Round 9 Trades

[Hot Tiges]

I like this trade, Gia is as cheap as he will get. Only if he is to be your 7th fwd keeper.

+1 Quality player and looked good against Melbourne. Could come back down to earth against Geelong though

Myself, looking at
T Tuck > Davenport/Sidebottom
Petrenko > Gilbee/P Burgoyne

Leave me with 11 trades and this backline

Fisher,Newman,Cornes,P Burgoyne/Gilbee,Bock,Broughton,Hill(Hodge, Cheney)

Ablett,Judd,Selwood,Cross,Beams,Rich(Davenport,Cockie)

or

Hill > Grimes
T Tuck > 567k downwards premo

Fisher,Newman,Cornes,Grimes,Bock,Cheney Broughton(Hodge, Petrenko)

Ablett,Judd,Selwood,Cross,567k,Rich(Beams,Cockie)

So all in all it's a huge week in trading circles and with 13 left it's a huge call

Any help would be awesome

 

[ingoodeswetrust]

+1 Quality player and looked good against Melbourne. Could come back down to earth against Geelong though

Myself, looking at
T Tuck > Davenport/Sidebottom
Petrenko > Gilbee/P Burgoyne

Leave me with 11 trades and this backline

Fisher,Newman,Cornes,P Burgoyne/Gilbee,Bock,Broughton,Hill(Hodge, Cheney)

Ablett,Judd,Selwood,Cross,Beams,Rich(Davenport,Cockie)

or

Hill > Grimes
T Tuck > 567k downwards premo

Fisher,Newman,Cornes,Grimes,Bock,Cheney Broughton(Hodge, Petrenko)

Ablett,Judd,Selwood,Cross,567k,Rich(Beams,Cockie)

So all in all it's a huge week in trading circles and with 13 left it's a huge call

Any help would be awesome

Option 2 for mine but i would look at keeping tuck, Trading Beams >>> Goodes $484,000 just ripe for the picking. Tuck will come good & Beams INJ plus sidebottom comming in will affect his selection i think.

Your mids would be set then & you wont miss the Grimes boat.

I have so many problems i dont knpw where to start, so i will take my time to post my trade options. As of right now i hate S/C as it is now my second job (non paying). I bundy in & out evey night now & pay my wife $10 per hour im doing S/C stuff.

 

[Dan87]

Anyone considering Kosi?

 

[munk3ymark]

Munky, if you think malceski is gonna come back and fire up then your weak back 3 of Raines, malceski, Hill doesnt look too bad. obv looking to upgrade that at some point.
If you are looking for cash this week, and Raines is named, i would go Hill to Grimes and Suban to Broughton. 300-350k is the minimum you would want to gain from 2 downgrades, but at least you are getting 2 very good players into your team (injury free that is)

Cheers FB- that's certainly the way I've been heading over the course of this afternoon. That scenario leaves me with a tick over $400K in the bank for upgrades the following week. Play my cards right I could bring Gilbee and Newman in (for example), or just one of them and use some of the rest to work on the holes elsewhere. It does require me to keep faith in both Malceski and Raines for at least another week, which is a little scary...

 

[BIGANT]

Beams >> J. McVeigh.... thoughts...i too looked at Beams >> Goodes; but i'm about 30k short - Boak/Lovett is also in the mix; can Lovett sustain is cracker form all yr tho !?
If i went Tuck downgrade, i could get Goodes no problem; Advice please

 

[ingoodeswetrust]

14 trades left, $72,000 in bank, Red = Keepers

Goddard,Gilbee,Cornes,Gilbert,Adcock,Hoops,Broughton,(Rance,Pentrenko)

Bartell,Judd,Gibbs,Cooney,Power,Rich,(Tuck,Robbo)

Cox, H'Mac (Jacobs, Spencer)

Pav,Franklin,S.Johno,Deledio,Higgins,Roughead,Kraks,(Brown,Thompson)

Plan A, This week, Hoops >>> Grimes, Then Tuck >>> McGlynn/Davenport

Next Week, Pentrenko >>> Hurley (hope he gets picked)

Week After, Rich >>> Ablett

Week After That, Robbo >>> Rookie, Then Kraks $400,000 >>> Any GUN

Team After trades

Goddard,Gilbee,Cornes,Gilbert,Adcock,Gimes,Broughton,(Rance,Hurley)

Bartell,Judd,Gibbs,Cooney,Power,Ablett,(Dav/McGlynn,Rookie)

Cox, H'Mac (Jacobs, Spencer)

Pav,Franklin,S.Johno,Deledio,Higgins,Roughead,GUN,(Brown,Thompson)

Leaves me 8 trades for 10 rounds. Mids & Fwds SET. Backs GRRR

Ant advise would be great. Dont hold back

 

[RWnBluey]

What do you guys think?

