Round 9 Trades

[weagles_fan]

Should I get SJ or O'Keefe? SJ is almost 20k more expensive. Decisions....

 

[IDIG]

Went Rance --> Newman

and Hasleby --> Cooney Goodes Cooney Goodes Cooney Goodes Cooney Goodes Cooney Goodes Cooney Goodes Cooney Goodes Cooney Goodes Cooney Goodes Cooney Goodes Cooney Goodes Cooney Goodes Cooney Goodes Cooney Goodes Cooney Goodes

Ahh crap, I'll sleep on it and make that one tomorrow

Same lol. I won't tell you who i went but gee that was a tough one. I'll throw in another name for you to look at. He's a lion and he's not brown but.. Down heaps in value and proven sc'er. Would be a unique choice as not many on here have him which surprises me actually. Haven't even seen his name thrown around.

 

[Liuy]

Still might go Petrenko----> Broughton in order to fund my upgrade to GAJ in a few weeks.....
to him getting dropped.

 

[alternatevista]

Who should i trade out of these 3?
Brown 242k (Macaffer 156k, Hogan 94k)

I wanna bring in Sidebottom 124k. The way i see it if i trade out Brown, i lose a playing bench warmer but make the most profit, trade out Macaffer keep Brown but make next to no profit. Trade Hogan, i keep Brown, it costs me the most but i can hope Macaffer gets a game and makes some dough (unlikely from the looks of it).

Neither options look all that good. I was going to trade out Brown for Sidebottom this week but have tentatively decided against it. Brown, while not scoring that well is a good sub as he doesn't look like getting dropped.

On the other hand Sidebottom could be gone at any moment (like Beams) and then when you have players like Chapman, Higgins, Skipworth all getting injured you have no cover.

But if you have to do the trade, Brown would be the one to go.

 

[Biggie]

Welcome aboard Chris Newman.

Thanks for the $$ Petrenko.

 

[RevDog]

I bought Broughton in just last week and now he is dropped, lucky I have Suban to cover for him!

As far as trading for this week I am going to go Hill > Fisher and Petrenko > Grimes, giving my backline the facelift it needed and hopefully now can lay off the trades for a few weeks. I will have 11 left after these trades and $135,500 in the bank for later on.

 

[TheVelourFog]

Should I get SJ or O'Keefe? SJ is almost 20k more expensive. Decisions....

If you think that O'Loughlin and Hall can stay fit then I would choose O'Keefe as he will just take a huge amount of marks as a link man. But that's a big if.

My problem is do I trade Brown -> Aaron Davey or,
Suban -> Newman/Gilbee

 

[G-Mo77]

I'm thinking of Skipworth to Koschitzke.

He's at 350K on the rise and probably will be a player that finishes in my team by the end of the year. What do you guys think?

It's been my first chance at getting rid of Skipworth.

 

[RWnBluey]

Same lol. I won't tell you who i went but gee that was a tough one. I'll throw in another name for you to look at. He's a lion and he's not brown but.. Down heaps in value and proven sc'er. Would be a unique choice as not many on here have him which surprises me actually. Haven't even seen his name thrown around.

Oh pretty pleeeeeeeeeease... I'll show you mine if you show me yours

I assume your ref to Black, yes he is temtping as well

 

[Liuy]

I'm thinking of Skipworth to Koschitzke.

He's at 350K on the rise and probably will be a player that finishes in my team by the end of the year. What do you guys think?

It's been my first chance at getting rid of Skipworth.

Skippy's playing VFL this weekend.

 

[Hondo]

Oh pretty pleeeeeeeeeease... I'll show you mine if you show me yours

I assume your ref to Black, yes he is temtping as well

If it's MacDonald then that's not a good choice IMO

 

[lamaros]

Mundy>Grimes
Greenwood>Dempsey

Hoping that two of Cheney, Grimes, Dempsey or Hurley will come good from here on and that I can leave it alone from here. Very risky, but it's what I'm going with.

 

[G-Mo77]

Skippy's playing VFL this weekend.

I'm tempted just to hold off and save a trade but I don't see Skipworth as being as much of a contributer in the second half of the season which is why I am thinking of moving him.

 

[RWnBluey]

If it's MacDonald then that's not a good choice IMO

Isn't he a defender?

 

[Liuy]

I'm tempted just to hold off and save a trade but I don't see Skipworth as being as much of a contributer in the second half of the season which is why I am thinking of moving him.

Do it if u thinkso. But remember, knights drafted him last year as a mature age recruit to play AFL games, not VFL plus his BE is 44.

 

[G-Mo77]

Mundy>Grimes
Greenwood>Dempsey

Hoping that two of Cheney, Grimes, Dempsey or Hurley will come good from here on and that I can leave it alone from here. Very risky, but it's what I'm going with.

There are much better options than Dempsey. I know you're a Bomber fan but I would look around a lot more before even considering taking him on.

 

[G-Mo77]

Do it if u thinkso. But remember, knights drafted him last year as a mature age recruit to play AFL games, not VFL plus his BE is 44.

Bugger it, he stays!

 

[Liuy]

Bugger it, he stays!

For your sake and my sake, i hope its the right decision.

 

[Jezzza]

Houlihan to Grimes
Otten to Judd

Now just need Rich to play well for a game or 2 and Ablett to be just a good player for a couple of weeks. No chance...

 

[infanti]

Here is a good one for all of you...
2 trades for me this week, getting 2 premiums.
Who the get for Krakouer up forward.
And who to get for beams in middle.

No matter who you say i will still have enough for ablett in 2-3 weeks, so anybody goes.
I already plan on getting ablett for higgins.

my forward line is
Pav, SJ, Deledio, Roughy, Krak, Zeibell, M.Brown, Ben Warren and Ben Reid.
(im happy having 3 rookies rotating for 7th spot)

and mids are
Judd, Bartel, Selwood, Ray, Higgins, Robinson, Beams, Davenport.

Open to all sorts of options...? Cheers

 

[Liuy]

Is anyone still getting Broughton? Headland still has to pass a fitness test tomorrow.

Personally, if Tom Collier makes Brisbane's 22 I'll be getting Broughton and most likely O'Keefe.

i might to fund getting GAJ

 

[inflames1919]

Need some help on who to upgrade. My backs look like a bit of a worry, but not sure if I should upgrade the midfield or forward line either. Here is my team:

Backs: Goddard, Cornes, Newman, Gilbee, Malceski, Suban, Grimes (Houlihan, Rance)

Mids: Judd, Corey, Sewell, Hasleby, Rich, Dangerfield (Ward, Beams)

Rucks: Cox, McIntosh (Spencer, Sellar)

Forwards: N Riewoldt, Pavlich, Krakouer, Higgins, Ziebell, T Walker (Gartlett, J.Grant)

I was thinking of upgrading Malceski or Suban.
But not entirely happy with Taylor Walker either.
Midfield looks ok but wouldnt mind adding another premium.

I have $248,000 to spend.

Opinions would be a great help!
Thanks.

 

[lamaros]

There are much better options than Dempsey. I know you're a Bomber fan but I would look around a lot more before even considering taking him on.

Who else at 350 or below has this:

At worst will score 70-80.
Will get selected every week unless injured.
At best will score 90-110.

I think there is a good chance that Dempsey will start putting in regular 90+ games from here on in. IF not, well I've wasted a trade or have a 7th defender scoring 70-80 instead.

Not a huge risk really.

 

[deadoralive]

just traded houlihan for grimes,

now deciding whether i should upgrade either hill or a tuck or rich to a premium.

any thoughts let me know.

 

[Baxter23]

Petrenko to Grimes.

Same price!

Sideways trade?