 6 votes)
4th: Lutkins (=29th, 2 votes)
5th: Hooker (=2nd, 9 votes)
6th: D. Pearce (=5th, 6 votes)
7th: Gum (=2nd, 9 votes)
8th: Frederick (=5th, 6 votes)
=9th: K. Antonio (=29th, 2 votes)
=9th: O'Dea (=29th, 2 votes)
11th: E. Antonio (did not poll any votes)
Thanks for the context. That clearly shows the correlation isn't very strong. I'm just hoping the fact that Stanton is a midfielder allows her to get a lot of the votes.
 

Top Bottom