Trades Round 5 Trades.

[Dazjack]

Read this ....why don't people read this, is puzzling ?

Mod. Notice - SC Scoring / Game Info / FAQ / Helpful Links

Thanks to manboob, The_Steadier and krk004 for their contributions to parts of this. SuperCoach Workings: You can trade and substitute players, name your Captain/Vice Captain and change Emergency selections right through each round, up until the time of the start of their team's actual match...

www.bigfooty.com

Maybe a dedicated thread for SC manipulation? Not that anyone will read that either, but then you can really give 'em the rounds of the kitchen.

 

[kenneje]

In over 7 years of playing Supercoach, I've never felt this indecisive. I'm on the backfoot massively in my cash league and need to make some moves or I'll get left behind.

Have already gone Hinge > O'Driscoll

Have used 2 trades so far this year, so am thinking of being aggressive, using the trade boost and going;

Cripps + Gibcus + Hinge
Hewett + Brodie + O'Driscoll

Would massively appreciate some help!

 

[JuddgementDay]

In over 7 years of playing Supercoach, I've never felt this indecisive. I'm on the backfoot massively in my cash league and need to make some moves or I'll get left behind.

Have already gone Hinge > O'Driscoll

Have used 2 trades so far this year, so am thinking of being aggressive, using the trade boost and going;

Cripps + Gibcus + Hinge
Hewett + Brodie + O'Driscoll

Would massively appreciate some help!

View attachment 1374759

It feels like your chasing with those two trades.

If I was in your shoes, I’ll save the trade(s), keep Cripps, this week - take a potential loss and go hard in the remaining weeks.
E.g Grundy to Preuss, Rookie to Premo etc

 

[kenneje]

It feels like your chasing with those two trades.

If I was in your shoes, I’ll save the trade(s), keep Cripps, this week - take a potential loss and go hard in the remaining weeks.
E.g Grundy to Preuss, Rookie to Premo etc

Yeah I'm going to get minced in this weeks fixture, so not chasing is a solid idea.

Looks like Gibcus has better JS than I thought.

Thanks for setting me straight!

 

[Mateyman]

After a great deal of umming and ahhing, have settled on:
Ryan -> Short
Bowey -> O'Driscoll

I think they're the right moves, just can't be sure on Ryan's role any more. Next week can target JHF/Hinge/Berry/Rowell -> SP with the money.

 

[Haggus_89]

Any thoughts on what move I should make? Need to bring in O'Driscoll but not sure if I should dump Hinge or Sinn for him.

 

[Dazjack]

Any thoughts on what move I should make? Need to bring in O'Driscoll but not sure if I should dump Hinge or Sinn for him.

View attachment 1374807

If you have a spare 50K, you could move Sinn to midfield and drop Owens instead. Port are kaka, so Sinn probably gets a good run at it soon. Gibcus is a slow burner, but will play more often than not. Owens seems well out of it.

 

[SC fish]

Just traded in O'Driscoll cos FOMO

 

[Haggus_89]

If you have a spare 50K, you could move Sinn to midfield and drop Owens instead. Port are kaka, so Sinn probably gets a good run at it soon. Gibcus is a slow burner, but will play more often than not. Owens seems well out of it.

Unfortunately I was 4k short of being able to go Owens to NOD!

 

[Dazjack]

Unfortunately I was 4k short of being able to go Owens to NOD!

It is a horrible choice you face, in that case. If anything, I'd trade Gibcus. Hinge will be back, albeit he has several injury points, with the shoulder and the hip flexor, but his scoring power is much higher. I don't have Hinge or Sinn. I do have Gibcus, but he will go next week, along with my dedicated loop Worner, for Rosas and Kreuger. I am pretty happy to run with MacRae as premeditated C each week for a while now. He is just ridiculously good.

 

[TheRednWhite]

Well Rach spudded up when I needed him as Cripps cover (of course, he only tons on my bench).....so do I know trade Cripps to avoid Rach (E)? Can go Cripps to Doch via Hew

 

[JuddgementDay]

I've added NOD to my team bye bye C MacDonald

 

[jdeezy]

Well Rach spudded up when I needed him as Cripps cover (of course, he only tons on my bench).....so do I know trade Cripps to avoid Rach (E)? Can go Cripps to Doch via Hew

I have done exactly this, I also have Hall so next week I will trade him for a mid premo and move Hewett back, and I'll grab Cripps when he's dropped price a bit.


My trades this week ended up as
Stephens > Pruess (allowed me to put one of my Ruck / FWDs on field, sadly I chose Dixon over Hayes)
Ward to NOD (I reckon Ward has a spike game coming and will earn a bit, but I need the cash)
Cripps to Doch

Over the next couple of weeks I'll get Hall, Rowell and Marshall all moved on things should be looking good.

 

[DT_35]

Got some close cash league matches. If I don’t trade Cripps I’m no chance in any of them, if I trade him to Doch or Brayshaw this is what it’ll look like:

Doch/Brayshaw vs 17 and Boak

Doch/Brayshaw vs 79 and ward

Doch/Bray, Ridley, Hewitt vs 237 + SDK

Doch/Bray, Ridley, Hewitt vs Stewart and 205

Is it worth it?

 

[Claythesmiths]

Really considering sideways trading Luke Ryan to Sicily. Ryan's dished up 70, 156, 74, and 77 so far. Another score in the 70s and he'll lose too much value to consider trading and I'll be stuck with him. The fact that he's even capable of a 156 makes me consider keeping him though.

 

[SC fish]

Got some close cash league matches. If I don’t trade Cripps I’m no chance in any of them, if I trade him to Doch or Brayshaw this is what it’ll look like:

Doch/Brayshaw vs 17 and Boak

Doch/Brayshaw vs 79 and ward

Doch/Bray, Ridley, Hewitt vs 237 + SDK

Doch/Bray, Ridley, Hewitt vs Stewart and 205

Is it worth it?

You might only win one or two of those if you trade. Who is covering Cripps and could you put someone on field to replace him?

I'm in a similar position, I can either trade Cripps or take Rachele 49 or field Ward.

 

[DT_35]

You might only win one or two of those if you trade. Who is covering Cripps and could you put someone on field to replace him?

I'm in a similar position, I can either trade Cripps or take Rachele 49 or field Ward.

Yeh same deal here, except i have MacDonald also

 

[toxic]

Got some close cash league matches. If I don’t trade Cripps I’m no chance in any of them, if I trade him to Doch or Brayshaw this is what it’ll look like:

Doch/Brayshaw vs 17 and Boak

Doch/Brayshaw vs 79 and ward

Doch/Bray, Ridley, Hewitt vs 237 + SDK

Doch/Bray, Ridley, Hewitt vs Stewart and 205

Is it worth it?

You'll win 3 of 4

Ward is the match you'll lose imho

 

[Bayskiez]

Went to boost sideways trade Butters to Jackson last night after a few bevs before the bounce but got locked out. Trade boost kept and disappointment delayed. Come on Butters! I have no faith in your feeble frame now give us a one fiddy

 

[Battlepants]

Did you do it battle pants ...

Yeah I did it. Looking like my best trade ever right now

 

[Jiska]

+70~ points
+$$$$$$

 

[Sherman41]

Made my first 2 trades this weekend

Hough-Dixon
SDK-NOD

 

[JuddgementDay]

Made my first 2 trades this weekend

Hough-Dixon
SDK-NOD

Amazing and still competitive!

You’ll come home with a wet sail with so many trades left

 

[Gavin Excell]

Butters survives the axe

 

[Jiska]

Butters survives the axe

Of course he does. He’s locked now for Round 5