Round 5 trades

[samFFC]

Fyfe stays.

Roberton -> Williamson tonight

then Cavarra or Georgie to SHill tomorrow.

Avoids a donut and still allows me to loop TBrown/McInerney in mids

 

[vast]

So do I trade out Noble or Brander?

 

[Red Syrah]

Currently carrying 4 non playing rookies:
B. Williams - emerg (traded out Xerri 2 weeks ago bc thought Williams had more chance of playing...)
D. Cameron - emerg
B. Davis - emerg (thought he played ok in R1)
I. Rankine - not listed as injured but who knows

Also have Noble and Brander and cannot avoid a donut without trading one of these idiots out,.

Who is least likely to get a game??? Or do I just move Noble on??

Good looking bench and still have Howe and Brander on the field....

 

[Loose at HB]

So do I trade out Noble or Brander?

I'm leaning towards Noble only because Brander has DPP and lets me play with more options next week pending rookies and other usual SC bullshit. Either way I plan to rid both of them in the next fortnight now

 

[Spanish Sahara]

Currently carrying 4 non playing rookies:
B. Williams - emerg (traded out Xerri 2 weeks ago bc thought Williams had more chance of playing...)
D. Cameron - emerg
B. Davis - emerg (thought he played ok in R1)
I. Rankine - not listed as injured but who knows

Also have Noble and Brander and cannot avoid a donut without trading one of these idiots out,.

Who is least likely to get a game??? Or do I just move Noble on??

Davis at least might get a game this week as hes on the extended bench. I think Rankine would be building up some fitness in the scratch matches.

 

[vast]

I'm leaning towards Noble only because Brander has DPP and lets me play with more options next week pending rookies and other usual SC bullshit. Either way I plan to rid both of them in the next fortnight now

Brander is injured so I think he goes first because of that. Plus they were saying he might get dropped anyway. Then again who knows he might make a miracle recovery like sturt. Gotta see the sunday teams first as I wanna make sure I have cover on all lines if possible.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

So do I trade out Noble or Brander?

Im surprised either were dropped TBH

 

[Shermy]

Whats broken with Brander?
as of 2 days ago he wasnt injured...

 

[Guardian Hawk]

Ha ha, like clockwork...

Fwd carnage 2 weeks ago with Whitfield, Dusty, Greene and Smith all out/injured.

Last week was mid carnage with Dunkley, Fyfe, Pickett and Bennell all out/injured (and Cogs a decoy).

This week is defence carnage with Howe, Noble, Brander and I've still got BZT as my loophole (cos I never have enough trades to cover injuries and trade him out).

Looks like I'm keeping Fyfe after all.

Also, just a heads up for next week, my rucks are Grundy and Pittonet. Trade them out before their injuries this week.

 

[vast]

Im surprised either were dropped TBH

Brander is injured apparently

 

[Spanish Sahara]

So do I trade out Noble or Brander?

I am thinking Noble of the two, purely as Brander has DPP.

Williamson vs Hill or Serong?

Stuck whether I should trade Howe for a premo def or dg to Hill or Williamson and bring in a premo mid instead.

 

[vast]

I am thinking Noble of the two, purely as Brander has DPP.

Williamson vs Hill or Serong?

Stuck whether I should trade Howe for a premo def or dg to Hill or Williamson and bring in a premo mid instead.

Im still looking to bring in Bont for Howe but its going to depend on Hamiil and Rivers getting a game.

 

[Loose at HB]

Brander is injured so I think he goes first because of that. Plus they were saying he might get dropped anyway. Then again who knows he might make a miracle recovery like sturt. Gotta seem the sunday teams first as I wanna make sure I have cover on all lines if possible.

This is true. Not really sure which of them has the better chance of coming back in either - gut feel says Noble but I'm also pretty stunned he was dropped after Howe died.
Agree on waiting for Sunday teams. If Rivers is dropped I basically have to trade one of Noble or Brander to Hill to avoid a donut and it probably encourages me more to trade Howe -> Ridley for the $$$ so I can dump the other of Noble/Brander next week. ******* campaignercoach

 

[Red Syrah]

What's the go with the Saints Butler - $413K? Already increased $180k and projected for another $54K.
NOt sure it can continue if he relies on the Saints winning...

 

[what a disaster]

Got quite lucky not having Howe/fyfe but a bit stuck what to do with Brander and Noble out. Original plan of not having to do much urgently but now in donut city.

Option A:
Brander/Noble > Ridley + rookie (Hibberd/Xerri/Mahoney)

Option B:
Viney/Noble > Hill + any mid premo under 620k (Titch/bont/danger)

Only concern with Ridley is that I dont rate him as a top 6 def, and with option B can move Viney on before he goes down a bit. But honestly absolutely no idea lmao.

Thoughts?

 

[Spanish Sahara]

Im still looking to bring in Bont for Howe but its going to depend on Hamiil and Rivers getting a game.

With Howe, Brander, Noble out and Rivers pending. I think I might need to do Howe to prem def and Noble to Williamson/Hill to ensure I have enough players this week unfortunately.

 

[DaveyBoy123]

So do I trade out Noble or Brander?

I'm trading Brander out. He's injured & Noble isn't. Noble just scored 72, while Brander went sub 50... So if they both get 2 more games, I reckon Noble makes more $$$.

Only reason why I'd go Noble out this week is if you need the extra $30k... Or you think the DPP will come in extra handy.

 

[vast]

This is true. Not really sure which of them has the better chance of coming back in either - gut feel says Noble but I'm also pretty stunned he was dropped after Howe died.
Agree on waiting for Sunday teams. If Rivers is dropped I basically have to trade one of Noble or Brander to Hill to avoid a donut and it probably encourages me more to trade Howe -> Ridley for the $$$ so I can dump the other of Noble/Brander next week. ******* campaignercoach

Seems he was pushed out by Varcoe. Not sure who else would be holding noble out but pies fans would know more than me.
varcoe seems a bit more injury prone too.

I think the eagles can cover brander more easily but who knows.

 

[DaveyBoy123]

Fyfe stays.

I think I'll go:

Brander > Williamson
Howe > Haynes

 

[vast]

View attachment 904627
With Howe, Brander, Noble out and Rivers pending. I think I might need to do Howe to prem def and Noble to Williamson/Hill to ensure I have enough players this week unfortunately.

Nice team. Hopefully Rivers stays in.

 

[Northernsoul74]

Doesn’t look like anyone is going to be able to bring Serong in this week due to other pressing issues.

 

[vast]

3 ******* trades would be handy right now. I swear its like the dont even consider it. ******* morons.

 

[Shermy]

Viney is out of my team and damn it looks better...
my fwds are weak but Whitty will be back in the team when he stops dropping in coin

 

[vast]

Doesn’t look like anyone is going to be able to bring Serong in this week due to other pressing issues.

Yep looks like its going to have to be Hill wether I like it or not.

 

[Spanish Sahara]

Yep looks like its going to have to be Hill wether I like it or not.

Not Williamson? Or have you already got him? Or pending say Rivers being selected