Hasleby --> Goodes

Or

Hasleby --> Cooney (+$46k)

 

[Lids12]

ingoodeswetrust,
I like the look of McGlynn as well, just not sure if he is going to play when Hawthorn have their better players back?? Hurley also looks like a good keeper for your bench once he starts playing again, or even for your 7th backman.

This round, im going to trade:
Hill/Petterd - Grimes
and one of three options:
Fev/Krakouer - Sidebottom/McGlynn
Fev/Krakouer - Gun Forward
Petterd/Hill/Houlihan - Gun Defender

Do you think it would be smarter to get rid of Petterd or Hill, and which option should i take??
** Backline: Goddard, Fisher, Drummond, C.Cornes, Hill, Petterd, Cheney
(Houlihan, Petrenko)
Forwards: Goodwin, Deledio, S.Johnson, Krakouer, Fevola, Skipworth, Higgins
(M.Brown, Macaffer)

 

[Speck]

What do you guys think?

Hasleby --> Goodes

Or

Hasleby --> Cooney (+$46k)

Goodes is a safer option however Cooney could start racking up the numbers. A very tough one. I'm not really sold on Cooney this year.

Backs: Goddard, Newman, C Cornes, P Burgoyne, Waite, Hurn, Houlihan (Broughton, Petrenko)

Midfielders: Dal Santo, Bartel, Gibbs, Judd, Mitchell, Rich (Robinson, Zaharakis)

Rucks: Cox, McIntosh (Spencer, Currie)

Forwards: Chapman, Pavlich, Deledio, Fevola, Krakouer, Higgins, Walker (Ziebell, Warren)

Bolded are keepers. I think I'm in a fairly good position with only 7 players non-keepers. My biggest worry is my forwards so I'm very keen to upgrade in that area. It all depends on who is named but I'm keen to get rid of Petrenko. I'm thinking Buddy however I think its worth getting enough money to get a proven gun.

I have 11 trades left and 48k in the bank. I'm willing to use two this week and not use any for about 5 weeks. I'm sitting 220th if that matters.

 

[OneEyedHawk]

Tossing up between 3 potential scenario's this week, would really appreciate some advice. Need a win this week to stay top-4.

16 trades, $38k in bank.

B: Chornes, Goddard, Gilbee, Fisher, Malceski, Cheney, Broughton (Hill & Petrenko)
M: Ablett, Judd, Selwood, Haselby, Foley, Rich (Dangerfield & Beams)
R: Petrie, Tippett (Jacobs, Spencer)
F: Pavlich, Riewoldt, Deledio, SJ, Roughead, Higgins, Ziebell (Brown & Walker)

Option 1:
Hill > Grimes, then Malceski > Newman (+ $55k)

Option 2:
Hill > Grimes, then Rich > Goodes (+ $3k)

Option 3:
Hill > Grimes, then Foley > Nicky Dal (+ $87k)

 

[BIGANT]

Just bit the bullet.......Tuck >>> McGlynn; now leads me with 11 trades remaining with 622,900k. Trade 2 is Malceski >>> any premium or less; thoughts !? Waite/CCornes/Gilbee/any1 else...

 

[Hot Tiges]

Shane Tuck or Travis??Lot of cash left over! McGlynn looks the goods I reckon.

Just realised I've got Hodge soaking up the bench. Possibly Hodge > Grimes and T Tuck > Goodes + 200k or Power/Cooney + 240k then next week Hill who will hopefully not drop too much > Burgoyne and extra cash of around 100 k possibly.. thoughts?? However, I did bring in Hodge the week he was injured

 

[BIGANT]

Shane Tuck or Travis??Lot of cash left over! McGlynn looks the goods I reckon.

Just realised I've got Hodge soaking up the bench. Possibly Hodge > Grimes and T Tuck > Goodes + 200k or Power/Cooney + 240k then next week Hill who will hopefully not drop too much > Burgoyne and extra cash of around 100 k possibly.. thoughts?? However, I did bring in Hodge the week he was injured

Travis. T it was....

 

[Purrfect Pussies]

Want to upgrade forward rookie to ROK this week.

Which one goes?

Walker or Brown

 

[Hot Tiges]

Want to upgrade forward rookie to ROK this week.

Which one goes?

