Stats & History S31 Rules & Tribunal Thread

[Barrybran]

That would be difficult for him. Halfie cries whenever he cuts something. "Allergies" he says.

Ah, that explains his departure from the Furies then

 

[The Half Back]

Not his own team though so clearly it's a violation.

Haha how can someone be temp captain of a team they don't play for? C'mon rook.

I didn't get in trouble for doing it last season, so why should I get in trouble this time? Grow up Cads you twat.

 

[Dav]

Joke teamsheets have always been allowed, it's just the captain's one supersedes any others.

 

[The Half Back]

If Barrybran forgets to put one in this week, he'll thank me for it.

 

[Barrybran]

If Barrybran forgets to put one in this week, he'll thank me for it.

I doubt it

 

[Cadsky]

If Barrybran forgets to put one in this week, he'll thank me for it.

Barrybran doesn't forget to put them in. Just misses deadlines

 

[Barrybran]

Barrybran doesn't forget to put them in. Just misses deadlines

The All-SFA berths mean more when you increase the difficulty by missing games and still get in before Headless

 

[serial_thrilla]

Cool. I'll be naming the other 11 teams shortly.

I've got dibs on the Warriors team. Bad luck Tonga Bob - you're cut.

 

[DenieD]

I've got dibs on the Warriors team. Bad luck Tonga Bob - you're cut.

Can you put me in the midfield?

 

[serial_thrilla]

Can you put me in the midfield?

No. Back pocket.

 

[DenieD]

No. Back pocket.

Still better than Headless. At least I'm on the field.

 

[Tonga Bob]

I've got dibs on the Warriors team. Bad luck Tonga Bob - you're cut.

I had a good run.

 

[GremioPower]

Still better than Headless. At least I'm on the field.

But there is no competition for best BP yet, unlike for best IC.

 

[ClarkeM]

FOLL: RU – RR – RO

Quick one (genuinely asking), since when has this been the abbreviation and will we still accept "Ruck" "Rover" "Rov" "R-R" or are we that strict on exact abbreviations?

I get not using "R" as that can be confusing but surely a line of "Ruck - RR - Rov" would still work no?

 

[Barrybran]

Quick one (genuinely asking), since when has this been the abbreviation and will we still accept "Ruck" "Rover" "Rov" "R-R" or are we that strict on exact abbreviations?

I get not using "R" as that can be confusing but surely a line of "Ruck - RR - Rov" would still work no?

The abbreviations per the sim are "Ruck-RR-R" and I argued RU-RR-RO as a matter of common sense a couple of seasons ago. There shouldn't really be any need to deviate from either of those.

 

[NaturalDisaster]

Quick one (genuinely asking), since when has this been the abbreviation and will we still accept "Ruck" "Rover" "Rov" "R-R" or are we that strict on exact abbreviations?

I get not using "R" as that can be confusing but surely a line of "Ruck - RR - Rov" would still work no?

Stick to the format above please

 

[ClarkeM]

So is there a penalty if a team uses "Rov" instead of "Ro"? NaturalDisaster

 

[Dingster]

So is there a penalty if a team uses "Rov" instead of "Ro"? NaturalDisaster

Failure to submit a team sheet in the correct format (20 eligible players, positional changes, correct spelling of every name within the whole team sheet and in the team sheet submission thread), or AT ALL will result in penalties under Sec [6] of the Rules

 

[ClarkeM]

The abbreviations per the sim are "Ruck-RR-R" and I argued RU-RR-RO as a matter of common sense a couple of seasons ago. There shouldn't really be any need to deviate from either of those.

Stick to the format above please

The format above or the format in the OP?

 

[ClarkeM]

Failure to submit a team sheet in the correct format (20 eligible players, positional changes, correct spelling of every name within the whole team sheet and in the team sheet submission thread), or AT ALL will result in penalties under Sec [6] of the Rules

Which is the penalty for using Rov and not Ro?


6A) High impact

The following list of offences will result in a 2 point deduction in league standings, and 1 game suspension for a team’s listed captain(s):

• Failing to submit a valid initial squad and changes in the squad submission thread by deadline as per 4A
• Failing to satisfy the minimum initial squad list requirement (22 eligible players) as per 4A
• Failing to satisfy the minimum team list requirement in season (20 eligible players) as per 4A
• Failure to submit a complete team sheet in the submission thread by the deadline as per 5A
• Editing the team sheet after team sheet deadline as per 5A
• Deliberately hindering the simulation team through disregard of 5A, 5B and/or 5C.

6B) Medium Impact

The following list of offences will result in a 1 game suspension for a team’s listed captain(s), and any offending player:

• Failing to satisfy the maximum squad list requirement in season (27 eligible players) as per 4A
• Incorrect squad changes as per 4B
• Incorrect player signing as per 4C and 4D
• Incorrect positional changes on a team sheet as per 5A
• Naming an ineligible player on a team sheet as per 5B

6C) Low Impact

The following list of offences will result in a suspended 1 game suspension for a team’s listed captain(s), and any offending player:

• Incorrect spelling of player names in a team sheet as per 5A
• Incorrect team sheet formatting as per 5A
• Any post in the squad submission thread notifying a squad change that did not occur as per 4A & 4B

 

[ClarkeM]

I just want to be very clear on this because the way I see it is that we're asked to follow the abbreviations and formatting yet there's no rule regarding incorrect spelling of a positional change.

It's not "Incorrect team sheet formatting" (6C) because that references the Team Sheet, not the abbreviations in the changes list.
Is it "Incorrect positional changes on a team sheet" (6B) even though the positional change isn't incorrect? How do we see this?

Should this be changed to "Incorrect positional changes and/or abbreviations on a team sheet" to be inclusive of this if we're saying that we want to be strict on this exact formatting?

 

[Barrybran]

I just want to be very clear on this because the way I see it is that we're asked to follow the abbreviations and formatting yet there's no rule regarding incorrect spelling of a positional change.

It's not "Incorrect team sheet formatting" (6C) because that references the Team Sheet, not the abbreviations in the changes list.
Is it "Incorrect positional changes on a team sheet" (6B) even though the positional change isn't incorrect? How do we see this?

Should this be changed to "Incorrect positional changes and/or abbreviations on a team sheet" to be inclusive of this if we're saying that we want to be strict on this exact formatting?

I'd call it a formatting issue personally however I'm not the one dishing out penalties

 

[Dingster]

I just want to be very clear on this because the way I see it is that we're asked to follow the abbreviations and formatting yet there's no rule regarding incorrect spelling of a positional change.

It's not "Incorrect team sheet formatting" (6C) because that references the Team Sheet, not the abbreviations in the changes list.
Is it "Incorrect positional changes on a team sheet" (6B) even though the positional change isn't incorrect? How do we see this?

Should this be changed to "Incorrect positional changes and/or abbreviations on a team sheet" to be inclusive of this if we're saying that we want to be strict on this exact formatting?

I'd call it a formatting issue personally however I'm not the one dishing out penalties

Agree Baz. Low impact - under formatting.

 

[ClarkeM]

Agree Baz. Low impact - under formatting.

If only there was a low, low impact for such a minor, minor indiscretion...

 

[Agent93]

Incorrect positional changes on a team sheet as per 5A

That one.

Edit: Baz and Ding suck. Go for the throat.