Stats & History S31 Rules & Tribunal Thread

[VainGlorious]

Make them play the Bombers. Whoever the Dragons and Bombers play can play each other instead.

No campaigner. We played them 3 ****ing times last season and that’s 3 ****ing times too many!

They’re Dragons. They’ve got a sheep playing for them. They don’t eat the sheep.

They are ****ing FRAUDS!

 

[TJASTA]

Do we have a rule in place for punishing massive ****ing nerds?

 

[serial_thrilla]

Do we have a rule in place for punishing massive ******* nerds?
View attachment 1059899

No. I checked.

 

[Cadsky]

No. I checked.

You should do a new media thread Analysis about it

 

[Ned_Flanders]

Furies official response serial_thrilla



Lady Godava made her older so you'd at least have half a shot

 

[Cadsky]

Furies official response serial_thrilla

View attachment 1059962

Lady Godava made her older so you'd at least have half a shot

HOT

 

[Barrybran]

HOT

Yeah. I don't mind a little head.

 

[Test Tickle]

Yeah. I don't mind a little head.

well yeah, now that you mention it

 

[RelaxMax]

I really like the flamboyant use of the green chisel-tip texta

It's bold AF!!!

 

[Ned_Flanders]

I really like the flamboyant use of the green chisel-tip texta

It's bold AF!!!

That's how we roll at the Furies

 

[NaturalDisaster]

Case 2 - Swapped Interchanges.

The West Coast Wonders have been charged with violating Section 5A with an incorrect positional change in their R3 team sheet.

5A) Submission Rules

The deadline for team sheet submission is the Thursday 11:59 PM Melbourne Time before a match unless stated otherwise by the Administrator

• Team sheets must be displayed in a logical format that is comprehensible by the game simmers. Each positional line {e.g. B, HB, C, HF, F, Foll, INT} must be defined clearly and in case of positional changes the specific positions must be communicated in the listed changes. The only acceptable format is:

B: BP – FB – BP

HB: HBF – CHB – HBF

C: W – C – W

HF: HFF – CHF – HFF

F: FP – FF – FP

FOLL: RU – RR – RO

INT: INT – INT
CHANGES:

• All positional changes from the previous round MUST be noted correctly in the Team Sheet Submission, including swapping from LHS positions to RHS positions
• Teams must contain 20 eligible players, and be submitted in a single post in the Official Team Sheet Submission Thread each round.
• The team submission post must carry a uniquely team identifying characteristic, (eg team logo) and the correct round number.
• Maliciously hindering the simmers from doing their jobs, by any deliberate acts to alter the team sheet such that simmers have additional difficulty in reading using them, will not be tolerated.

Failure to submit a team sheet in the correct format (20 eligible players, positional changes, correct spelling of every name within the whole team sheet and in the team sheet submission thread), or AT ALL will result in penalties under Sec [6] of the Rules

In their R2 teamsheet, the Wonders had former skipper Sab22 was named on the right hand side of the interchange bench.

Round 2 vs Baghdad Bombers
West Coast Wonders Official Team Sheet


B: Cadsky - BallaratBulldog - Kangaroos4eva
HB: SweetD - AngryRanga - mezaire
C: croweater 41 - Crusty Undies - ClarkeM
HF: JT_the_Man - bomberlegend2007 - jezzajay
F: Grand Uncle Horace - dogs105 - Off Tap
FOLL: ArdentEagle - haydo – SSwans2011

INT: BlueMaster1 – Sab22

Changes

croweater 41 FP to W
Cadsky C to BP
Off Tap W to FP
mezaire RO to HBF
ClarkeM HBF to W
SSwans2011 W to RO
AngryRanga INT to CHB
Kangaroos4eva CHB to BP
Crusty Undies INT to C
bomberlegend2007 BP to CHF
BlueMaster1 CHF to INT
Sab22 Out to INT
akkaps BP to OUT

In their Round 3 Team Sheet, they dropped Sab22 for craffles, putting BallaratBulldog on the Interchange bench. However, their mistake was the unnoted swapping of BlueMaster1 and BallaratBulldog.

Round 3 vs Coney Island Warriors FFC
Official Team Sheet

B: mezaire - Grand Uncle Horace - Kangaroos4eva
HB: SweetD - AngryRanga - Off Tap
C: croweater 41 - Cadsky - ClarkeM
HF: JT_the_Man - craffles - jezzajay
F: bomberlegend2007 - dogs105 - SSwans2011
FOLL: ArdentEagle - haydo – Crusty Undies

INT: BallaratBulldog – BlueMaster1

Changes

Sab22 INT to OUT

Off Tap FP to HBF

mezaire HBF to BP

Cadsky BP to C

BallaratBulldog FB to INT

craffles OUT to CHF

Crusty Undies C to RO

SSwans2011 RO to FP

bomberlegend2007 CHF to FP

Grand Uncle Horace FP to FB

As this is technically an incorrect positional change, this is regarded as a Medium Impact offence, which means Wonders Co-Captains Cadsky and haydo will serve a one match suspension in Round 4.

6B) Medium Impact

The following list of offences will result in a 1 game suspension for a team’s listed captain(s), and any offending player:

• Failing to satisfy the maximum squad list requirement in season (27 eligible players) as per 4A
• Incorrect squad changes as per 4B
• Incorrect player signing as per 4C and 4D
• Incorrect positional changes on a team sheet as per 5A
• Naming an ineligible player on a team sheet as per 5B

As per usual, the West Coast Wonders have the right to appeal this decision. If they wish to appeal, they have until 11.59pm Sunday 21/02 to do so.

