Trades Round 8 Trades

[Nelso]

Frederick dropped

Never change Hinkley you muppet

How Hartett is not dropped is beyond me!

This campaigner will cost us a flag with his dumb selections.

 

[Deliverance]

****ed if i know now. Probably not. Git enough s**t rookies scoring 50s.

 

[Leeroy Brown 15]

So with Fredrick now dropped do we go Murphy or a week early on RCD? Murphy better JS and on the bubble but lower ceiling compared to someone like RCD who has the better scoring potentially but less JS. Tough one since I’ll have to field whoever I bring in. Also the off chance that Hinkley recalls Fredrick next week and if we don’t go RCD we’ll be left with a choice of either Fredrick or RCD since they’ll both be on the bubble and won’t be able to grab both

 

[Juzzomac]

Early thoughts after the Fredericks news is to hold Chapman this week - no (C) loop without him and can play Mansell tonight so no donut regardless.

The point benefits of a loop could easily be worth more points than the difference between Mansell and an upgraded D6 anyway.

Downside is no F6 upgrade this week - one of Rowe/Scott will need to be played.

Unless I go early on RCD which is tempting if Byrnes keeps his spot as a potential bubble rook next week, as he could be a decent playing rookie over the byes and would prefer him over a Murphy if he keeps his spot. However with everything that's happened this year, going early on RCD could be playing with fire.

 

[freddy mercury]

f’ed if i know now. Probably not. Git enough sh*t rookies scoring 50s.

Yeah I was thinking the same thing. Id rather go early on Dawkins and upgrade Chapman to May. Ignore the temptation of Bolton for one more week.

 

[rocker_oz33]

I have enough to go Chapman to May.

I want to make some cash for next week.

Murphy or Parks are options.

RCD then Poulter the week after ..

 

[Sherman41]

I’m fairly confident Murphy has solid JS. Injuries have ruined his chances previously. Will be given every chance to make it.

 

[LukasTheGreat]

I’m fairly confident Murphy has solid JS. Injuries have ruined his chances previously. Will be given every chance to make it.

So he's injury prone?

 

[Loose at HB]

So with Fredrick now dropped do we go Murphy or a week early on RCD? Murphy better JS and on the bubble but lower ceiling compared to someone like RCD who has the better scoring potentially but less JS. Tough one since I’ll have to field whoever I bring in. Also the off chance that Hinkley recalls Fredrick next week and if we don’t go RCD we’ll be left with a choice of either Fredrick or RCD since they’ll both be on the bubble and won’t be able to grab both

Highmore dropped after 2 games. Jones injured in his second game. Frederick dropped after 2 games. You would need to have either the largest chol known to man, a complete disregard for your own safety, a simple ability not to give a * or a combination of all 3 to go early on RCD. Even if Frederick comes back next week he's just as likely to go out again and at best he becomes a poor version of Flynn in terms of cash gen. I would go Murphy and then prioritise RCD next week

 

[Sherman41]

I have enough to go Chapman to May.

I want to make some cash for next week.

Murphy or Parks are options.

RCD then Poulter the week after ..

My thoughts are same.
Chapman-May
Highmore- Murphy

then double downgrade next week. Build a big kitty for double upgrade.

 

[pieman123]

Any Collingwood nuffies? Who has better JS out of Murphy and Keane? And who would have a higher ceiling/better role?

Definitely Murphy, Keane is playing Key Position in defence while Murphy has played Wing and as the 3rd tall in defence.

 

[freddy mercury]

I’m fairly confident Murphy has solid JS. Injuries have ruined his chances previously. Will be given every chance to make it.

Scoring might be the only issue.

 

[THECHIEFTON]

RIP to the people who went early on Freddy!

Luckily I didn't.

 

[Sherman41]

So he's injury prone?

He has had some set backs but seems to be on top of things.

realistically I just need him to keep playing and make cash until Jones is back

 

[rocker_oz33]

My thoughts are same.
Chapman-May
Highmore- Murphy

then double downgrade next week. Build a big kitty for double upgrade.

Parks fame straight back in after inj good sign IMO.

Murphy might stick around unsure..

Grrr FU Kenny

 

[Megabattimus]

Locked in my first trade (Rowe > Frederick), but kinda stumped on what to do with my second:

I've narrowed it down to two options:

Option 1-

Option 2-

Welp, Freddy being dropped really put a dent in my plans. Back to square one:

I can still double down, but it would be with someone who doesn't have the scoring potential that Freddy had:

Orrrrr, I could go early on RCD and get May:

All I know is that Rowe's gotta go and I should probably dump Gulden, 'cause I'm not at all confident in his ability to get close or beat his 86 BE.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Parks fame straight back in after inj good sign IMO.

Murphy might stick around unsure..

Grrr FU Kenny

I agree Parks might be the safest out of the lot.

 

[Pocket Aces]

Shattered. Wanted him to get one more week before being dropped so he could burn everyone

Agree with this, although going Murphy over Frederick was making me a little nervous.

 

[rocker_oz33]

I agree Parks might be the safest out of the lot.

I was hoping Poulter was def-mid .

Would of worked out better ,...but he's fwd-mid ...

 

[UltimateStrategist]

RIP to the 7,261 people who went early on Frederick

 

[Sherman41]

Scoring might be the only issue.

He will be my D7 so not much of an issue

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

View attachment 1120499

28,762 Reverse trades?!?

Lots won't get there in time. Would have been hilarious if there was a Thursday game this week.

 

[stevebbb]

I'm not confident Murphy will stick around.
Howe is listed as just 1-2 weeks away, not sure where Murphy fits in then. Noble, Quaynor, Crisp and Maynard are not getting dropped. Moore is moving back to defence. Then there's Roughy or Keane playing as the other tall.
Yes Murph will rotate between wing and half back, but then there's Poulter, WHE, Daicos and Madgen who have all played wing recently.
With our inside mid troubles, Sidey and Daicos are getting bulk CBA's, so that SHOULD leave a spot open on the wing.

Murph will get a few games, but I don't think he can score over 50 or 60 points.


I might just go early RCD, then I can grab May (I only have 1 DEF spot available, so I was going to choose Frederick)


Next week we should get other downgrade options

 

[jdwood]

Bringing in Frederick and May was going to bugger my structure, so at least that crisis is averted. Will bring in RCD early. It went so well with Jones, can't see what could possibly go wrong.

Also on Frederick - he is clearly going to be the sub, some on early for a game ending injury to Boak, and then never leave the team. Those who forgot to reverse trades will benefit from the rookie of the year!

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Well judging by those tweets pudgy little Rowe is playing. BE is 77 so he needs to go really.

I can still trade him to May with 1 trade. Not sure on the second trade.

Maybe Chapman to Murphy but I already have Macrae and McCreery and that feels like too many Pie's rookies. Having said that they all play different positions, and I think Collingwood have realised they suck and will give the kids plenty of games this year.

Would like to build the bank this week ideally, to get Dusty in two weeks. Next week might be a double downgrade too.

Decisions decisions.