MVP Round 5: Votes vs Essendon

[Flawed Genius]

All in here

 

[gokangas]

I challenge anyone to name three good players.

 

[spongebucket]

I challenge anyone to name three good players.

Yep.... not going to give votes this week.

 

[DEVO]

I challenge anyone to name three good players.

3pts - Cunnington
2pts - Carey

No one else deserves a point.

 

[north_lad]

3 votes - Brad Scott (Ess)

 

[DarwinRoo]

3. Atley
2. Zurhaar
1. Tarrant

 

[treegreen]

3. Cunnington - Okay.
2. Tarrant - Well beaten.
1. Dumont - Poor and showed his limitations as a footballer.

 

[Silver finger]

3. People who watched whole game
2. People who watched up to the last quarter
1. People who watched up to the 3rd quarter

I gave up and went home at HT. So I've got no vote. Thanks.

 

[Bigeasy]

3. ANDERSON
2. CUNNERS
1. DUMONT

 

[DEVO]

Last year the Bombers killed us off half back - as other sides did - and this year they did the same. Yet Scott picked a side where our second ruckman - Zurhaar - looked most likely to crumb a goal and most agile at ground level. And that includes Turner.

This problem, of opposition sides just killing us off half back, is a long term one and it's Scott's to own. High quality small forwards like Walters of Freo are not just icing on the cake as Brad seems to think.

It's also very concerning how players like Ahern, Thomas, Simpkins and others seem to have had their natural instincts coached out of them.

The list is way better than it's performing - even with the small forward gap - but the players look completely devoid of belief in the Scott's direction and the side's balance.

It's obviously time Brad went and the long term assistants too and player development needs a big review.

Would have been a "like" worthy post in the Autopsy thread.

 

[Works atErrol St]

3. Cunnington
2. Atley
1. Hall

 

[roomagic1984]

I don’t feel like voting

 

[osaka mick]

3. Anderson
2. Atley
1. Thompson

 

[The Dingrel]

3/ Jed Anderson
2/ Wayne Carey
1/ the kid who tossed the coin

 

[Egga]

3 - Anderson
Everyone else can GAGF

 

[CunnyTarryn]

3. Anderson
2. Tarrant
1. Dumont
GTFO Turner, Thompson, Simpkin

 

[roos_fanatic08]

3. Anderson
2. Dumont
1. Atley

 

[Val Keating]

3. Anderson 10 tackles. Our next best had 4
2. Tarrant
1. Atley

 

[Harris 10]

Atley
Anderson
Dumont

 

[billnats]

3-Atley
2-Thomo
1-meh... maybe Jed for at least smashing for a few blokes

 

[Engimal v3]

3. Anderson - Only bloke who cared about stopping their run
2. Hall - Did some errors, but was at least trying to make plays
1. Zurhaar - Did what he could

What a disappointment.

 

[Marstermind]

No votes. These blokes get nothing.

 

[giantroo]

3. Jed
2. Atley
1. Cunnington

 

[Marstermind]

Can we give negative votes? Surely that was the worst game played by a NMFC captain in living memory. Maybe Boomer got totally tagged out of a game by Clint Jones one night but...yeah...nah...Ziebell

 

[The Nostradamus]

3: Anderson
2: Higgins
1: Atley