Round 5 Discussion

[TheOz]

Any Hawks fans know of Jed's chances of getting a game this week? One of him or NVB have to go for Krak this week, if Jed gets a game i'd be tempted to keep him

Not a Hawks supporter obviously but Puopolo out for two could help his chances. Could still be the starting sub though which might even be worse than if he didn't play.

 

[Dr Supercoach]

Not a Hawks supporter obviously but Puopolo out for two could help his chances. Could still be the starting sub though which might even be worse than if he didn't play.

The latest information I've seen has Puopolo fit to line up this weekend. Agree with the rest.

 

[PoopingHindi]

Any Hawks fans know of Jed's chances of getting a game this week? One of him or NVB have to go for Krak this week, if Jed gets a game i'd be tempted to keep him

he's really stunk it up this year so far. no idea how he went in the VFL last week but Hartung has looked much better when given the opportunity.
i reckon Whitecross might be a chance to play the defensive forward role if Poppy is out and Shiels is fit and will hopefully come straight back in.

honestly though i've got NFI. wait for Thursday (im guessing he misses)

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

Any chance that idiot Minson gets s game this week, I lost by like 30 last round, not happy.

 

[Double the Fist]

Any chance that idiot Minson gets s game this week, I lost by like 30 last round, not happy.

Pfft, I lost by 130. Tell your story walking punk.


srs

 

[stevebbb]

^^ why did you guys not trade Minson out?!

I reckon van Berlo is going to score 80-100 this week

 

[toxic]

Any chance that idiot Minson gets s game this week, I lost by like 30 last round, not happy.

^^ why did you guys not trade Minson out?!

I reckon van Berlo is going to score 80-100 this week

Minson ...No game
NVB ...sub or tags the chad

Lock it in Eddie

 

[stevebbb]

Minson ...No game
NVB ...sub or tags the chad

Lock it in Eddie

he won't be the sub, will probably sit on a player though

 

[Krujan]

he won't be the sub, will probably sit on a player though

Who would you trade out first? NvB: Ave 74 B/E 64 or Lang: Ave 53 B/E 32

 

[stevebbb]

Who would you trade out first? NvB: Ave 74 B/E 64 or Lang: Ave 53 B/E 32

absolutely no idea!
I'm in a similar situation, except with Heeney, Lang and VanBerlo
Heeney and Lang play Sat arvo, so I'll see if they start and avoid the vest.
Can see if I trade VanBerlo out, he'll score 100 and then have a BE of ~40

 

[Krujan]

absolutely no idea!
I'm in a similar situation, except with Heeney, Lang and VanBerlo
Heeney and Lang play Sat arvo, so I'll see if they start and avoid the vest.
Can see if I trade VanBerlo out, he'll score 100 and then have a BE of ~40

I have Heeney as well. So same decision as you.

 

[karaoke]

Who would you trade out first? NvB: Ave 74 B/E 64 or Lang: Ave 53 B/E 32

absolutely no idea!
I'm in a similar situation, except with Heeney, Lang and VanBerlo
Heeney and Lang play Sat arvo, so I'll see if they start and avoid the vest.
Can see if I trade VanBerlo out, he'll score 100 and then have a BE of ~40

I have Heeney as well. So same decision as you.

Ive got NVB, Heeney & Lang too.

I'm going Lang, reckon he has only got another 25-50k in him to make + not as good as cover as other 2.

Heeney might get that second wind we brought up yesterday - so he stays as a medium term play.

NVB is better cover than Lang ATM, but once I get some $$, will look to upgrade him.

 

[Faz 2000]

he's really stunk it up this year so far. no idea how he went in the VFL last week but Hartung has looked much better when given the opportunity.

Apparently he tore it up. Was listed as one of three dominant midfielders in the game. This is the frustration - and of course the reason so many of us have Jed - he seems ready to make an impact at AFL level but it just hasn't happened yet.

I am looking at the Krak/Tarrant double and I think those in the gun are NVB (mistake)/Jed (cos he's not doing anything)/Heeney (that 7 and... someone has to go).

None of them are awful, but I feel like I HAVE to get on Tarrant and Krak.

 

[Double the Fist]

Apparently he tore it up. Was listed as one of three dominant midfielders in the game. This is the frustration - and of course the reason so many of us have Jed - he seems ready to make an impact at AFL level but it just hasn't happened yet.

