Ryan Grifffen or Marc Murphy

[Jeremias]

Homework mate.

...and I see you are doing it well by being on BF

 

[F/D]

...and I see you are doing it well by being on BF

 

[DynamoUltra]

10 possies in the 1st for Griff.

And he's butchered about 8 of them.

 

[cs61]

I'd take Griffen at this stage because of the way he uses it.

 

[Ysaye]

Griffen is a more complete player for mine. Plus Freo already has it's bag of small midfielders with dodgy kicks.

 

[Jeremias]

Griffen is a more complete player for mine. Plus Freo already has it's bag of small midfielders with dodgy kicks.

and Murph would replace them because he doesn't have a dodgy kick...

 

[Ysaye]

and Murph would replace them because he doesn't have a dodgy kick...

I must be really unlucky, but every time I have seen Murphy he has kicked a bag of clangers.

But as you say, Murphy would probably replace more than a few of our guys

 

[F/D]

And he's butchered about 8 of them.

29 possies now.

Let me guess, hes butchered about 21 of them?

 

[DynamoUltra]

29 possies now.

Let me guess, hes butchered about 21 of them?

Has he hit a target all day? Even his handballs are sloppy. Usually he's got slick disposal, but today has been ordinary.

 

[F/D]

Has he hit a target all day? Even his handballs are sloppy. Usually he's got slick disposal, but today has been ordinary.

Still a top class youngster.

 

[DynamoUltra]

Still a top class youngster.

Yes, but today his disposal, and the rest of the Bulldog's side for that matter, was the difference between a Kangaroo's win and a Bulldog's win.

 

[TheBacko]

murphy has shown more in his first year. he has done better than deledio's first year before he got injured, so based on that he looks like he will have a bigger impact for his club in the future than griffen. having said that, its easier for him to stand out in a crap team.

 

[The Grover]

Carlton supporter who is rapt with Murphy, haven't seen a lot of Griffen.

What I have seen he looks very good has pace & is very strong as well.

Looks as though he has some height as well.

If I had a choice between Griffen & Cooney I think I'd take Griffen.

 

[Bentleigh]

murphy has shown more in his first year. he has done better than deledio's first year before he got injured, so based on that he looks like he will have a bigger impact for his club in the future than griffen. having said that, its easier for him to stand out in a crap team.

Dunno about that.

Lids had a solid first 2/3's of the season and a huge Round 16-22.

 

[celtic_pride]

All these comparisons of young players is a bit pointless at the moment. Try again in 3 years time I reckon.

 

[Silvagnis]

Griffen, we don't need Murphy we have Sam Mitchell.

You needed Eliis and you don't need a replacement for Crawford!

How quick is Mitchell?

Does he run and carry the ball as much as Murph?

Has he kicked a running like Murphy did against the Tigers and Roos?

Your side isn't in the position to knock back either of them and Murph has kicked more goals than Mitchell this year.