Trades Round 4 trades (aka We Need to Talk About Rocky)

[PAFC27]

Switch to Atkins > Stack since Gibbons has Gold Coast

 

[TedDougChris]

Also worried that Tuohy's return in a couple of weeks will impact Stewart's scoring as they will likely share kick-in duties which I think Stewart has been taking heaps of (and playing on a lot).

Ok, I’m going full on. Will get Stack next week....

 

[Cotchy9]

Would anybody be confident fielding Miers?

I’m doing this. Back to back 70’s and at home

 

[YippeeYiYeo]

Gibbons somehow holds his spot. Bailey Scott has to go.

Scott --> Stack.

 

[Cotchy9]

Setterfield to Schultz worth it? Would mean bring Petrucelle onto the field. Trade pockets 80k. Schultz -4 BE, Setterfield 27 BE

 

[Borgan]

which 1 of setterfield/drew/scrimshaw/clark to Rozee?

 

[Cotchy9]

which 1 of setterfield/drew/scrimshaw/clark to Rozee?

Setterfield I think. Highest BE and not scoring highly

 

[Fitzey]

Im so confused here, Parker/Setterfield to Rozee or Cousins to Libba? Heart is saying Parker to Rozee and bench Setters for a week but my mind is saying Cousins to Libba for a potential 40 point better outcome.

 

[Gunf]

Gibbons to Rozee via Setters dpp . Means Setters on ground in mid and Rozee on ground forward?

 

[happy_eagle]

With Scott to Stack locked in, what is the best way to spend or build on my $119k bank

1. Spending options
Sheed to Boak
Goldstein to McEvoy (playing the b/e game here until I get Gawn likely next week)
Williams to Milera


2. Building options
Goldstein to Mumford = $311k
Sheed to Liberatore = $247k
Williams to Rozee = $205k

 

[JADED]

Gibbons somehow holds his spot. Bailey Scott has to go.

Scott --> Stack.

Same here. Gibbons isn't great but barring complete disaster, will make more money than Scotts $0 this week.
B.E of 18 & G.Coast which are pretty much at his level (too good for VFL, under par in AFL)

Ahern has earned his stripes after being punished/banished to the VFL to work on his defensive game (was pretty good in JLT) so there's 1 less mid spot available at North for Scott.

 

[Fitzey]

With Scott to Stack locked in, what is the best way to spend or build on my $119k bank

1. Spending options
Sheed to Boak
Goldstein to McEvoy (playing the b/e game here until I get Gawn likely next week)
Williams to Milera


2. Building options
Goldstein to Mumford = $311k
Sheed to Liberatore = $247k
Williams to Rozee = $205k

I really want to trade Goldy but surely he will dominate O'Brien this week. Williams to Rozee looks good there.

 

[Anzac16]

Scott -> Stack
Balta -> Petrecculle

First trade is easy. Been tossing up every option but I think Balta needs to go. He could very well come out and make me regret it but I doubt it. Petrecculle looks the goods, prefer him over Miers personally. Rioli is still out for a fair few more weeks yet and Petra has been playing pretty damn well. Not that many forward rookie options I'm liking at the moment coming through so I'll spend the 95k and hopefully be able to recoup that in a few weeks from Petra. Leaves me 81k in the bank.

 

[Corby_4]

Same here. Gibbons isn't great but barring complete disaster, will make more money than Scotts $0 this week.
B.E of 18 & G.Coast which are pretty much at his level (too good for VFL, under par in AFL)

Ahern has earned his stripes after being punished/banished to the VFL to work on his defensive game (was pretty good in JLT) so there's 1 less mid spot available at North for Scott.

Plus Jed Anderson taking another mid spot and it's gotten bleak real quick for Scott, enough to trade him out.

 

[JADED]

With Scott to Stack locked in, what is the best way to spend or build on my $119k bank

2. Building options
Goldstein to Mumford = $311k

I don't mind that.
I built last week dumping Higgins and it was great to be able to go Smith to Whitfield this week.
Still $126k in the bank for much needed R2 upgrade.

 

[_Cayz_]

So I feel I've missed the Boak train. Could afford dunkley to Boak but I'm thinking dunkley to Miers and holding money in the bank to get Lloyd in next week.

 

[SloaneysDanger]

Bring in Miers or Petruccelle?

 

[happy_eagle]

I don't mind that.
I built last week dumping Higgins and it was great to be able to Smith to Whitfield this week.
Still $126k in the bank for much needed R2 upgrade.

I had enough to do Goldstein to Gawn yesterday but didn't quite trust the Preuss and Gawn setup
With Goldy likely falling in price (b/e 122) and Mumford rising (b/e 49) I can still do this next week if Mummy struggles

 

[Gunf]

Bring in Miers or Petruccelle?

Flip a coin . in saying that Petro has an easier match up the week

 

[Saints2001]

So, surprisingly Gibbons is named after all - that earns him a reprieve. Still got a trade left now - what about downgrading Laird to Z Williams? Laird is going to lose more $$ I feel, while Williams has some upside still, and I have Whitfield and Lloyd already, along with Brodie Smith, Clark and Duursma (bench is Wilkie and Scrimshaw - is it worth shifting Wilkie to someone better perhaps?)

 

[Anzac16]

Bring in Miers or Petruccelle?

Think both are good, I'm going Petruccelle. Hasn't had to kick as many goals to get a similar score. Think his JS is safe the way he is playing right now as well.

 

[Neale4brownlow]

Wow Gibbons saved.

Opens up too many options my mind can handle now with no other immediate trades needed.

1. Gibbons to Petrucelle still.
2. Balta to Petrucelle (costly).
3. Setterfield or Parker to Rozee and field him at F6.
4. Archie Smith to Zac Clarke for a playing R3.

So many options... impossible to decide....

..but whatever I choose I feel like its the wrong call. Can't NOT trade though..

 

[JADED]

Think both are good, I'm going Petruccelle. Hasn't had to kick as many goals to get a similar score. Think his JS is safe the way he is playing right now as well.

Petruccelle also seen defensive side chasing kick/mark late in game plus a late goal. Missed 2 gettable goals and gave 1 off last week. Could've been a much higher score.

 

[Aussie_boy]

Looking like:
Sheed > Libba
Scott > Stack

Frees up 200k for next week

Was tempted to go Dunkley > Newnes but I want guys playing tonight plus I feel like Dunkley can still come good.

 

[mitchzz]

Am seriously considering Rowan Marshall

Have I lost my mind?

Saints fans, will Lewis Pierce be back soon?