I am looking at the Krak/Tarrant double and I think those in the gun are NVB (mistake)/Jed (cos he's not doing anything)/Heeney (that 7 and... someone has to go).

None of them are awful, but I feel like I HAVE to get on Tarrant and Krak.

Jed may be a half decent downgrade option if he keeps this dribs and drabs appearance regimen.
From footywire
2015 Supercoach Stats
Round Price Score Value
1 $141,400 36 25.5
2 $141,400 55 38.9
3 $141,400 9 6.4
4 $148,500 - -
5 $148,500 - -
Gone up seven grand. If he cracks a whole game, will be tempting to take him. Krak forward and Ando in Mids.

Why Faz do you consider NVB a mistake?
He was pricey, but I got him for JS. Better than some other options. Would like to have some insight into that.

 

[Double the Fist]

Ive got NVB, Heeney & Lang too.

I'm going Lang, reckon he has only got another 25-50k in him to make + not as good as cover as other 2.

Heeney might get that second wind we brought up yesterday - so he stays as a medium term play.

NVB is better cover than Lang ATM, but once I get some $$, will look to upgrade him.

I have Lang to. Did he get subbed last week? He had very little impact, was at a lot of contests but never could get involved.
If he was subbed, maybe he will go instead of NVB? Bloody tricky situation.
If Lang wasn't subbed, then I will chop VB.

 

[karaoke]

I have Lang to. Did he get subbed last week? He had very little impact, was at a lot of contests but never could get involved.
If he was subbed, maybe he will go instead of NVB? Bloody tricky situation.
If Lang wasn't subbed, then I will chop VB.

Other games he's had 10+ disp (13,12,17) and at least 2 tackles.

Against Nth, 7 disposals & 1 tackle.

Reckon NVB will give you (& me) better coverage until we turn him into premium mid.

 

[Mullarkey]

^^ why did you guys not trade Minson out?!

I reckon van Berlo is going to score 80-100 this week

well for me personally, had Bartel, Deledio, McGrath, Gray to deal with that week - so Minson donut was consumed

 

[Double the Fist]

Other games he's had 10+ disp (13,12,17) and at least 2 tackles.

Against Nth, 7 disposals & 1 tackle.

Reckon NVB will give you (& me) better coverage until we turn him into premium mid.

Thing is, NVB is emergency with Lang. I have Heeney on the back burner because I dunno what is going to happen to him. Personally, I'm keeping Heen because I think he will grow soon, Swans will keep playing him. Just a gut feel of course.
Just a problem with who to trade out, Lang or NVB, leaning toward NVB as Lang can grow a bit more, and NVB is a little close to maxed out IMO

 

[karaoke]

Thing is, NVB is emergency with Lang. I have Heeney on the back burner because I dunno what is going to happen to him. Personally, I'm keeping Heen because I think he will grow soon, Swans will keep playing him. Just a gut feel of course.
Just a problem with who to trade out, Lang or NVB, leaning toward NVB as Lang can grow a bit more, and NVB is a little close to maxed out IMO

Based on current ave's, NVB has another 79k to make & Lang 46k;

Van Berlo-


Lang-



Not always accurate, but goes into the mix.

 

[Double the Fist]

Based on current ave's, NVB has another 79k to make & Lang 46k;

Van Berlo-

View attachment 129196
Lang-

View attachment 129197

Not always accurate, but goes into the mix.

DAMMIT KRK! Just when I have ruminated over it for a whole week and made up my mind, you do this to me? Why do you torture me so! My mind was soooo made up!

 

[karaoke]

DAMMIT KRK! Just when I have ruminated over it for a whole week and made up my mind, you do this to me? Why do you torture me so! My mind was soooo made up!

 

[SnappyHappy]

GC SUNS ✔ @GoldCoastSUNS
Rookie Josh Glenn has been elevated off the rookie list and will debut this Saturday: http://gcsuns.com/1DXT1rX #gcsuns

 

[SELFCONFESDAFLNERD]

I'm happy I jumped on WhiteX a week early so i can get both Tarrant & Krak in this round

 

[GOAUS!]

 

[james1995]

Clark and Heeney both out