Round 5: Changes Vs Giants

[MrDanggazz]

have at it lads and ladets, Expect Fyfe to be back from a concussion and Hamling to miss with concussion.

IN: Fyfe, North, Valente
OUT: Schultz, Hamling, Wilson

 

[Farrand]

In: Fyfe, North, Darcy, Valente, Sturt
Out: Hamling, Colyer, Brayshaw, Wilson, Tabs

 

[serial_thrilla]

Hamling to get up.

In: Fyfe, North
Out: Hughes, Schultz

 

[Bastyy]

Hamling out so i think Wilson survives one more week

IN: Fyfe
OUT: Hamling

 

[Van_Dyke]

Out: Wilson, Schultz, Hamling
In: Nyhuis, Fyfe, Cox?

No obvious replacements for Hamling really seeing Cox is playing forward and Watson seemingly isn’t ready. Possibly bring in Carter or Sturt and force Hughes/Ryan/Duman to play taller.

 

[MrDanggazz]

Hamling to get up.

In: Fyfe, North
Out: Hughes, Schultz

I thought Hughes was good tonight

 

[Deathly]

Would Darcy's tank be ready yet to run out one AFL game?

 

[Bastyy]

Out: Wilson, Schultz, Hamling
In: Nyhuis, Fyfe, Cox?

No obvious replacements for Hamling really seeing Cox is playing forward and Watson seemingly isn’t ready. Possibly bring in Carter or Sturt and force Hughes/Ryan/Duman to play taller.

Can we bring in Carter? He's Cat B so we'd have to upgrade him to the mainlist and we don't have anyone on LTI

I considered him

 

[serial_thrilla]

I thought Hughes was good tonight

Duman takes his spot. Conca to go to the backline with Fyfe and North coming in.

 

[maka]

How schultz and colyer get games is beyond me

 

[Van_Dyke]

Can we bring in Carter? He's Cat B so we'd have to upgrade him to the mainlist and we don't have anyone on LTI

I considered him

I reckon Kersten could be moved onto the LTI, doesn’t sound like he’ll be back anytime soon.

 

[wayToGo_]

Let me guess? Out: Hughes

FFS some people should not be allowed to analyse football.

 

[Docker82]

Out: Matera, Hamling
In: Fyfe, Darcy

Not sure where to put this but Switkowski is more of a half forward for me. Seems to set up play for us very very well but doesn’t seem to have natural goal sense. I liked what I saw but just an observation.

 

[Midnite65]

Why is Hamling automatically out? Rockcliff played pretty well this week after concussion the game before.

 

[Scham]

Cox in for Hamling
Fyfe in for Schultz

 

[Ysaye]

In:
Fyfe,
Cox (to play back),
Darcy (was dominant all day in the reserves game)

Out:
Shultz;
Hamling;
Duman.

 

[wayToGo_]

Not sure where to put this but Switkowski is more of a half forward for me. Seems to set up play for us very very well but doesn’t seem to have natural goal sense. I liked what I saw but just an observation.

He is good at either. It was his 3rd AFL game and 1st game back since last year. Give him some time to settle in. He's a key piece to a functional forward line imo - but needs time to gel.

 

[Freo Big Fella]

Out: Wilson, Schultz, Hamling (inj - they're not going to muck around if it's a concussion)
In: Nyhuis, Fyfe, Cox (to play back)?

 

[PintofPale]

Hughes is interesting - is borderline 22, didn't have a great game but he worked damn hard and punched above his weight when Hamling went down.
Cox must be a chance to come in for Hamling?

 

[Jezzitizle]

Schultz topped our pressure acts, interesting to see if he holds his spot even tho he wasn’t great offensively. He’d do himself a favour if he converted his opportunities.

I’d be happy for them to keep him in and see how he goes.

Thought Hughes was solid too.

Let’s be honest, there’s nobody banging down the door to get into the team with our injury list.

I’m predicting only Fyfe possible in plus forced changes.

 

[Bastyy]

Thinking bout it now, wouldn't mind trying out some young blokes before we start having everyone come back in

Players like North/Valente/Sturt/Carter that will (more than likely) be behind the likes of Blakley, Hill, Bennell (In a perfect world), Logue, Fyfe, Hamling and Darcy when fit

 

[longsuffreosupp]

Out - Hamling (?), Schultz, Colyer
In - Fyfe (?) Crowden, North

 

[Heart Of Purple]

For this week -
Out: Wilson, Hamling (If not up for it)
In: Fyfe, Darcy

Worth having one more look at the 4 tall forward line? Wouldn't hold it against them to say straight no to it, but McCarthy's really not a tall (even 3rd tall).
Might free Hogan up a bit as well.

Having said that, I actually love the Tabs, Hogan, McCarthy combo, they just need to get more seperation. All good on a lead, Tabs can really clunk them and Hogans a real pack crasher, McCarthys the opportunist. Sooner or later we need to make a call for 5/6 rounds and stick with it though and I'd like to see us give the 4 pronged attack 1 last shot.

 

[wayToGo_]

The young guys at Peel are not ready (North, Valente, Crowden etc). Get on 7plus and watch the replay of the game today if you need convincing (assuming it will be there soonish if not already). Given how young the Peel midfield was I wasn't as critical as some others who watched - I think they just need time to refine some things at Peel before being considered for selection. We need Logue back so Cox can play forward at Peel - and both can bring AFL selection pressure. More importantly we need our senior players back from injury (Fyfe, Blakely, SHill etc).

 

[Square Peg]

Mumford will eat Lobb and Taberner for breakfast, Darcy must play. Darcy and Fyfe in, NFI who comes out. Colyer was poor but he played well prior weeks.