Trades Round 4 Trades

[mochacinolatte]

Hunter Clark is a fail pick cause St Kilda are mis using him. I am sitting on him this week cause Gresham is out and want to see if his CBA's improve.

 

[hoddo]

View attachment 1096975
Ranked 461, 29 trades & 77k

Option 1) Phillips & Kosi -> Heeney & Chapman leaving $400

Option 2) Phillips & Fyfe -> CJ & Chapman (moving Campbell FWD, Laird & Clark into mids) leaving 97k

Option 3) Phillips & Fyfe -> Impey & Chapman (moving Clark/Laird into Mids) leaving 141k

Option 4) Fyfe to Chapman

What do you guys think? I think I am leaning towards the more riskier option 2 or 3 compared to the safer Heeney. I do however already have 5 premo DEF with Lloyd/Whitfield to complete. However given scoring trends I could have Laird sitting in mids all year

Option 4
The Phillips trades seem a bit sideways.

 

[Barnzy]

View attachment 1096993

Which rookie do i cull for Chappy, thinking Sharp as Downie should play this week or next.

Sharp was last seen in school detention. Never to be seen again

 

[balmainforever]

So confused here. Need to move on JDG and Phillips.
Not sure whether to play Laird at M4 this week or not.
Rookie + Dunkley looking the right move.

 

[Hack_Watts]

Mostly solid trades mate.

Do you think Jelly is a massive mistake that should be fixed up to Ridley seagull apprentice?

That's 104 times.

 

[Scythe94]

Was going to hold off on trades this week, but just had a sneaky temptation to trade Phillips and Clark to King Gull and Waterman, which would leave my backs looking like this:

View attachment 1096914

It's so beautiful, but I probably shouldn't.

fu** it, doing it.

 

[Hai_Newman]

fu** it, doing it.

Absofeckinglutely.

 

[Kadog]

I dont think you can go wrong with either tbh.
I doubt either are year long keepers.
Id take CJ as imo its going to be harder to insure adequate defence coverage.

Good point. I’m warming more toward CJ if I’m honest but I keep looking at the value of Impey. Chapman the other I’ll bring in.

 

[go you pups]

Hunter is a failed pick at this point which is agreed. A trade to Chapman nets him $285k and injects a new cash flow.

As for J.Clarke, he is becoming a liability. He hasn’t quite panned out as hoped. Now has a BE 24 and set to make another projected 20k. Last score of 71 inflated by a crucial goal otherwise it would’ve been pretty average. You say he’s one good score to mooing to 400k, I say he’s another average score away of almost being cooked.
He’s batting 5 deep in defence so would I trade to Bowes, another speculative pick that could work?...or an ultra premo who’s averaged 123 over the past 3 seasons and already at a 121 clip to date? I dare say Macrae would be high on everyone’s get list so if you can afford him now, why wait? Get his points now and lock in a set n forget stud...but that’s just my opinion.

GenuineMatchWinner asked for opinions and can choose to ignore whom he pleases. That’s his call, not yours.

Agree Hunter is a failed pick

Jordan Clark is performing as expected imo and will bite many impatient coaches on the backside in a few weeks time when inferior rookies will have to be fielded in droves, read Bollox's round 4-5-6 theory here: https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/round-4-trades.1260973/post-69429213

If you expected a 85-90 average from him then think again, 70-75 from J Clark is more than fine to get to the byes at 350-400k.

As an example I remember when everyone jumped on Bonner like 2-3 years ago after a big round 1 score, everyone expected too much from him and he disappointed averaging about 60 since his round 1 heights, Clark is a far more useful prospect than what Bonner was back then and so far his scoring variance is excellent over the first 3 rounds, he's a far safer pick than most rookies at the moment.

Imo your advice was very reactionary hence I felt the need to give my 2 cents. Yes Macrae will get points, but slaying J Clark is not the right cow for it.

 

[ImissFrosty]

sharp
nice team dude.

Thanks dude, was just making sure that Sharp would be the consensus vote.

 

[Spanish Sahara]

Good point. I’m warming more toward CJ if I’m honest but I keep looking at the value of Impey. Chapman the other I’ll bring in.

Looks like we have similar trades

 

[Milanista28]

Are people moving on Neale?

 

[Bobber]

so I am thinking either of the below, any thoughts?

A: Phillips to Ridley
B: Phillips, Sharp to Tex and Chapman

 

[rocker_oz33]

Was going to this last week.

Berg to Chappy.
I need a Def.
Really no choice Highmore doesn't look like playing.


If Jones looks good I'll wait for him.
Or Nigel mansell.



I feel it abit of a waste swapping rookies around
Because they can't stay in the fooking team.

 

[buttox]

Good point. I’m warming more toward CJ if I’m honest but I keep looking at the value of Impey. Chapman the other I’ll bring in.

thats r4 every year. There is always a few that got away.
pick whats best for your team.
ignore the grey noise.
Impey has a scoring history of not being a premo. Could he revert to type?
Jiath is a break out. His average could be anything.
Id take the break out every day of the week.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

View attachment 1096990
So confused here. Need to move on JDG and Phillips.
Not sure whether to play Laird at M4 this week or not.
Rookie + Dunkley looking the right move.

Agreed, Dunkley/Martin and Chapman, Laird or Clark into the Mids.

Could do Atkins and Bowes if want to go mid-pricey.

 

[go you pups]

Doesn't look like Highscore is going to play. Wasn't mentioned by Ratten in his presser today and was playing in the Saints B side at training.

I would revolve your trades around him not being named. fu** you Aints

They lose a few more games and he'll be back

But yeah, seems Chapman will be a popular trade in this week, maybe Parks next week

 

[Hack_Watts]

With Young injured and Dow sucking a bag of proverbials, I'm bringing in Waterman and Hurn. Would prefer Ridley but don't have the cash.

Hopefully H2TYW likes sharing his toys.

 

[go you pups]

Hunter Clark is a fail pick cause St Kilda are mis using him. I am sitting on him this week cause Gresham is out and want to see if his CBA's improve.

So who's in the middle for them?

Steele, Ross and Crouch? Gresham was their point of difference as a smaller more nimble type.

Just get these vibes about Clark, don't worry, these 2 sucked a few of us in over the years too.

 

[Hack_Watts]

Hunter Clark is a fail pick cause St Kilda are mis using him. I am sitting on him this week cause Gresham is out and want to see if his CBA's improve.

+ 1

 

[mochacinolatte]

So who's in the middle for them?

Steele, Ross and Crouch? Gresham was their point of difference as a smaller more nimble type.

Just get these vibes about Clark, don't worry, these 2 sucked a few of us in over the years too.

View attachment 1097024
View attachment 1097025

Yeah Idk what to do with him, I might offload Clark for Oliver/Mithcell in a few weks when they bottom out. Just gonna use the next week or 2 and reassess their on-ball brigrade.

 

[ROOINYOU]

Nah, not for the trade to work. He has a breakeven of 34. I mean, I'm not confident. Do you think CJ will keep up this scoring?

i like CJ...can’t see any reason he wouldn’t be able to maintain his scores

 

[ROOINYOU]

With Young injured and Dow sucking a bag of proverbials, I'm bringing in Waterman and Hurn. Would prefer Ridley but don't have the cash.

Sloppy second rate defender there Joe.

 

[go you pups]

Yeah Idk what to do with him, I might offload Clark for Oliver/Mithcell in a few weks when they bottom out. Just gonna use the next week or 2 and reassess their on-ball brigrade.

Yeah fair play

If he averages 80 odd then he should still hold a low 400s price

Hopefully he doesn't go Jack Billings on ya and plummets to low 300s

 

[Gigantic]

I'm still holding faith for Hunter Clark but if he spuds up again this week and/or doesn't get many CBAs then I'll ship him off.