Opinion Round 4 Changes vs. Melbourne

[Kenny_01]

Tucker in for Hughes.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[DeanS]

Sutcliffe was very good in the WAFL too and really took the game on.

And has failed every time he has been brought back.

No changes. People calling for Hughes to be dropped don't realise how good this bloke could be if he was allowed to string a few AFL games together. He has a lot to offer. Don't fret about Tucker, he will get another chance. Just not right now.

 

[DudleyDocker]

And has failed every time he has been brought back.

No changes. People calling for Hughes to be dropped don't realise how good this bloke could be if he was allowed to string a few AFL games together. He has a lot to offer. Don't fret about Tucker, he will get another chance. Just not right now.

Don't disagree with leaving the team unchanged for next week, but I (and many others) have put Sheridan and Crozier in the same bracket as Sutty - tigers at WAFL, pussies at AFL.

Sheridan and Crozier both proved me wrong last night, I'm hoping Sutty will as well at some point.

A few games at WAFL may be just what he needs.

 

[theGav56]

No need to write Sutcliffe off, but no need to rush him in. Right now he is behind Hughes and Tucker, and for good reason.

 

[Lach72]

Why would you make any changes? Giving Hughes one game is nuts


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[meima]

Definitely not this game , I would rest Johnson if he is sore , but he look million buck in the last quarter. Nobody should be drop , but nobody is safe if they don't put in effort like yesterday .

 

[picko]

Firmly in the don't drop Hughes camp. Couple of shockers, but thought he did some really good things too.

 

[Superkoops]

Sutcliffe had a dip for Peel and defended well. Even late in the last he put in a big solo effort to spoil a certain mark and then followed up with a crunching front on tackle which went unrewarded and weight numbers saw Subi kick the sealer. But he was still a little untidy with his skills. A few handballs I saw either lead to turnovers or put teammate under pressure. I think a week or two further in the WAFL will do him some good while the youngsters get a bit more taste.

The two I'd look at would be Tucker and Tabs. It will be a case of team balance as to whether they come in or not. The MCG suits a taller fwd line. It will be hard to make changes.

 

[meima]

Sutcliffe had a dip for Peel and defended well. Even late in the last he put in a big solo effort to spoil a certain mark and then followed up with a crunching front on tackle which went unrewarded and weight numbers saw Subi kick the sealer. But he was still a little untidy with his skills. A few handballs I saw either lead to turnovers or put teammate under pressure. I think a week or two further in the WAFL will do him some good while the youngsters get a bit more taste.

The two I'd look at would be Tucker and Tabs. It will be a case of team balance as to whether they come in or not. The MCG suits a taller fwd line. It will be hard to make changes.

I will take tab as emergency, I need to see how peel play without tab , especially strnadica as a forward.

 

[noise36]

I would like to see tabs in... But also no changes otherwise.

Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk

 

[theGav56]

I will take tab as emergency, I need to see how peel play without tab , especially strnadica as a forward.

That is the worst reason for taking a player that I have ever heard.

The best thing for Fremantle is to either play Taberner, or leave him to play at Peel. That is the best thing for Taberner as well.

 

[meima]

That is the worst reason for taking a player that I have ever heard.

The best thing for Fremantle is to either play Taberner, or leave him to play at Peel. That is the best thing for Taberner as well.

Just my opinion , don't take it too seriously, can always swap at last minute with emergency based on what Ross think . Who would you take then? Collins ? Tucker? Or Griffin

Tab , Collins tucker all can go and visit their family but only one will make the trip.

 

[Sweetback]

No Gawn, Lewis or Hogan for the dees.

 

[Admiral Byng]

Out: Owen
In: Juan

 

[electricfeel]

No changes

 

[Alfonz]

It would be silly to drop any of the new inclusions. I personally would be happy to bring Tucker in for Spurr, but Spurr played OK and don't really see any changes being made.

 

[johnnomac]

Out: Owen
In: Juan

Juan for this week only. Next week it will be Desmond.



... as in Tutu.

 

[masai]

Why would you make any changes? Giving Hughes one game is nuts


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

After watching the replay, I can now see that Hughes did ok.

Unless the whippersnappers do bugger all, they should get at least 2 - 3 games to build their confidence up.

Why change for changes sake ?.

 

[TheMcManusNose]

Nah no changes.

Back Hughes, Balic and Logue to improve and give them more game time. Tucker can keep building, he will be back soon enough.

 

[Talking Dockers]

No Changes. this side barring injuries should be given at least 3-4 games. Tucker and Tabs need to keep racking up big N0's to force their way in.

 

[Purple dynamite]

Look guys and gals, as a rep of the darcy tucker support crew. Darcy was throwing lasers in the peel game yesterday. Easily best of field, including upping his tackle rate by infintity. This effort needs to be rewarded. The pressure needs to be maintained. Put him in!

 

[Unique Name]

No Gawn, Lewis or Hogan for the dees.

Potentially Vince out too.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2017-04-09/vince-nailed-after-having-foot-stomped-on

 

[electricfeel]

Potentially Vinve out too.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2017-04-09/vince-nailed-after-having-foot-stomped-on

View attachment 355475

That makes me squirm like crazy.

 

[Grape Bear]

As Sutty's old buddy, I must remind people how attacking he actually was up to early in 2015. Not sure where and when things started going wrong for him, but he's just been so down on confidence the last 18 months. I think a few weeks at the WAFL may be just what he needs to get his touch and his confidence back. Hopefully it gives him impetus to hold hard at it and force his way back in the way Croz and Sherro have.

Would like Tucker in, but for whom?

 

[Outshined]

Would be mad to make any unforced changes.

Hughes deserves another couple of games before he's in the firing line. Tucker will force his way back in eventually.