Rumour Thread

speedytiger · Oct 3, 2013

morgoth said:
I thought Swallow was from Perth?

Going home Mitch Clarke style?

SpongePie · Oct 3, 2013

dubber said:
Perhaps wants to be closer to his brother?

Yeah that's what was said on the trade radio.

So my question... let's say it could happen, and I doubt that it could... but anyway...
Shaw for Swallow or Shaw for Adams

POKsPies252 · Oct 3, 2013

SpongePie said:
Yeah that's what was said on the trade radio.

So my question... let's say it could happen, and I doubt that it could... but anyway...
Shaw for Swallow or Shaw for Adams

Shaw for Adams. Shown more than Swallow despite the difference in draft pick and has also played one less year

dubber · Oct 3, 2013

SpongePie said:
Yeah that's what was said on the trade radio.

So my question... let's say it could happen, and I doubt that it could... but anyway...
Shaw for Swallow or Shaw for Adams

Tough question, line ball.. Swallow for me only cos he is taller and stronger than Adams..Only 10 months older but has played 20 more games.

Rustin Cohle · Oct 3, 2013

Do not rate Swallow. He won't be as good as his brother.

jabbers · Oct 3, 2013

Atheist said:
Do not rate Swallow. He won't be as good as his brother.

He is better now! Better user of the ball, just got injured this year. His averages are almost identical to his brother. He is bigger, faster and 6 years younger.

morgoth · Oct 3, 2013

I just cannot see GC trading out Swallow for a pick.

They have plenty of young talent coming through, they need mature players to rill holes in their side. FF and CHB stand out.

dap · Oct 3, 2013

Rumour on Facebook that Patton was in Melbourne today meeting with the Saints. If this is true, he could be on the move.

CoreyBurnett1 · Oct 3, 2013

If we got pick 2 off the dees could we trade that for Adams & Patton?

morgoth · Oct 3, 2013

Fisher and their first rounder would be the offer I reckon.

GWS have been rumoured to be interested in Fisher for some time so add him to their first rounder pick 3? and it would go close I reckon. Aints needs a replacement for Reiwoldt.

dap · Oct 3, 2013

morgoth said:
Fisher and their first rounder would be the offer I reckon.

GWS have been rumoured to be interested in Fisher for some time so add him to their first rounder pick 3? and it would go close I reckon. Aints needs a replacement for Reiwoldt.

That would be about on the money I reckon. Damn, would love him at the Pies.

Old Spice · Oct 3, 2013

morgoth said:
Fisher and their first rounder would be the offer I reckon.

GWS have been rumoured to be interested in Fisher for some time so add him to their first rounder pick 3? and it would go close I reckon. Aints needs a replacement for Reiwoldt.

How on earth would a dubious Fisher fit a GWS need? Old as the hills and dubious off-field behaviour. No way on god's green earth.

Old Spice · Oct 3, 2013

dap said:
Rumour on Facebook that Patton was in Melbourne today meeting with the Saints. If this is true, he could be on the move.

If Patton went to the Saints, I'd be all over Riewoldt like a ****ing rash.

I'd give them pick 11.

DWil6 · Oct 3, 2013

Old Spice said:
If Patton went to the Saints, I'd be all over Riewoldt like a ******* rash.

I'd give them pick 11.

If he was younger...

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk - now Free

CoreyBurnett1 · Oct 3, 2013

DWil6 said:
If he was younger...

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk - now Free

He has experience for player like Darcy Moore coming through the system and once he's done he could be a fwd development coach

Tbone McGraw · Oct 3, 2013

Old Spice said:
If Patton went to the Saints, I'd be all over Riewoldt like a ******* rash.

I'd give them pick 11.

Interesting you would give up pick 11 for reiwoldt. A chance at one of the best kids in the country for a bloke that appears past it to me and has 3 years max imo.

However, I want to make it clear, I am not attacking your opinion as I respect your posting.

Can I ask what you thinks he would bring to pies to make it worth pick 11?

If we did want to do this, I think saints would jump at it in their rebuilding phase.

ash84 · Oct 3, 2013

Tbone McGraw said:
Interesting you would give up pick 11 for reiwoldt. A chance at one of the best kids in the country for a bloke that appears past it to me and has 3 years max imo.

However, I want to make it clear, I am not attacking your opinion as I respect your posting.

Can I ask what you thinks he would bring to pies to make it worth pick 11?

If we did want to do this, I think saints would jump at it in their rebuilding phase.

I thought Reiwoldt had a really good year this year.

dunno4 · Oct 3, 2013

Daicosssssssssss said:
Kruzer = Fraser MK2

I have been saying this for 3 years! Couldn't agree more.

Tbone McGraw · Oct 3, 2013

ash84 said:
I thought Reiwoldt had a really good year this year.

Fair enough but would you give pick 11.

I am skipping round my point but no way I would give up 11 for reiwoldt.

However always interested in other opinions.

NT.Thunder · Oct 3, 2013

ash84 said:
I thought Reiwoldt had a really good year this year.

He did early but as usual his body really felt the strains of footy over the last few weeks.
We would need White, Lynch & Riewoldt all in the one team to rotate them each week like EPL

beez · Oct 3, 2013

I've heard whispers on this board that loki04 is considering taking a week's break from Bigfooty as a self-imposed punishment for his apparent ridiculous
"Dayne Beams also seeking trade!" thread. The one week break is likely to go down after the end of the player transfer window, although the powerful rulers of this board may deem to hand down the punishment at any given time with a bright red card.

loki04 · Oct 3, 2013

beez said:
I've heard whispers on this board that loki04 is considering taking a week's break from Bigfooty as a self-imposed punishment for his apparent ridiculous
"Dayne Beams also seeking trade!" thread. The one week break is likely to go down after the end of the player transfer window, although the powerful rulers of this board may deem to hand down the punishment at any given time with a bright red card.

lmao.

I reckon half the board had coronary's reading my thread title.

soreplums · Oct 3, 2013

loki04 said:
lmao.

I reckon half the board had coronary's reading my thread title.

I sharted

jefffff34 · Oct 4, 2013

speedytiger said:
Going home Mitch Clarke style?

I can't see Swallow having reasons to get as much money, as quickly as possible like Clark did/does.

Obese Arachnid · Oct 4, 2013

Hoggy said:
I can't see Swallow having reasons to get as much money, as quickly as possible like Clark did/does.

I think it's fair enough A. Swallow should cost more.

Log In or Create New Account

Rumour Thread

Club Legend

Premium Platinum

Club Legend

Anvil's death stare

Flat Circle

Club Legend

Brownlow Medallist

Rookie

Team Captain

Brownlow Medallist

Rookie

Norm Smith Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Team Captain

Norm Smith Medallist

Club Legend

All Australian

Norm Smith Medallist

K2 Party Platter

A*mazing

Hall of Famer

Norm Smith Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Diplomatic Immunity

Rumour Thread

Similar threads