Round 7 Trades

[pincrusher]

Thanks for the replies. Already traded Smith in this week so have just the one trade up my sleeve. Actually thinking of culling Sheridan, moving Brown back and getting Cox. Means I have to start Hartley on the field. Just realised I don't have enough cash to go M Crouch> Jelwood. $184k in the bank.

This is the way I ended up going. Might cost me a few points this week but will hopefully help in the long run. $391k in the bank for next week.

 

[Hairy Lager]

View attachment 244116

Any suggestions folks? Not sure whether to grab Cox or upgrade a spud. Could go Sheridan> Simpson or M Crouch> Jelwood or Rocky.

With your DPP ruck capability, I'd grab Cox.
McCarthy > Cox for me also.

 

[SC fish]

Parish or Davis to Smith? Thoughts?

I'm doing Parish but did think about Davis. I'd like the extra $$ for next week

 

[toxic]

I'm doing Parish but did think about Davis. I'd like the extra $$ for next week

Parish will be back and make more cash

Davis won't

 

[Changa10]

Parish or Davis to Smith? Thoughts?

Depends, do you want to make cash, or ditch a dud?

If you need cash trade Parish, otherwise ditch the dud

 

[Mercuri Rising]

so if someone was to sleep in past the pies/blues lockout, just hypothetically, and can't bring in smith or cox

which rookie do you take a punt on instead? keays? macpherson?

 

[Deliverance]

Both good trades, although I think Dea is the priority to move on so simpson.

Thanks, I owe you one.

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Cox dropped this week for Cloke? Sucks if you got him I think.

 

[stevebbb]

Cox dropped this week for Cloke? Sucks if you got him I think.

If Cox doesn't play vs Brisbane I'll be very, very, very surprised.

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

If Cox doesn't play vs Brisbane I'll be very, very, very surprised.

He has to go soon, he's a spud.

 

[toxic]

He has to go soon, he's a spud.

If we drop all our spuds we'd only field 4 players

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

If we drop all our spuds we'd only field 4 players

Haha!

 

[stevebbb]

He has to go soon, he's a spud.

Tries harder than most of our team.. I really hope Buckley persists with him

 

[Raveneyes]

He has to go soon, he's a spud.

Needs a good run of games.....

If we drop all our spuds we'd only field 4 players

...and this.

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Needs a good run of games.....



...and this.

You're too top heavy with him & Grundy.
Cloke has to come back in soon.

 

[toxic]

You're too top heavy with him & Grundy.
Cloke has to come back in soon.

What's the alternative?

Plz dont say Cloke as R2

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

What's the alternative?

Plz dont say Cloke as R2

Play 1 ruck and you would already be better off easily, with an extra runner in the team or someone that can actually play forward.

Surely big sook Cloke can provide a contest in there for 5 mins a quarter to give Grundy a rest.

 

[toxic]

Play 1 ruck and you would already be better off easily, with an extra runner in the team or someone that can actually play forward.

Surely big sook Cloke can provide a contest in there for 5 mins a quarter to give Grundy a rest.

Tried the cloke ruck option
Unmitigated disaster
We not only lose a fwd target but guaranteed loss of any form of a ruck contest

We must play 2 capable of rucking. Cloke is NOT that

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Tried the cloke ruck option
Unmitigated disaster
We not only lose a fwd target but guaranteed loss of any form of a ruck contest

We must play 2 capable of rucking. Cloke is NOT that

Not sure how you can argue the "lose a forward option" when Cox is keeping Cloke out?

You're currently losing a forward (probably your best still) for 4 quarters by playing Cox... Go figure.