Rumour Thread

[jimmy35]

Malthouse is now claiming he said he would love to have Ben Reid at Carlton, not Cloke as first reported.

As first reported? He said it himself in his Carlton presser.

 

[Pie eyed]

ROFL.
It's a rumour.....you know?

 

[Embleberry]

MM wants the Collingwood list at Carlscum

 

[Markfs]

A good friend of mines parents are best friends with Swanny's parents.

Apparantly he cannot stand Buckley and after his contract that is it. Doing it purely for financial reasons nowadays other wise he would have walked after the last contract.

Just what i have been told not saying its true.

Swan said in the paper a few months back that he only plays for the chance of winning a premiership...

 

[Beary17]

Damien Barrett on the footy show just said the rumor is tippet to gold coast, josh caddy to collingwood, Nathan brown to the crows. Thoughts?

 

[Baltimore Jack]

Damien Barrett on the footy show just said the rumor is tippet to gold coast, josh caddy to collingwood, Nathan brown to the crows. Thoughts?

Ha ha ha

 

[HFF]

That rumour is rubbish. Nathan Brown is contracted isn't he?

Also, very much a required player with Taz retiring. Brown and Reid are the cornerstones of our defense. Not for sale.

We have no need for Josh Caddy. We also have a kid who has finally got his body right in Josh Thomas who is similar to Caddy.

Nathan Brown is staying put.

 

[Beary17]

That rumour is rubbish. Nathan Brown is contracted isn't he?

Also, very much a required player with Taz retiring. Brown and Reid are the cornerstones of our defense. Not for sale.

We have no need for Josh Caddy. We also have a kid who has finally got his body right in Josh Thomas who is similar to Caddy.

Nathan Brown is staying put.

Yep would of thought the same thing, just sounds completely made up doesn't it! Don't know much about Caddy but I can't imagine why we'd contemplate trading N. Brown.

 

[Cory]

But Reid signed

 

[TradeDraft]

Damien Barrett on the footy show just said the rumor is tippet to gold coast, josh caddy to collingwood, Nathan brown to the crows. Thoughts?

Would Love Caddy but I would not Trade Nathan Brown

 

[Cory]

Q-Stick would be very handy would not need Wood.

 

[daics_35]

Apparantly Cloke had talks with Carlton on Friday. At least if he leaves he will leave playing good footy for us rather than putting in no effort like he was playing during the home and away season.

 

[TradeDraft]

Apparantly Cloke had talks with Carlton on Friday. At least if he leaves he will leave playing good footy for us rather than putting in no effort like he was playing during the home and away season.

Who said This?

 

[Shade]

I would do the Caddy trade i think we have a surplus amount of Key Backs and need another hard inside mid

 

[Breakthelines]

I would do the Caddy trade i think we have a surplus amount of Key Backs and need another hard inside mid

Brown, Reid & Keefe.
Maxy is almost done.
Play Brown at FB/Keefe at CHB & Reid the 3rd man.

 

[Shade]

We also have Gault and Hartley what young inside mids do we have? zero and no Josh Thomas doesn't count

 

[Breakthelines]

Q

We also have Gault and Hartley what young inside mids do we have? zero and no Josh Thomas doesn't count

Quality KPP don't grow on trees!
It's easier to develop a midfilder than a key defender.
I'd love Caddy but not at the price of N.Brown.

 

[Shade]

Q
Quality KPP don't grow on trees!
It's easier to develop a midfilder than a key defender.
I'd love Caddy but not at the price of N.Brown.

I always thought Nathan Brown was overrated good honest battler that does his job but some weeks he can get caught with his pants down.

 

[Breakthelines]

I always thought Nathan Brown was overrated good honest battler that does his job but some weeks he can get caught with his pants down.

So did Presti & Soss mate.
He killed Kennedy/Cox last night. Has taken plenty of quality KPF to the cleaners.
I think we need to go for that inside midfielder as you said but via the draft.
We have used our first rounder the last couple of years to get Krakouer/Ceglar/Elliott/Clarke, its now time to go via the draft and develop the list we have.
The only trade I'd be making is our 2nd Rounder for a Griffin/Giles type because Wood looks finished.

 

[sr36]

i'd very happily trade Brown for Caddy. I personally think that Brown is mediocre at best.

 

[TradeDraft]

We also have Gault and Hartley what young inside mids do we have? zero and no Josh Thomas doesn't count

Here is our Inside Mids:

• Ball
• Beams
• Pendles
• J Thomas
• M Williams

I would love Josh Caddy but I would not Trade N Brown to get him

 

[Maggie5]

Q-Stick would be very handy would not need Wood.

Actually, last night is a good example of why I don't favour Lynch, sorry.

 

[Mark_K]

Apparantly Cloke had talks with Carlton on Friday. At least if he leaves he will leave playing good footy for us rather than putting in no effort like he was playing during the home and away season.

Can they talk during the season?

 

[Embleberry]

For mine, Brown is very much required. Sure we can play Keefe or Gault/Hartely but Brown would get the job done more often than not.

 

[TradeDraft]

Actually, last night is a good example of why I don't favour Lynch, sorry.

Already Playing for us