Trades Round 7 Trades

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this ad.

GenuineMatchWinner

All Australian
Sep 11, 2008
838
639
Mornington Peninsula
AFL Club
Carlton
Okay need some help with some things.

21 trades and only $96,400 in the kitty...

Screenshot_20210501-121448_SuperCoach.jpg

Screenshot_20210501-125019_SuperCoach.jpg

Screenshot_20210501-121502_SuperCoach.jpg


Which trade would you look at this week?

Gulden > Robertson
Waterman > Farrar / Bosenavulagi

It's a shame I don't have my DPP link at the minute as I am bullish on Farrar especially but feel culling Waterman might be the wrong move. Any other suggestions welcome.

Also would you field Koschitzke or Chapman this week? This teams releasing a day before games is killing me.
 
Last edited:

toxic

Hall of Famer
May 9, 2008
41,233
57,012
GONE
AFL Club
Collingwood
Okay need some help with some things.

21 trades and only $96,400 in the kitty...

View attachment 1115851View attachment 1115852

Which trade would you look at this week?

Gulden > Robertson
Waterman > Farrar / Bosenavulagi

It's a shame I don't have my DPP link at the minute as I am bullish on Farrar especially but feel culling Waterman might be the wrong move. Any other suggestions welcome.

Also would you field Koschitzke or Chapman this week? This teams releasing a day before games is killing me.
I'd bring in 2 rucks tbh
 

TheRednWhite

Cursed Man
Jan 27, 2017
8,599
6,077
AFL Club
Sydney
Help me! What should I do with my last trade? Have $392700 in the bank

Initial thoughts are:
A) Rowe to Zorko/Sideass
B) Chapman to Hous
These options keep some money in the bank..

Or I can spend up a bit and go:
C) Rowe to Marshall
D) Chapman to Lloyd

Any other options I've missed? Please help...team is a mess

1619837746183.png
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

GenuineMatchWinner

All Australian
Sep 11, 2008
838
639
Mornington Peninsula
AFL Club
Carlton
Help me! What should I do with my last trade? Have $392700 in the bank

Initial thoughts are:
A) Rowe to Zorko/Sideass
B) Chapman to Hous
These options keep some money in the bank..

Or I can spend up a bit and go:
C) Rowe to Marshall
D) Chapman to Lloyd

Any other options I've missed? Please help...team is a mess

View attachment 1115882
I would ditch Brockman and go and get Farrar or Robertson for cash generation. Chapman and Rowe can wait a week and you could go 1 up 1 down next week to get rid of rookies. Just my thoughts on it
 

TheRednWhite

Cursed Man
Jan 27, 2017
8,599
6,077
AFL Club
Sydney
I would ditch Brockman and go and get Farrar or Robertson for cash generation. Chapman and Rowe can wait a week and you could go 1 up 1 down next week to get rid of rookies. Just my thoughts on it
Yeah I do like Farrar, but is it wise to keep 380k in the bank for next week? Don't think my team is good enough to pull that off. Farrar does have a nice matchup though and he is on the bubble...
 

GenuineMatchWinner

All Australian
Sep 11, 2008
838
639
Mornington Peninsula
AFL Club
Carlton
Yeah I do like Farrar, but is it wise to keep 380k in the bank for next week? Don't think my team is good enough to pull that off. Farrar does have a nice matchup though and he is on the bubble...
It is short term pain for 1 week to get rid of a dead rookie mate. Unfortunate that your side isn't super strong at the minute but long term cash gen is just as important as gaining an extra few points this week IMO. Who knows, Farrar might score a 90+ and similar to or more than the Premo you are wanting....
 

TheRednWhite

Cursed Man
Jan 27, 2017
8,599
6,077
AFL Club
Sydney
It is short term pain for 1 week to get rid of a dead rookie mate. Unfortunate that your side isn't super strong at the minute but long term cash gen is just as important as gaining an extra few points this week IMO. Who knows, Farrar might score a 90+ and similar to or more than the Premo you are wanting....
Alright I think you've convinced me. Farrar seems good, think he got shafted with his score last week, was better than a 59 imo. What about paying up a bit more to get Dev Rob?
 

GenuineMatchWinner

All Australian
Sep 11, 2008
838
639
Mornington Peninsula
AFL Club
Carlton
Alright I think you've convinced me. Farrar seems good, think he got shafted with his score last week, was better than a 59 imo. What about paying up a bit more to get Dev Rob?
I agree I feel he will be a good choice. I would lean towards Farrar over Dev just for role and price but feel both are good choices.

If you scroll up I have a similar issue I am trying to work out this week. I have to trade Waterman or Rowe if I want Farrar where I can trade Gulden to get Robertson...
 

TheRednWhite

Cursed Man
Jan 27, 2017
8,599
6,077
AFL Club
Sydney
I agree I feel he will be a good choice. I would lean towards Farrar over Dev just for role and price but feel both are good choices.

If you scroll up I have a similar issue I am trying to work out this week. I have to trade Waterman or Rowe if I want Farrar where I can trade Gulden to get Robertson...
in your case it's a bit easier to choose, definitely get Farrar. Gulden has a much better chance of going big than Waterman and Rowe. I expect Gulden to bounce back today, had a mare last week and I think he knows it
 

GenuineMatchWinner

All Australian
Sep 11, 2008
838
639
Mornington Peninsula
AFL Club
Carlton
in your case it's a bit easier to choose, definitely get Farrar. Gulden has a much better chance of going big than Waterman and Rowe. I expect Gulden to bounce back today, had a mare last week and I think he knows it
It taps me out for cash and feel Waterman will more likely be back at some stage... I like Gulden and wouldn't surprise if he bounced back but his scores have been spiralling down every week...
 

TheRednWhite

Cursed Man
Jan 27, 2017
8,599
6,077
AFL Club
Sydney
It taps me out for cash and feel Waterman will more likely be back at some stage... I like Gulden and wouldn't surprise if he bounced back but his scores have been spiralling down every week...
fair enough. I just think it is rare for a rookie to be capable of 130s, so on that basis I am giving Gulden another chance. I don't think he is capable of playing any worse than he did last week. Dropped like 5 marks by my count.
 

GenuineMatchWinner

All Australian
Sep 11, 2008
838
639
Mornington Peninsula
AFL Club
Carlton
fair enough. I just think it is rare for a rookie to be capable of 130s, so on that basis I am giving Gulden another chance. I don't think he is capable of playing any worse than he did last week. Dropped like 5 marks by my count.
That is also a fair call... I didn't see the game so I couldn't judge. Just know he could undo a lot of his good work if it goes wrong... I have no clue what to do 😂
 

toxic

Hall of Famer
May 9, 2008
41,233
57,012
GONE
AFL Club
Collingwood
Okay need some help with some things.

21 trades and only $96,400 in the kitty...

View attachment 1115851
View attachment 1115878
View attachment 1115852

Which trade would you look at this week?

Gulden > Robertson
Waterman > Farrar / Bosenavulagi

It's a shame I don't have my DPP link at the minute as I am bullish on Farrar especially but feel culling Waterman might be the wrong move. Any other suggestions welcome.

Also would you field Koschitzke or Chapman this week? This teams releasing a day before games is killing me.
Gulden to Heppell an option
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad