Discussion Round 7 Discussion (dedicated to Andrew Birch)

Status
Not open for further replies.

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Andrew Birch

Carnage Enthusiast
Dec 3, 2017
7,251
19,847
AFL Club
Melbourne
You can use my one week result of trading Goldstein > Ross (net me $350k odd to combine with my $200k odd), which gave me funds to go Sheed > Fyfe.

This can be cross analyzed on the basis of score breakdown below, which has me 35 points in front.

Round 7 scores:
Goldstein - 114 & Sheed - 98 = 212
Fyfe - 124 & ROB - 123 = 247

But this can also be analyzed in terms of the fact I now have $433k in the bank, which will allow me to go Drew > Westhoff, Scrimshaw > Lloyd and Duursma > Whitfield using just 4 trades (using one to downgrade Constable > Hately for $150k cash).

So the extra points i'd be netting from the likes of Lloyd, Whitfield and Westhoff compared to Drew, Scrimshaw and Duursma is also a flow-on effect on top of the points i'll be getting from Fyfe and ROB compared to Goldstein and Sheed. :thumbsu:
Maths isn't my forte, so I'm not sure how you got 433k upgrade money from doing Goldy & Sheed > Fyfe & ROB.
 
Last edited:

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Here2tellyouwhy

SA GREAT
Sep 3, 2005
28,143
71,276
Adelaide
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
West Coast Eagles
Hanley, Whitfield, Scrimshaw all out of my DEF.
No doubt it's classified as bullying in here if I trade one of those campaigners out. :moustache::rainbow:
Here2tellyouwhy would tell you to rub the balm onto Hurns' quads or Tom's Bareass.
Doesn't he already have that job all sown up?
He's rubbing something ...that's for sure
He likes to watch.
These posts are all reported for making me pants move

Back in 5
 

Better Loosen Up

Norm Smith Medallist
Jan 2, 2009
7,302
10,556
Melbourne
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Excellent discussion guys Andrew Birch .....if I had the want, I'd do a spreadsheet comparison of the different scenarios over the last 3 weeks (hint) ......but Andrew hit the nail, it depends very much on who you traded out & traded in

If you used ROB on-field to bring in Whitfield / Heeney / Seagull ....there's a short term analysis & longterm analysis to be viewed ....obviously the short term maynot have provided the advantage sought

However, as ROB keeps rising in price, the $$ gap required to get Gawn back in, won't be as great as anticipated

I still take the view ....ROB on R3, is great for my byes, & covers (saves trade) if there's an injury .......plus using ROB's $$$ during the bye, IMO will give me a greater advantage
I did the Goldy > ROB trade with ROB as R2.

I needed the money at the time to fund some team corrections which is working out well. My best case scenario plan at the time was to do a 1 up 1 down with Hore to get ROB to Gawn. Thought at the time i would be stretching it... now it looks like i'll even have change left over! :thumbsu:
 
Last edited:

gutsroy

Brownlow Medallist
May 12, 2013
14,877
22,531
Switzerland
AFL Club
Collingwood
I did the Goldy > ROB trade with ROB as R2.

I needed the money at the time to fund some team corrections which is working out well. My best case scenario plan at the time was to do a 1 up 1 down with Hore to get ROB to Gawn. Thought at the time i would be stretching it... not it looks like i'll even have change left over! :thumbsu:
Had the bullet in the chamber for that exact trade but held Goldy in the end.
You nailed it, absolutely nailed it.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

WaLkEr_ThE_StAr

Ultimate campaigner
May 8, 2004
4,721
3,786
Where you'd rather be
AFL Club
Carlton
Maths isn't my forte, so I'm not sure how you got 433k upgrade money from doing Goldy & Sheed > Fyfe & ROB.
I didn’t trade Goldy to ROB, I picked up ROB weeks ago when he was bottom priced.

My sums were slightly off from what I said, sorry. I had $350k from Goldy > Ross combined with $250k already in my bank, giving me $600k.

I then spent $167k odd on Sheed > Fyfe, leaving me with the $433k I now have. :thumbsu:
 

Andrew Birch

Carnage Enthusiast
Dec 3, 2017
7,251
19,847
AFL Club
Melbourne
Danger on SEN said he had scans this morning. Will get results later. Get your emergencies ready.

This could potentially mess up many C loopholes for those of us with Bines as their loophole doughnut in the forward line, especially with both Parker and Drew at F6 & F7 playing at the same time on Saturday night and Danger playing on Sunday. Might need to put forward E's on both Drew and Parker to avoid a possible Danger doughnut similar to what happened to some people with Marshall a couple of weeks ago and hope than one doesn't dish out a 30.
 

stevebbb

Brownlow Medallist
May 21, 2013
14,000
27,988
Melbourne
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Arsenal, Fluminense; Blue Jays
Danger on SEN said he had scans this morning. Will get results later. Get your emergencies ready.

This could potentially mess up many C loopholes for those of us with Bines as their loophole doughnut in the forward line, especially with both Parker and Drew at F6 & F7 playing at the same time on Saturday night and Danger playing on Sunday. Might need to put forward E's on both Drew and Parker to avoid a possible Danger doughnut similar to what happened to some people with Marshall a couple of weeks ago and hope than one doesn't dish out a 30.
I'll use Bailey Scott as my non playing loophole this week

E on Balta up forward!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top Bottom