Preview Round 9, 2019: Richmond v Hawthorn, 19 May 2019, 3.20pm @ MCG

[Dixie Flatline]

Yay, another Sunday afternoon game. GGAF, AFL.

Preview and changes in here.

 

[hawkguru]

Roughead with a bag and glass continues to play well in the midfield you also have smith and wingard if both are fit. good luck picking the ins, the only outs might be morrison and maybe moore (unluckly did some nice things) not sure if scrimshaw will miss with concussion. Did ceglar do enough today? i think so

 

[mickmaster]

Unless injured any outs very stiff.

 

[macdaddio]

Gee I didn’t realize we have Richmond next week just as I was enjoying this win.
Can we get some revenge on these dam tigers

 

[madhawksfan]

Smith and Wingard back in only if 100% fit. Roughie to stay at BHH for mine. I know he kicked 5 but our forward line looked better today.

Scrimmers probably misses with concussion and Moore the other out.

 

[Leather Poisoning]

Hmmm big selection questions here:

- Will Roughy play? Richmond are a better backline outfit than GWS. Would Roughy's experience help us? Or would his lack of pace hinder us?

- Will Isaac Smith play? Morrison did the simple things well today. Smith often does the hard things well and fluffs the easy.

- Will Wingard play? He's too good to leave out. Wonder how he would have gone today?

- Will Howe come back in? I really like him, but understand the omission.

Interesting times. very very interesting times.

 

[PhatHQ]

I’d really like to see no change purely because the team balance looked great.

Smith being “managed” for another week should be enough to inspire him to lift his game. His long bombs weren’t missed today at all.

Wingard is really interesting.
I would like to see him do a mini Pre season & learn the systems better & get him super fit & firing for the second half of the season.
3 weeks & the bye to get him up & about would be perfect.
He had a great summer from memory til he had the hamstring issue & I think it has hurt his output.
Yes he is learning a new system & yes I think he has had some great moments but if he has some serious juice in his legs to run more in the midfield rotations & we are sitting in the 8 his skills & match winning abilities will be huge!
Throw in a possible return of Mitchell & we are a very dark smokie in finals.

No change

 

[Leather Poisoning]

Looks like Nankervis has done a groin injury for Richmond so they'll be without their best ruck. Wonder if that will affect our decisions at all.

 

[Dinsdale]

Looks like Nankervis has done a groin injury for Richmond so they'll be without their best ruck. Wonder if that will affect our decisions at all.

Big Boy and Cegs combined well today, Cegs resting in the forward line (for 2 nice straight goals), Ben in defence at times. I'd keep them both in.

 

[lethalselbow]

Looks like Nankervis has done a groin injury for Richmond so they'll be without their best ruck. Wonder if that will affect our decisions at all.

They ate in trouble withoit Nankervis.

 

[Rob R]

Smith for Scrimshaw(if inj) or Moore. We looked better up forward with Lewis + Gunston + resting ruck. Sorry to say it about a legend but roughie is too slow and can't mark consistently. No Wingard till he gets fitter and shows more in VFL.

On SM-G570F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[caliente]

I don’t see Wingard getting relegated to VFL. If fit he and also Smith should slot into 1s.

Agree team balance was excellent today though so anyone out is stiff...

 

[Leather Poisoning]

I don’t see Wingard getting relegated to VFL. If fit he and also Smith should slot into 1s.

Agree team balance was excellent today though so anyone out is stiff...

Moore and Morrison are probably at risk of Last in First Out.

 

[Mitchell54]

Out: Moore
In: Wingard

Smith comes in for Scrimshaw if he misses.

Morrison doesn’t deserve to be omitted. Thought he was good today. Moore working very hard but doesn’t have the composure and polish as of yet.

 

[caliente]

Moore and Morrison are probably at risk of Last in First Out.

I know but Moore was good though and his work rate was great... difficult calls for selection panel this week.

 

[spudmaster]

Does Chip miss a week for the fence push report?

 

[Holy Rioli]

Does Chip miss a week for the fence push report?

god no...he's got every right to compete in that situation whilst Cameron is trying to keep the ball in play.

 

[TylerDurden]

Chad and Smith will come in.

Nank out for them is huge. More ruck dominance to be had this week then.

 

[Kanga Commando]

Gee I didn’t realize we have Richmond next week just as I was enjoying this win.
Can we get some revenge on these dam tigers

Yes please.

My brother ( Richmond supporter ) needs a double dose of humble pie... it’s been a long time coming for him.

 

[cryptor]

OUT: Moore (omit)
IN: Wingard

OUT: Scrimshaw (concussion)
IN: Smith

OUT: Frawley (suspension)
IN: Roughead

If Scrimshaw and Frawley get up then Smith and Roughy might just have to wait to crack back in. For the most part the team today earned the opportunity to back it up.

 

[Argy]

Gee I didn’t realize we have Richmond next week just as I was enjoying this win.
Can we get some revenge on these dam tigers

We regularly lose to them in premiership years.

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

You can't change perfection

 

[Threadkilla]

OUT: Moore (omit)
IN: Wingard

OUT: Scrimshaw (concussion)
IN: Smith

OUT: Frawley (suspension)
IN: Roughead

If Scrimshaw and Frawley get up then Smith and Roughy might just have to wait to crack back in. For the most part the team today earned the opportunity to back it up.

Surely Frawley doesn’t go for that?

 

[Mrzohs]

The only possible out would be Scrimshaw with concession maybe a fit I.smith comes in.
Morrison was good today, Moore is on the fringe but i like to see all young players be judged off 3 games in a row

 

[FisherHawk]

If Smith and Wingard are fit and free of niggles, then they have to play. Moore out and Scrimshaw, if concused otherwise Morrison. I'd keep Rough out for at least another one.