Walker or Brown

Got to be Brown I reckon. Walker shows some promise. Brown is purely 30's to 60's + Walker still has some cash to make as he has a negative BE

 

[Hondo]

Plan A, This week, Hoops >>> Grimes, Then Tuck >>> McGlynn/Davenport

Next Week, Pentrenko >>> Hurley (hope he gets picked)

Week After, Rich >>> Ablett

Week After That, Robbo >>> Rookie, Then Kraks $400,000 >>> Any GUN

Be careful with Davenport. He has been serviceable but not set the world on fire and is being mentioned on the Port board as a potential OUT this week. I take that as, if not this week, then soon when SBurgoyne and Salopek return.

I'd leave the Tuck trade if Davenport was your only option.

 

[ingoodeswetrust]

Be careful with Davenport. He has been serviceable but not set the world on fire and is being mentioned on the Port board as a potential OUT this week. I take that as, if not this week, then soon when SBurgoyne and Salopek return.

I'd leave the Tuck trade if Davenport was your only option.

Thank Hondo, What about McGlynn tho?

 

[Judd_Magic]

Thank Hondo, What about McGlynn tho?

McGlynn is a battler at best. Like I said earlier you wouldn't want him in your team come SC finals time when the Hawks have their best line up in.

 

[ingoodeswetrust]

McGlynn is a battler at best. Like I said earlier you wouldn't want him in your team come SC finals time when the Hawks have their best line up in.

He only has to give me 5 weeks on the bench, just to make some cash.

He might take tucks place? Can only hope

 

[fugu]

McGlynn is a battler at best. Like I said earlier you wouldn't want him in your team come SC finals time when the Hawks have their best line up in.

In theory there is one spot available in the Hawks best 22 due to Crawford's retirement. Competing for it are McGlynn, Moss, Tuck and Whitecross, maybe Morton also. I would say that McGlynn and Whitecross are leading the race.

There is also a possibility that the Hawks will not get their "best" 22 back this year. There is plenty of doubt over Ladson and Ellis. That will open up more spots.

I would say McGlynn is a pretty good shot at holding his place.

 

[RWnBluey]

Goodes is a safer option however Cooney could start racking up the numbers. A very tough one. I'm not really sold on Cooney this year.

Yeah, so hard to decide. Cooney has the cats this week but after that the dogs have a good run for while and his knee seems to be fine now. To be honest I really havent watched much of the swans this year perhaps someone that has or a swans supporter could help me out here

 

[Hands Open]

trying to sort out a long term midfield plan here..

my non keepers are haselby and rich, and possibly griffen, but he'll be the last to go.

Currently have 231k in the bank and want Ablett, but am leaning towards the idea of say Rich - Winderlich and then soon after Haselby to Montanga/Hayes once my other cash cows peak..

Should I stick it out a bit and get Ablett or just go with Winders/montagne/hayes??

Cheers

 

[RWnBluey]

trying to sort out a long term midfield plan here..

my non keepers are haselby and rich, and possibly griffen, but he'll be the last to go.

Currently have 231k in the bank and want Ablett, but am leaning towards the idea of say Rich - Winderlich and then soon after Haselby to Montanga/Hayes once my other cash cows peak..

Should I stick it out a bit and get Ablett or just go with Winders/montagne/hayes??

Cheers

If you want Gaz wait a couple of weeks. His price will drop 50-100k

 

[Dylz48]

Have serious backline issues at the moment mine reads

S.Fisher---L.Gillbee---L.Hodge---A.Toovey---A.Raines---T.Williams---N.Suban---K.Cheeney---A.Rance
I also have 88,000 in the kitty

ATM I was thinking

Toovey/Raines/Williams >>> Grimes
Hodge >>> Premium not sure who Goodard looks the good but not sure if too expensive

While Toovey is a spud he is averaging 63 which is more than the other 2 however and is likely to get dropped and has earned me 36K

Williams has lost me 65K but is getting regular game time and the less said about Raines the better

 

[Judd_Magic]

Have serious backline issues at the moment mine reads

S.Fisher---L.Gillbee---L.Hodge---A.Toovey---A.Raines---T.Williams---N.Suban---K.Cheeney---A.Rance
I also have 88,000 in the kitty

ATM I was thinking

Toovey/Raines/Williams >>> Grimes
Hodge >>> Premium not sure who Goodard looks the good but not sure if too expensive

While Toovey is a spud he is averaging 63 which is more than the other 2 however and is likely to get dropped and has earned me 36K

Williams has lost me 65K but is getting regular game time and the less said about Raines the better

Gees and I thought I had problems in my backline with a lineup of Fisher, Goddard, Cornes, Gilbee, Hill, Petrenko, Broughton (Rance, Houlihan)

Fix that backline up ASAP mate, its your no.1 priority I reckon!

I'm turfing out Hill and Houlihan for Grimes and Newman this week so I don't have to give my opponent a 90 + head start by playing Spudrenko on the ground! LOL!

God I hate that $#U$U$*$