Game Day Round 8 Vs Geelong - Monday Night Footy

[MrDanggazz]

Leave the changes you want to see and any pre-match discussion below

 

[Unique Name]

Maybe more than 10 shots on goal in 4qtrs of football.

 

[wild side]

Banfield OUT
Weber OUT

 

[FreoRicci]

Out:
Banfield-useless. Offers nothing as a forward
Who knows? Battled hard but nothing to replace them with
in:
McCarthy. We need a medium forward, and he’s it.
Valente- deserves a shot.

 

[Sir Deadly]

Out: Banfield, Colyer, Shultz
In: McCarthy, Valente, Blakely

 

[salim malik]

We are going nowhere with Schulz, Banfield, Colyer and Bewley in the team.
Anybody in for them.

 

[Righteo]

Need to wait and see how many injured players we'll need to replace.

 

[poshman]

Colyer sh*te
Banfield sh*te
Shultz sh*te
tucker sh*te

Mundy average
Aish average (but a heap of pressure all game long)
Wilson - not sure he is much good
Hill - love hill but average

midfield apart from brayshaw, Cerra and Walters -average to sh*te

Tabs and Lobb missing easy key kicks on goal - sh*te

 

[Bastyy]

Mundy was sh*t, get him out

 

[Scham]

Who’s available? Seriously is Blakely available this week? There was some very soft efforts from our midfielders tonight but can you drop them off one game and who exactly is available anyway?

 

[Scham]

Mundy was sh*t, get him out

A week ago 95% of this board were saying he should play on next year or worse still, we should leave it entirely up to him how long he wants to go on. I wonder what the narrative will be this week?

This board is so reactionary - worse than the media. I bet there’ll be calls for Schultz to be dropped or even delisted but just last week he was the answer to our forward pressure and small forward goal scoring issues. It’s laughable.

 

[Bastyy]

A week ago 95% of this board were saying he should play on next year or worse still, we should leave it entirely up to him how long he wants to go on. I wonder what the narrative will be this week?

This board is so reactionary - worse than the media. I bet there’ll be calls for Schultz to be dropped or even delisted but just last week he was the answer to our forward pressure and small forward goal scoring issues. It’s laughable.

I've been consistent in saying Mundy should have retired last year, we need more room for the young midfield and when Fyfe is here we don't need him in the midfield. In a game like this without Fyfe, he should in theory be playing a good, reliable game. He didn't.

 

[salim malik]

Schulz was ok last week and was recognized for it but one swallow doesn't make a summer.
Schultz nice guy but .........

 

[Freo Big Fella]

Out: Banfield, Colyer, Cox
In: Valente/Blakely, McCarthy, Watson

Backline looks a little short, but (sadly) I just don't see what Cox adds.

 

[Scham]

I've been consistent in saying Mundy should have retired last year, we need more room for the young midfield and when Fyfe is here we don't need him in the midfield. In a game like this without Fyfe, he should in theory be playing a good, reliable game. He didn't.

To be any chance we needed him and Walters to star but I guess WC knew that too. Both were well beaten.

We desperately need to trade an A grade mid in.

 

[Lach72]

We are going nowhere with Schulz, Banfield, Colyer and Bewley in the team.
Anybody in for them.

Bewley was fine. Colyer was just ok.
The other two not so much.

I mean Mundy and Tucker sucked tonight but no brickbats for them?

 

[mike91]

Mundy was sh*t, get him out

Pot shot a 34 year old in his last season? Shame on us still relying on him, not his fault.

All these people potting a 34 year old should ask themselves this - why can't Tucker play 4 quarters? Brayshaw & Cerra did alright but where was the more experienced Tucker? Seems a bit off blaming Mundy

 

[Freo Big Fella]

I mean Mundy and Tucker sucked tonight but no brickbats for them?

I think runs on the board are a bit of a factor. (Although Tucker's increasing tendency to go missing when the going gets tough means his are rapidly diminishing.)

The whipping boys are generally on the block for a reason - "What do they add?" has a pretty obvious answer for Tucker and Mundy, not so much for Banfield/Colyer/Duman.

 

[Unique Name]

Am I reading the stats correctly? Schultz - 7 disposals at 0% disposal eff?

He gets a pass because of last week and we can't/won't drop 3-4 players at once.

Banfield has to be the first to go, Coyler aswell.

Don't worry though, Conca should be good to go. Wonder if Sturt will be good to go being we don't play for 8 more days?

 

[Linebreaker]

Few boys had a bad game but doesn't mean we drop them, Tucker was down tonight but has been solid all year.

Banfield is playing out of position and I don't think he offers us anything as a forward. Replace with McCarthy.

unpopular opinions but I think Darcy is hurting us. So slow and offers next to nothing around the ground. Doesn't get back to help defence. Gives away frees. Replace with Meek.

Mundy been poor over a few games. Love him to death but slow around ground, soft at stoppages, Got sucked into the play a few times. Either move to HBF as a distributer or Replace with Blakely.

Lots of positives tonight. Game style good in patches. Remember we are missing a fair chunk of B22. WCE good side starting to hit there straps.

 

[Kram]

We are going nowhere with Schulz, Banfield, Colyer and Bewley in the team.
Anybody in for them.

He's an ordinary footballer but you are fantastically biased against Bewley, his game tonight was fine.

 

[FreoGirl]

Take more of this

 

[FreoGirl]

Bewley was fine. Colyer was just ok.
The other two not so much.

I mean Mundy and Tucker sucked tonight but no brickbats for them?

Mundy will be given a holiday

 

[Scham]

Tucker is gradually building a reputation of being a front runner.

 

[Spirit Level]

Fredericks though, boy oh boy wowee