Round 3 Trades

[Hazey1977]

Just wondering what people's thoughts on trading Meeson for the Trent West? Would make some cash on the trade and then with West playing could become a cash cow.

Does Meeson look like getting a game at all?

Full of bl88dy questions today arent I!

 

[fraser25]

Just wondering what people's thoughts on trading Meeson for the Trent West? Would make some cash on the trade and then with West playing could become a cash cow.

Does Meeson look like getting a game at all?

Full of bl88dy questions today arent I!

dont see why not.

 

[adam1302]

Top rookies to date are

Cyril Rioli
Ryan Gamble
Chris Masten >>> I dont care what people say when you can get the ball like he does he will bea star.
Rhys Palmer
Chris Mayne
Nathan Brown
Josh Hill
Jarryn Geary
Darren Pfeiffer
Cameron Stokes
Matthew Stokes

am not sure on some of the following
Kieran Jack
Heath Grundy
Kurt Tippet
Shaun Hamposn

I would also add Scott Selwood to this list

 

[speaknoevil]

Just wondering what people's thoughts on trading Meeson for the Trent West? Would make some cash on the trade and then with West playing could become a cash cow.

Does Meeson look like getting a game at all?

Full of bl88dy questions today arent I!

It is probable that West will be dropped when Ottens is fit. There are question marks over when this will be, but West might only get one or two more games before he spends a decent spell in the two's.

Top rookies to date are

Cyril Rioli
Ryan Gamble
Chris Masten >>> I dont care what people say when you can get the ball like he does he will bea star.
Rhys Palmer
Chris Mayne
Nathan Brown
Josh Hill
Jarryn Geary
Darren Pfeiffer
Cameron Stokes
Matthew Stokes

am not sure on some of the following
Kieran Jack
Heath Grundy
Kurt Tippet
Shaun Hamposn

Do you mean top rookies for the future? I haven't seen anyone question Masten on ability, I certainly am not, but rather his current body for AFL level this season. On debut scored 26 points and was dropped.

Almost certainly a star for the future, but I am not sure for this season (i hope I am wrong though!).

BTW Matthew Stokes is a third year player so probably shouldn't be on your list - although he has been great so far this season.

I would add H Taylor on the list also after 90pts on debut.

[edit] Cale Morton has also been decent in his first two games

 

[Bourne]

Out: Mackie, A Edwards
In: Mattner, Porplyzia

Its done and dusted, but thoughts anyway?

 

[SJ]

Ha Matthew Stokes a rookie. Try premiership player and 23-year-old.

 

[Alistair]

OUT: Charlie Gardiner, Nathan Jones
IN: Josh Hill, Luke Power

 

[Ricketts]

Traded Brent Reilly for Travis Tuck. Seemed fairly logical.

 

[beekieboy]

I would like anyones thoughts on who i should trade for andrew raines?
i have 309k in my salary cap plus raines' value which means i can get any backman that i would like.

My original thoughts were to get milburn and hav a bit of money spare for other trades but im not sure

anyone have suggestions???

 

[sdsdsdsd]

Kieran Jack is better than rioli, hes an absolute gun also craig bird and travis tuck

 

[Carlton Kid]

IN: Abblett, Hill

OUT: Monfries, Sherman

 

[Turmoil]

Thoughts on Aaron Edwards?

I have him and am having a hard time not grabbing Hill for him. Should I or shouldnt I?

First trade so far and no plans to make any more in the near future *touch wood*

 

[beekieboy]

Im thinking of trading Andrew Raiines for Michael Osbourne??

Will Osbourne continue his form??

Any suggestions?

 

[C-Dog]

i got woonarmeeri in on the bench thoughts?

 

[speaknoevil]

Kieran Jack is better than rioli, hes an absolute gun also craig bird and travis tuck

I'll have to keep an eye on him sd (jack). That's a big rap as I think Rioli is real class. It's always good to see new guns appear, especially ones with a story like his.

 

[OneEyedHawk]

Im thinking of trading Andrew Raiines for Michael Osbourne??

Will Osbourne continue his form??

Any suggestions?

I don't think so. Maybe am being overly sceptical but Ozzie has played some good individual games in the past, and has always struggled to sustain it.

Up to you...I wouldn't.

 

[Yoda_]

Do people think that hill will really keep his form up this year. am skeptical to pick him though i have JEtta on the pine. Looks like real value but with the price rise due am not sure whether i can get him now.

 

[adam1302]

thinking of trading simmonds or putting him on the bench and bringing kruezer on,

anyone else thinking of trading simmonds he is scoring terrible.

 

[alternatevista]

I don't think Simmonds is playing that badly. I think over the season he should be able to improve his disposal accuracy up to around the 70pt mark. Which isn't bad for the $200,000 odd he cost.