Trades Round 9 Trades - Can I Buy a DEF Rookie ?

[raymagoo]

Flynn dropped preuss solo ruck

 

[Dark Sharks]

Thoughts please lads!!!


Double downgrade + 1 upgrade
or
Double upgrade + 1 downgrade






Options







I could go 2 (MRJ, Carrol) down 1 up (Brayshaw). But i don't know who i'd actually trade out for the second downgrade???

Needs to be a defender rookie i'm trading out, and there's no way to make it happen.

 

[TempletonTheRat]

Thoughts please lads!!!


Double downgrade + 1 upgrade
or
Double upgrade + 1 downgrade


View attachment 1399020



Options

View attachment 1399023
View attachment 1399024

pretty tough choice

 

[Axly]

Would love to Boost to get Hamilton as well as grabbing MRJ.
Round 12 Bye has turned me off.
He looks good though.

 

[buttox]

Thoughts please lads!!!


Double downgrade + 1 upgrade
or
Double upgrade + 1 downgrade


View attachment 1399020



Options

View attachment 1399023
View attachment 1399024




I could go 2 (MRJ, Carrol) down 1 up (Brayshaw). But i don't know who i'd actually trade out for the second downgrade???

Needs to be a defender rookie i'm trading out, and there's no way to make it happen.

I reckon Rioli is the better rookie over Carroll mate.

 

[Dark Sharks]

I reckon Rioli is the better rookie over Carroll mate.

My nan is only just speaking to me again and i've only just got my life back together after you convinced me to trade in LDU last year..

 

[Ingy]

NOD to Clark
Rozee to Cameron
Gibcus to Zorko

Leaves me with 2 rookies on field, excluding Martin. 18 trades.

View attachment 1398760


View attachment 1398762

Jumping off Rozee while keeping Butters is an interesting move.

Wanna share your thinking there?

 

[balmainforever]

Show us your team.
Cameron probably.

 

[Hamez]

View attachment 1397121
View attachment 1397122

Thoughts on the following:
NOD > Dawson
Gibcus > Clark via Daicos
Dixon > MRJ

Bank: $170k & 21 trades remaining (2 x boost)

Now that teams have dropped what are your thoughts on the same INS but trading out Rosas instead of Gibcus? So it’d end up being…

NOD > Dawson
Rosas > Clark
Dixon > MRJ

 

[samFFC]

Jumping off Rozee while keeping Butters is an interesting move.

Wanna share your thinking there?

Jumping off Rozee while keeping Butters is an interesting move.

Wanna share your thinking there?

For sure mate!
Essentially I feel Butters is a more consistent scorer and better player

1. More expensive so nets me more cash given I feel similar or better scoring for Butters. Running low on trades so squeezing dollars where I can.
2. DPP will be helpful in the byes
3. Rozee was a mistake and I want to correct it.

 

[Ingy]

For sure mate!
Essentially I feel Butters is a more consistent scorer and better player

1. More expensive so nets me more cash given I feel similar or better scoring for Butters. Running low on trades so squeezing dollars where I can.
2. DPP will be helpful in the byes
3. Rozee was a mistake and I want to correct it.

Last 4: Rozee 91, 153, 87, 74. Butters 130, 58, 89, 52.

I think they'll both score well this week.

Good luck with it mate

 

[Plugger35]

Just locked in NOD > MRJ, Stephens > Hamilton and Dixon > Cameron.

Decided to trade Stephens to Hamilton rather than MacDonald as Stephens looks to be dead while MacDonald still has a pulse and can make more cash.

It also gives me the option of trading Rosas to Clark next week instead of MacDonald if Rosas puts in another stinker and completely kills his cash gen.

I'd like to keep MacDonald if I can, his cash gen is going at a snail's pace but he has that valuable Mid/Fwd DPP, not that I need any more Mid/Fwds.

 

[timtimtim]

Which of you legends are already outta boosts … like me

If you’ve still got boosts you have a small chol

 

[GamerKnight]

Saving my last boost for the bye rounds

 

[Bayskiez]

Hinge > Rioli
Butters > Cameron
JHayes > Darcy
Last boost used (and a 400k warchest) fingers crossed Butters spuds it up and Darcy doesn't get injured

 

[SC fish]

It is done. Got Miller and turfed Durdin to the bench

 

[Chrissybabes]

Bringing in Begg for Dixon.

If Dixon cant get a game now he never will again, and this will likely be the last chance I get to move him on for a green dot

 

[SloppyJoe]

Anyone agonising over Carroll v Hamilton like me?

I can't take both and Hamilton being slightly cheaper and having DPP doesn't make much difference to me.

They look to score similarly (maybe Carroll a higher ceiling), but it comes down to JS I think.

Hamilton's JS is unknown and hard to predict given the change in coach. GWS aren't doing well and he may get a run of games.

Any Blues fans who can share a view on Carroll? I see he's retained his spot with Hewett returning but is there anyone else lining up for his spot?

 

[Kedford]

Might bite me in the arse, but going Carroll and Hamilton over MRJ.

Just feel like MRJ is prone to getting a 30 point game being a small forward and feel like his job security isn't all there.

 

[THECHIEFTON]

With Pendles out i think I'll beef up the back line. Do you trade NOD > Dawson or Gibcus > Docherty.

Doch not the best choice for my byes but it probably gives me another excuse to trade Butters....

 

[SC fish]

With Pendles out i think I'll beef up the back line. Do you trade NOD > Dawson or Gibcus > Docherty.

Doch not the best choice for my byes but it probably gives me another excuse to trade Butters....

I'd go Doch

 

[raymagoo]

Any thoughts?

Tempted to hold.

I’d like to move on NOD & Daicos but I don’t like def downgrade options

 

[evo]

Rowell > Brayshaw
Ward > MRJ

 

[SC fish]

Saving my last boost for the bye rounds

I'm hoping to save mine for SC finals but dunno if I can hold out

 

[THECHIEFTON]

I'd go Doch

I am. Just realised it finishes my defence so it's get Doch now or wait for a injury. Really want him.