 

[Santoz]

Case 2 - Swapped Interchanges.

The West Coast Wonders have been charged with violating Section 5A with an incorrect positional change in their R3 team sheet.




In their R2 teamsheet, the Wonders had former skipper Sab22 was named on the right hand side of the interchange bench.




In their Round 3 Team Sheet, they dropped Sab22 for craffles, putting BallaratBulldog on the Interchange bench. However, their mistake was the unnoted swapping of BlueMaster1 and BallaratBulldog.



As this is technically an incorrect positional change, this is regarded as a Medium Impact offence, which means Wonders Co-Captains Sab22 and haydo will serve a one match suspension in Round 4.



View attachment 1061510

As per usual, the West Coast Wonders have the right to appeal this decision. If they wish to appeal, they have until 11.59pm Sunday 21/02 to do so.

Have they given Cadsky the flick already?

Lol.

 

[PMBangers]

Ruour has it they purposefully got suspended so they don't have to face the Hawks

 

[craffles]

Case 2 - Swapped Interchanges.

The West Coast Wonders have been charged with violating Section 5A with an incorrect positional change in their R3 team sheet.




In their R2 teamsheet, the Wonders had former skipper Sab22 was named on the right hand side of the interchange bench.




In their Round 3 Team Sheet, they dropped Sab22 for craffles, putting BallaratBulldog on the Interchange bench. However, their mistake was the unnoted swapping of BlueMaster1 and BallaratBulldog.



As this is technically an incorrect positional change, this is regarded as a Medium Impact offence, which means Wonders Co-Captains Sab22 and haydo will serve a one match suspension in Round 4.



View attachment 1061510

As per usual, the West Coast Wonders have the right to appeal this decision. If they wish to appeal, they have until 11.59pm Sunday 21/02 to do so.

Power tripping flogs

 

[Headless]

BREAKING NEWS

In a breakthrough moment for the Sweet FA, league administration has this morning recognised for the first time that interchange players exist.

"Yeah, it turns out there are actually 20 players named on the team sheet - not 18," mused NaturalDisaster.

More to come.

 

[NaturalDisaster]

BREAKING NEWS

In a breakthrough moment for the Sweet FA, league administration has this morning recognised for the first time that interchange players exist.

"Yeah, it turns out there are actually 20 players named on the team sheet - not 18," mused NaturalDisaster.

More to come.

Must you use my admin hammer wielding as a chance to push your agenda? ffs

 

[Headless]

Must you use my admin hammer wielding as a chance to push your agenda? ffs

I simply must - thanks for asking.

 

[TedDougChris]

BREAKING NEWS

In a breakthrough moment for the Sweet FA, league administration has this morning recognised for the first time that interchange players exist.

"Yeah, it turns out there are actually 20 players named on the team sheet - not 18," mused NaturalDisaster.

More to come.

Actually incorrect Headless !! Still funny though !

 

[Santoz]

While we're convening, can this be dealt with too please?

It's a terrible look for the SFA

 

[TJASTA]

throw the book at them

 

[Dingster]

Cadsky and haydo - Ned_Flanders knows a good lawyer.

 

[ClarkeM]

Yes, I'm a Wonders person yada yada ya and I am all for the learning of lessons for captains - especially new captains. It's a rite of passage essentially, especially for Cadsky as the young skipper fresh into the role.

I genuinely think that an immediate 1 match suspension for interchange benches being swapped around is a ridiculously harsh punishment for what is at the lowest end of the spectrum in terms of "positional change offenses". Then again, all of this is ridiculous to me and always has been.

Whatever the outcome is, I'll accept it as a patron of the club. It's a breach of the rules, I ain't doubting that, I just doubt that the penalty is fitting to the crime because I really can't see how it is. Understanding of course though that this is a blanket rule of all positional changes and has been written as such.

PS: By your definition NaturalDisaster, if you're going to convict the captains of breaching an incorrect positional change, therefore by your own interpretation, the interchange is a position and thus, why don't we see an interchange position in the All-SFA. Why isn't Headless more up in arms about this (and now I've just seen his post haha) ?

 

[Cadsky]

LOL

 

[serial_thrilla]

LOL

But were all your hyphens in the correct location???

 

[TedDougChris]

Yes, I'm a Wonders person yada yada ya and I am all for the learning of lessons for captains - especially new captains. It's a rite of passage essentially, especially for Cadsky as the young skipper fresh into the role.

I genuinely think that an immediate 1 match suspension for interchange benches being swapped around is a ridiculously harsh punishment for what is at the lowest end of the spectrum in terms of "positional change offenses". Then again, all of this is ridiculous to me and always has been.

Whatever the outcome is, I'll accept it as a patron of the club. It's a breach of the rules, I ain't doubting that, I just doubt that the penalty is fitting to the crime because I really can't see how it is. Understanding of course though that this is a blanket rule of all positional changes and has been written as such.

PS: By your definition NaturalDisaster, if you're going to convict the captains of breaching an incorrect positional change, therefore by your own interpretation, the interchange is a position and thus, why don't we see an interchange position in the All-SFA. Why isn't Headless more up in arms about this (and now I've just seen his post haha) ?

Precedent already exists for this penalty !!