Round 4: Changes Vs Eagles (DERBY TIME)

[tonygeeks]

We can’t drop Banfield. Came into the middle, in his position and kept us in it. Play him in the guts ffs.

Aye he really lifted in the 2nd half , most of the young guys did

I'd probably look at Tucker before him


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Scham]

Ross already putting it down as a loss...

 

[Farrand]

Ross already putting it down as a loss...
View attachment 650090

That's what you want to see

 

[tonygeeks]

I'd give Fyfe at least the next 2 games off. You only have one brain and it is kind of important.

Rubbish I've got on just fine without 1 ,they just get in the way really


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Square Peg]

Darcy will be back won't he? Tabs would be nervous, he would be next tall in line.
Out Banfield and in whoever, anyone, I'd play any other single player on the list, even the crippled ones, ahead of him.
Brayshaw was awful but you can't hide the kid from next week, give him the challenge and back him in

 

[muzzington]

Fyfe's out but we're primed to hit this game hard!

 

[bushchook]

Surely Giro is next in line for mids. Was good in JLT and been emergency every week.

I realise Darcy was only "managed" but realistically we were a better team today for him not being there. He offers very little around the ground and Lobb showed today why that's important.

 

[MrDanggazz]

Is this a new report?

apologises Allikat not very good with bigfooty but in the usual "who starred for your club in the reserves" article on the AFL website they say he suffered a hip injury.

 

[rgauci]

Out: Fyfe (good evidence that concussion lasts 8-10 days at which point the brain remains very vulnerable)
In: Switta

Switta replaces Banfield up front and Banfield goes into the middle.

 

[apuchar]

out- Hughes in Nyhuis
out Hughes- in Nyhuis
out Hughes- in Nyhuis

 

[bushchook]

Out: Fyfe (good evidence that concussion lasts 8-10 days at which point the brain remains very vulnerable)

Isn't it compulsory to miss a week if you fail a concussion test anyway? I don't think he could play even if he wanted to.

 

[Unique Name]

Brayshaw and Langdon's disposal was beyond awful. Brayshaw fumbled soo often. McCarthy's disposal was awful as well. Banfield been bery average for three games now. Lifted when played in his preferred role though.

Will have to watch again but the only reason the Saints were able to stay in the game was because we kept turning the ball over. I would say the majority of Saints scores were from turnovers and very little from stoppages/kick ins.

Fyfe should not be playing this week.

We need to improve our disposals and stop turning the ball over so much.

 

[tonygeeks]

out- Hughes in Nyhuis
out Hughes- in Nyhuis
out Hughes- in Nyhuis

Just the 3 changes then


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[TheInjuryFactory]

So this week it's ok to float Brayshaw?

Kid needs a run in the magoos to fix up his disposal.

 

[Taylor]

Isn't it compulsory to miss a week if you fail a concussion test anyway? I don't think he could play even if he wanted to.

It's not, but it might need to be.

 

[Alfonz]

IN: David Muir, Michael Brown, Josh Carr, Matt Carr, Troy Cook, Dean Solomon
OUT: Andrew Gaff

 

[Tom_Thumb]

IN: David Muir, Michael Brown, Josh Carr, Matt Carr, Troy Cook, Dean Solomon
OUT: Andrew Gaff

Yeah apparently he got some leather poisoning Saturday night.

 

[PapaJ]

We can’t drop Banfield. Came into the middle, in his position and kept us in it. Play him in the guts ffs.

Agree in principle, but he was also tanked. He stays, and plays middle more, I agree, but we'll need to work out who is going to do the grunt work for the bulk of the game.

 

[apuchar]

Just the 3 changes then


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

As long as it's those three.... don't mean to be awful but enough is enough. If the want another tall then Cox or else Nyhuis

 

[TheInjuryFactory]

Yeah apparently he got some leather poisoning Saturday night.

How regularly do you search for 'Andrew Gaff'?

Do you also cover the social media platforms?

Cool hobby mate. Do you and DanWA take it in shifts?

 

[FreoRicci]

Darcy will be back won't he? Tabs would be nervous, he would be next tall in line.
Out Banfield and in whoever, anyone, I'd play any other single player on the list, even the crippled ones, ahead of him.
Brayshaw was awful but you can't hide the kid from next week, give him the challenge and back him in

Why would he be? Competed well in the ruck. Two goals is handy. Could’ve had another. Darcy needs to really get gametime for Peel me thinks. His fitness and/or work rate can be improved there. Darcy lumping around and not offering much for us doesn’t help him nor the club

 

[Taylor]

Banfield was cooked in the forth, barely able to get out of a jog. Put a lot in previously.

 

[stax on the mull]

Fyfe won't get up for a six day break and maybe Banfield could do with a reset at Peel playing midfield.

I'd back the backline again with Hughes and Duman the junior players there and go for a young mid (North or Crowden) and another small forward (Switkowski or Shultz).

Probably need Darcy to ruck against Vardy (who had a great game against Grundy) and Hickey, which means one of the tall forwards has to go out - Hogan, Tabs or McCarthy.

 

[apuchar]

Banfield was cooked in the forth, barely able to get out of a jog. Put a lot in previously.

He looked horrible on TV. Did a bit better when he had a stint in the midfield

 

[Taylor]

He looked horrible on TV. Did a bit better when he had a stint in the midfield

There was one passage of play on the left half forward flank as the Saints were moving it out of defence and I thought I saw the St Kilda player start further from the ball than Banfield and beat him to it by a couple of metres to mark uncontested.