Rules S33 Rules & Tribunal Thread

[Grand Uncle Horace]

Banning Bangers from the Admin race would punish those enjoying the absurdist entertainment.

 

[Barrybran]

Banning Bangers from the Admin race would punish those enjoying the absurdist entertainment.

Removing PMBangers from the admin race would be unnecessary and unfair. Pointing and laughing at him is more than enough.

 

[Cadsky]

Removing PMBangers from the admin race would be unnecessary and unfair. Pointing and laughing at him is more than enough.

We should take this to the #barrybran4admin war room

 

[TRUMAN#1]

So what's the go, have they thrown the book at the Royals yet?

 

[philreich]

Removing PMBangers from the admin race would be unnecessary and unfair. Pointing and laughing at him is more than enough.

I've never had a problem laughing at the misfortunes of others......

 

[The Filth Wizard]

So what's the go, have they thrown the book at the Royals yet?

It’s not our fault although Bangers should be killed.

 

[TedDougChris]

It’s not our fault although Bangers should be killed.

 

[nahnah]

NaturalDisaster the Royals have decided to accept the punishment of suspending our captain for a full season instead of the 2 premiership point deduction

 

[NaturalDisaster]

Update:

The Royals elected to appeal and it went to a committee a vote. It was a near unanimous decision to uphold the charge. Therefore, the week suspension on PMBangers will remain as will the 2 point penalty deducation.

 

[nahnah]

NaturalDisaster the Royals have decided to accept the punishment of suspending our captain for a full season instead of the 2 premiership point deduction

 

[Metalcrusher]

NaturalDisaster the Royals have decided to accept the punishment of suspending our captain for a full season instead of the 2 premiership point deduction

Does that mean The Filth Wizard takes back the crown??

 

[The Filth Wizard]

Update:

The Royals elected to appeal and it went to a committee a vote. It was a near unanimous decision to uphold the charge. Therefore, the week suspension on PMBangers will remain as will the 2 point penalty deducation.

I’d be interested to see the rationale here after the precedent set by the Bombers not losing points.

 

[DenieD]

I’d be interested to see the rationale here after the precedent set by the Bombers not losing points.

I was led to believe that the rules are not 'law' in Sweet-FA and just a guideline from what happened with the Bombers. So in that sense precendent cases don't have any affect. They are all judged on a case-by-case basis and cannot be compared to anything previously voted on by the committee.

 

[The Filth Wizard]

I was led to believe that the rules are not 'law' in Sweet-FA and just a guideline from what happened with the Bombers. So in that sense precendent cases don't have any affect. They are all judged on a case-by-case basis and cannot be compared to anything previously voted on by the committee.

Are you saying we hired a dud lawyer? Bangers strike 2.

IMO all points penalties should have been thrown out of the rules with the first time a team was deemed not responsible and not expected to lose points. There’s no discernible difference between the two in that regard.

Of course we all know the committee needed two shots to get that one right too.

 

[BLUEALLTHRU]

Are you saying we hired a dud lawyer? Bangers strike 2.

IMO all points penalties should have been thrown out of the rules with the first time a team was deemed not responsible and not expected to lose points. There’s no discernible difference between the two in that regard.

Of course we all know the committee needed two shots to get that one right too.

Yes ban Bangers for the season but ffs the 2 points must be squashed.

 

[The Filth Wizard]

Yes ban Bangers for the season but ffs the 2 points must be squashed.

It was a good opportunity for a committee stand. It was a one person error and by error I mean innocent accident. Another club will miss finals through this and could have prevented that now.

 

[NaturalDisaster]

It was a good opportunity for a committee stand. It was a one person error and by error I mean innocent accident. Another club will miss finals through this and could have prevented that now.

and there was not one person in the 7 person LG who did not notice no teamsheet by 9:30-10 and posted something in the LG PM?

 

[BLUEALLTHRU]

It was a good opportunity for a committee stand. It was a one person error and by error I mean innocent accident. Another club will miss finals through this and could have prevented that now.

It's a ridiculous punishment imo.

 

[ImissFrosty]

and there was not one person in the 7 person LG who did not notice no teamsheet by 9:30-10 and posted something in the LG PM?

It's really just a punishment for incompetence. Not for the crime. And i'm all for it.

 

[BLUEALLTHRU]

It's really just a punishment for incompetence. Not for the crime. And i'm all for it.

You would be.

 

[ImissFrosty]

You would be.

once again bat, i'm really not sure what you mean by that. If a 7 man LG can't pick up on a basic error they deserve to be punished.

 

[BLUEALLTHRU]

once again bat, i'm really not sure what you mean by that. If a 7 man LG can't pick up on a basic error they deserve to be punished.

A precedent has already been set this season, how is this any different to the Bombers error? Ban the Skipper/Skippers but be ****ed if the whole team should suffer. This decision lacks common sense.

 

[Barrybran]

It was a good opportunity for a committee stand. It was a one person error and by error I mean innocent accident. Another club will miss finals through this and could have prevented that now.

Filth, you know I love you but the only reason you're crying foul is because its your team. Everyone knows the drill as far as deadlines go.

4A) Submission Rules - Teams need to be submitted by the time specified in the OP. If no time is specified in the OP, it can be assumed that the deadline for submission is the Thursday 11:59 PM Melbourne Time before a match. Teams must contain 20 eligible players, be submitted by the deadline and state "Official Team Sheet" in the same post. Teams must note positional changes from the previous round, including where the player played last round and where they are playing this round. Failure to submit a team sheet in the correct format (20 eligible players, positional changes, correct spelling of every name within the whole team sheet and "official team sheet" in same post), or AT ALL will result in one of the following punishments based on the appropriate grading:

High Impact (results in an instant four point penalty):
Failure to submit a complete team sheet by the deadline.

 

[ImissFrosty]

A precedent has already been set this season, how is this any different to the Bombers error? Ban the Skipper/Skippers but be f’ed if the whole team should suffer. This decision lacks common sense.

What Baz just said. There's a rule, it was broken, there's a punishment.

 

[NaturalDisaster]

A precedent has already been set this season, how is this any different to the Bombers error? Ban the Skipper/Skippers but be f’ed if the whole team should suffer. This decision lacks common sense.

Anyone in the team can post a teamsheet.

No one took responsibility when the teamsheet wasn't posted by 11.59 pm.