Rumour Thread

[Witts the Messiah]

surely cant be possible if we have signed Lynch now?

That was my first reaction too, but it would hinder it at all (other than money being an issue). Dawes + pick 17 (wellingham trade) + 18 to the crows for tippet. Imagine a big 3 of Cloke, Q-Stick and Tiptruck. Q-Stick and Truck could both chip in the ruck at various stages. Still very much in the mix I think.

 

[juzzo]

inb4 main board mega thread accusing us of cheating(not that i blame them lol). Even if we don't get him how friggin good is free agency? So much more action than trade week.

 

[Paul87]

i live over in Perth. saw Sharrod Wellingham shopping this morning. I work at where he was shopping and he was with a friend which i was serving and Wellingham saw i was a Pies supporter by the tattoo on my arm but i didnt ask him anything in regard to where he will be next year which i regret. I might add he didnt seem in a very good mood if that means anything???

 

[Fred the Red]

Carlton offer 'fringe' player + pick 11 to GC for Caddy.

 

[Collingwoodity]

i live over in Perth. saw Sharrod Wellingham shopping this morning. I work at where he was shopping and he was with a friend which i was serving and Wellingham saw i was a Pies supporter by the tattoo on my arm but i didnt ask him anything in regard to where he will be next year which i regret. I might add he didnt seem in a very good mood if that means anything???

played shit this year?

 

[Breakthelines]

I honestly don't know about this. Pretty risky to trade our first round pick again. Also Tippett has had his fair share of concussions. If this does go through Dawes will have to go for a draft pick.

Are you joking?
Dawes doesn't have to go anywhere.
I'd rather get players like Krakouer, Clarke & Elliott & Tippet then use pick 17/18 to pick up another Danny Roach. Different if we had a top 10 pick.

 

[Breakthelines]

Carlton offer 'fringe' player + pick 11 to GC for Caddy.

Carlton need to wake up...THEY DON"T NEED MIDFIELDERS....THEY NEED KPP.

 

[jonbe54]

Carlton need to wake up...THEY DON"T NEED MIDFIELDERS....THEY NEED KPP.

You can't blame them in a way after all look at their coups so far

Cloke . . . . FAIL

QStick . . . FAIL

Tippet . . . FAIL

Check out the scum pond board for major panic stations about landing ANYONE

LOLOLOLOLOLOL

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Carlton offer 'fringe' player + pick 11 to GC for Caddy.

LOL Carlscum, another mid, maybe he can play in the ressies with Kane Lucas. These last few days have been beautiful to watch for an old Carlscum hater like me.

 

[larskunde]

Where is he going to kick it to?

The space Waite would occupy if he was fit?

 

[Shade]

Dawes on the trade table according to damo

 

[eddiebankbalance]

Tippett is magpie bound.

good lord, today is turning into a wankfest

 

[Temploar]

good lord, today is turning into a wankfest

If we land Tippett i'll name it "Wankfest day"

 

[carnthepies19]

Melb supposedly interested in Dawes. Says Damian Barrett

 

[HFF]

Dawes on the trade table according to damo

Melb supposedly interested in Dawes. Says Damian Barrett

Makes sense if we land Tippett.

 

[eddiebankbalance]

Melb supposedly interested in Dawes. Says Damian Barrett

That is good news, Dawes gets to stay in Melb and we get a better draft pic, you'd think.

 

[Number 10]

Two first round picks on Tippett.... No thanks, I would rather send a first round over to GWS for Giles. Save $200K and get a number 1 ruckman who is very good forward and would be better long term than Tippett or Lynch.

Also - how is he going to sign with us in "the next 24 hours" when trade week hasn't even started!!??

 

[SwanBet]

God i hope somehow we keep pick 18, and somehow get tippett.

Wellingham to West Coast for pick 17.
Dawes to Melbourne pick 26.

Collingwood trade pick 17, 26, and 39(our 2nd rounder) for Tippett.
Something like that would be ideal.

 

[eddiebankbalance]

Carlton need to wake up...THEY DON"T NEED MIDFIELDERS....THEY NEED KPP.

Best to let sleeping dogs lie

 

[itwdandy]

God i hope somehow we keep pick 18, and somehow get tippett.

Wellingham to West Coast for pick 17.
Dawes to Melbourne pick 26.

Collingwood trade pick 17, 26, and 39(our 2nd rounder) for Tippett.
Something like that would be ideal.

Seriously u think Dawes only worth pick 26?

 

[RuFiO]

God i hope somehow we keep pick 18, and somehow get tippett.

Wellingham to West Coast for pick 17.
Dawes to Melbourne pick 26.

Collingwood trade pick 17, 26, and 39(our 2nd rounder) for Tippett.
Something like that would be ideal.

Don't think you can just lump a bunch of crap draft picks expecting they'd budge
I mean you'd laugh at that if that's what someone offered that for Cloke.
Quality > quantity as much as I'd love for something along those lines to happen in an ideal world.

 

[Zahki]

Seriously u think Dawes only worth pick 26?

Not even worth that, 26 would be overs based on how he played this year.

 

[entourage]

Apparently Cam Pederson form North is likely to land with us too...WTF, he's a spud that can barely get regular games at north ffs.

 

[Embleberry]

lol everyone wants to come to Collingwood

 

[larskunde]

Not even worth that, 26 would be overs based on how he played this year.

Yeah but it's not based on that, it would be based on other years including his premiership year and the fact he is a 6ft 5" 100+kg power forward with a huge tank