Post BF Upgrade Feedback - Click Here

Remove this Banner Ad

Rumour Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Matz
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

TradeDraft said:
Why would that stop getting a Gun Player?
Click to expand...

Firstly I wouldnt want to see Brown go. Sure his year hasnt been great, but what did we expect after coming back from an injury.
Secondly, attitude is the reason a lot on this board didnt want Fev to come to the club. Sure Caddy doesnt equal Fev, but based on the story above about how he wants to come to Melb to essentially party... doesnt bode well.
 
spongetom said:
Firstly I wouldnt want to see Brown go. Sure his year hasnt been great, but what did we expect after coming back from an injury.
Secondly, attitude is the reason a lot on this board didnt want Fev to come to the club. Sure Caddy doesnt equal Fev, but based on the story above about how he wants to come to Melb to essentially party... doesnt bode well.
Click to expand...

Well we don't know if what was said about Caddy was true?

I would not like to Trade Brown as well
 
TradeDraft said:
Why would that stop getting a Gun Player?
Click to expand...

Hmm - Brendan fevola could be a good example to look. Chris Tarrant another who we had to get rid of to sort his shit out. Not the mention the numerous indiscretions that didak, shaw, Wellingham have been involved in. It's about character assessment and who u want to be around the club. Fevola was the best forward in the league when he went to Brisbane but they couldn't tame him.

I'm not saying caddy is like fev, I am just answering ur question of why a poor character may stop a club from picking someone up.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Number 10 said:
Yes definitely and all but Johnson have been close to being thrown out of the club.
Click to expand...

True.I trust in Hine and Rendell to make the Right Call on these type of Players
 
he wants to come back to melbourne because he wants the rock star lifestyle, he's pissed off he doesnt get noticed in nightclubs blah blah
now he's like fev, he's a tosser, he's this/that
give me a break
this all in the opinion of some gold coast staffer who is pissed that he wants out so looks for a reason.....family, friends, home, sick father, playing with a big club in melbourne.....nah he cant leave for that he wants to be a night club superstar...
oh dear.
fwiw we all wanted to be night club stars at 19 didnt we?
 
gifted1 said:
he wants to come back to melbourne because he wants the rock star lifestyle, he's pissed off he doesnt get noticed in nightclubs blah blah
now he's like fev, he's a tosser, he's this/that
give me a break
this all in the opinion of some gold coast staffer who is pissed that he wants out so looks for a reason.....family, friends, home, sick father, playing with a big club in melbourne.....nah he cant leave for that he wants to be a night club superstar...
oh dear.
fwiw we all wanted to be night club stars at 19 didnt we?
Click to expand...

How you explain to him. He does not give crap about Footy he just wants to be a Rock Star and the Girls. Sounds like Billy Morrison all over again.
 
gifted1 said:
he wants to come back to melbourne because he wants the rock star lifestyle, he's pissed off he doesnt get noticed in nightclubs blah blah
now he's like fev, he's a tosser, he's this/that
give me a break
this all in the opinion of some gold coast staffer who is pissed that he wants out so looks for a reason.....family, friends, home, sick father, playing with a big club in melbourne.....nah he cant leave for that he wants to be a night club superstar...
oh dear.
fwiw we all wanted to be night club stars at 19 didnt we?
Click to expand...
This was said at the start of this season- not the end. And this was the person's opinion from knowing him well. I am not saying it to be anything other than contributing to what people want to know about the kid. If you are quoting in me as saying he is like fev- I didn't mean it that way- I was more talkin about the big impact of overseeing character traits for talent.

Either way- we won't be getting him. His value is out of our range and we have plenty of great mids.
 
Number 10 said:
This was said at the start of this season- not the end. And this was the person's opinion from knowing him well. I am not saying it to be anything other than contributing to what people want to know about the kid. If you are quoting in me as saying he is like fev- I didn't mean it that way- I was more talkin about the big impact of overseeing character traits for talent.

Either way- we won't be getting him. His value is out of our range and we have plenty of great mids.
Click to expand...

not slapping you mate, just saying you post the opinion of someone you know and all of a sudden everyone takes it as gospel and runs with it.
It gets quite comical.
Football is an opinion business, everyone has one, no doubt a lot of people are really keen on caddy and i'd say reading between the lines that GC are pissed off he hasnt bought in to their ethos
 
gifted1 said:
not slapping you mate, just saying you post the opinion of someone you know and all of a sudden everyone takes it as gospel and runs with it.
It gets quite comical.
Football is an opinion business, everyone has one, no doubt a lot of people are really keen on caddy and i'd say reading between the lines that GC are pissed off he hasnt bought in to their ethos
Click to expand...
Nah I didn't take it badly and I agree. I also understand the irony in that this miniature post may be taken and turned into a new rumour-in the rumour thread.
I actually had avoided this thread until now- so too the mick malthouse thread because I just can't be ****ed with rumours - so I am probably fuelling a fire I don't want to be a part of.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Number 10 said:
What I was told about caddy was 100% true. He wants the rock star lifestyle
Click to expand...
You're kidding surely? That's the farthest thing from the truth. Everyone I've ever heard have only positive things to say. His dad is sick and he misses his family. That's why he wants to go home to Melbourne.
 
darkwingduck said:
You're kidding surely? That's the farthest thing from the truth. Everyone I've ever heard have only positive things to say. His dad is sick and he misses his family. That's why he wants to go home to Melbourne.
Click to expand...
Unless my ears deceived me, that is what I was told at the beginning of the season so no, no I am not kidding. Doesn't mean it is correct at this time of the year, but I am not one to make shit up. What would the point of that be? I have no reason to make something up. Who am I going to impress, some people I don't know on the Internet?
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

as much as I hate the idea...could the Eddie EMT story be Fev on a 1 year deal, with 2 coaches/minders ?
Heard it ths morning on rumour file.
 
Doubt it.

Didn't Ed say it would be out in the public forum in a couple weeks?

Unless we're giving Fev a deal whilst recovering from a PCL, being overweight and not in footy shape.

I don't see it. I would imagine this type of news would suffice come Nov/Dec, assuming it was to happen, but i could be wrong.
 
daics_35 said:
They got that rumor from the Stefan Martin thread. If he went to Melbourne he would be dumb.
Click to expand...

I agree that they got it from BigFooty but I don't think it would be terrible for Sharrod to to go Melbourne. He just about be there best Mid
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

JuniorB
Certified Legendary Thread Covid, Life, UFOs, Food, & Wordle :( Part 2
151 152 153 154 155
Replies
4K
Views
124K
Pistol Night
Pistol Night

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom