MVP Round 7 Votes v Fremantle

[Carbine Chaos]

5. Brad Sheppard
4. Josh Kennedy
3. Jackson Nelson
2. Liam Duggan
1. Tom Cole

 

[Lynch takes a mark]

5 Shep
4 Kennedy
3 Gaff
2 Kelly
1 Waterman

 

[TassieEagle]

5. Kennedy, if funds his radar a Coleman push is on the cards
4. Gaff
3. Kelly
2. Shep
1. Nelson

Lots of players in the mix for votes.

 

[The Stid]

5: JK
4: Gaff
3: Nelson
2: Shep
1: TK

HM: Yeo, Waterman, Redden, Duggan

 

[BlueandGoldforever]

5. Sheppard
4. Gaff
3. Nelson
2. Yeo
1. Kennedy

 

[AsterixTheGaul]

5. JK
4. Sheppard
3. Nelson
2. Duggan
1. Yeo

I want to give Cole at least a half vote for his goal line tackle on Taberner

Lots lining up for votes this week

 

[Dark Sharks]

Interesting reading all the votes compared to how i saw it at the game.

Seems i'm giving Naitanui more credit than most whilst i didn't really notice Nelson being outstanding like his stats suggest. Darling to me was meh.

Thought McGovern was good too. At the ground i'd score it as Naitanui, McGovern, Kennedy, Waterman, Sheppard, Yeo as being our best 6.


5. Sheppard
4. Naitanui
3. Kennedy
2. Yeo
1. Waterman


HM : Gov

 

[FreeTK]

Interesting reading all the votes compared to how i saw it at the game.

Seems i'm giving Naitanui more credit than most whilst i didn't really notice Nelson being outstanding like his stats suggest. Darling to me was meh.

Thought McGovern was good too. At the ground i'd score it as Naitanui, McGovern, Kennedy, Waterman, Sheppard, Yeo as being our best 6.


5. Sheppard
4. Naitanui
3. Kennedy
2. Yeo
1. Waterman


HM : Gov

I think many people (myself included) expected Nic to be on top of the ruck battle from start to finish.

If felt like Darcy was able to stifle Nic's influence early on and Nic didn't get on top until some time in the 2nd quarter. Nic did really well yesterday, but wasn't as dominant as he had been in his last two games, which is to be expected I guess.

Looking forward to Naitanui v Grundy next week

 

[kranky al]

Cbf voting this year - taken me this long to get into it but


If you dont have shep in your votes

just know that you are wrong....

 

[RookiePick]

5. JJK
4. Shep
3. Yeo
2. Nelson
1. Redden

HM - Gaff, Cole, Darling

Plenty that did their bit with the only real concerns being Bunga in general and the 1-1 efforts of Gov and Barrass.

If the forwards find their radar and the connection with the midfield continues to grow, we are going to start converting positional dominance into scoreboard pressure.

 

[donpyke92]

5. Kennedy
4. Sheppard
3. Nelson
2. Yeo
1. Gaff

 

[Agent93]

5. Josh Kennedy
4. Brad Sheppard
3. Jake Waterman
2. Jack Redden
1. Tom Cole

 

[DanWA]

5. Andrew Gaff
4. Nic Nat
3. JK
2. Liam Duggan
1. Yeo

 

[Luuuc]

5. Kennedy
4. Shep
3. Kelly
2. Gaff
1. Cole

(I couldn't leave Cole out of my votes after providing us with one of the all time great derby moments. The way the atmosphere was instantly sucked out of the stadium was amazing. Apologies to Duggan, Yeo & Nelson)

 

[shooshka]

Cbf voting this year - taken me this long to get into it but

View attachment 915527
If you dont have shep in your votes

just know that you are wrong....

How does he get 23 disposals from 22 possessions? A kick off the ground maybe?

I understand how he may be able to get more possessions than disposals, but the other way around seems odd to me!

 

[kranky al]

How does he get 23 disposals from 22 possessions? A kick off the ground maybe?

I understand how he may be able to get more possessions than disposals, but the other way around seems odd to me!

I didnt notice that

spud

delist

 

[Dark Sharks]

I didn't actually think that was possible

I know you can have more possessions than disposals (if you win a ground ball off the deck for instance), but i'd never seen more disposals than possessions

 

[flamingEMBERS]

5. Sheppard
4. Kennedy
3. Kelly
2. Naitanui
1. Gaff

 

[SloppyJoe]

5. JK
4. Sheppard
3. Kelly
2. Waterman
1. Nelson

 

[kranky al]

I didn't actually think that was possible

I know you can have more possessions than disposals (if you win a ground ball off the deck for instance), but i'd never seen more disposals than possessions

Soccer off the ground?

 

[Alesana]

What’s with all the Nelson hate?
Played a good game.
View attachment 915426
View attachment 915427

And gained 190 metres at 8.2 metres per disposal, really damaging stuff

 

[MrWoollie]

5. Brad Sheppard - especially when game still to be won
4. Josh Kennedy - if he'd kicked straight it would have been an easy 5 votes
3. Jackson Nelson - had a very good game with few mistakes. Lots of crossfield that genuinely opened play up.
2. Elliot Yeo - starting to ramp up
1. Andrew Gaff - boo you purple ****ers.

 

[fidstar]

5. Kennedy
4. Kelly
3. Sheppard
2. Nelson
1. Gaff

 

[WCE Wizard]

5 Kennedy - 4 goals and 8 shots at goal was awesome
4 Shep -
3 Gaff
2 Nelson
1 Yeo
HM Waterman, TK

 

[FreeTK]

Coaches votes are in. From the number of different people who got votes it looks like Simmo and the Dockers coach saw the game quite differently. JK with a perfect 10 in his 250th:

10 Josh Kennedy (WCE)
4 Brad Sheppard (WCE)
4 Andrew Gaff (WCE)
3 Elliot Yeo (WCE)
3 Matt Taberner (FRE)
2 Jackson Nelson (WCE)
2 Tim Kelly (WCE)
2 Luke Ryan (FRE)