Opinion Sack Hinkley 3 - 2021 is worse than 2020 already

[1954]

I like his Bold Personality

But about as smart as Hayden Haitana.

 

[thundercloud]

Against everybodymoan

a dour stayer, was tried on the flat and as a last resort before sacking to the knackery was tried over the jumps.
can make up position in the field by a sequence of short, repetitious spurts
when given a spell has to be placed in a paddock by self as has one anti social habit.
also shows jealously towards the resident head stud stallion.

has been a consistent performer and has a dogged determination shown throughout his 8 years on the provincial turf tracks. The one to beat and will strive to hold position right to the 100 post mark.

been strong betting support as punters know what they get with this performer.

 

[thundercloud]

I have absolutely no idea what's going on any more.

Starting to consider posting pancake recipes - would make as much sense as anything else in this thread
[/QUOTE

clue check the top contributories at top of page and the top 3 posters

 

[Powerade 08]

Sack the resident head stud stallion

 

[Grave Danger]

Hinkley is Bold Personality but Koch thinks he's Fine Cotton.

Yesterday, today was tomorrow
And tomorrow, today will be yesterday
So ring out the old
Ring in the new
Ring out the old
Ring in the new

 

[Forzaport]

We'll Mayes didn't play a game. However, we 'played the youf' by making sure:
- Ryder got more games than Frampton, Ladhams and Marshall combined, then got traded.
- Broadbent got 6 more games than Garner, then got delisted
- S Gray got 13 more games than Farrell, Cox & Woodcock combined then got delisted

Hmmmm.

Sackable.

Burning that number of games on cooked players and Sam Gray when the team wasn't a premiership threat is awful list management.

Hinkley must have been worried about his job to rely on mature players so often. The selected round 22 team was the epitome of short term decision making. We must have been very close to sacking him and whoever/whatever stopped that sacking needs to be removed from the decision making process.

 

[Ilias M]

While many codes show accountability PAFC are and have always been in the AFL an amateur mentality

News

All the latest news from across the A-Leagues including, A-League Men, A-League Women, Australia Cup, A-League Youth, AFC Champions League and more!

www.a-league.com.au

 

[afl2004]

 

[Expat power]

I love it every time someone with an unpopular opinion uses this meme.

 

[Expat power]

I was born in 1988.

25 years after the baby boomers mate. I was 16 when I saw us win our first AFL flag so seen the good times.

So you’re not a boomer, you just sound like one

 

[Granny Duurs is Lovely]

Sackable.

Burning that number of games on cooked players and Sam Gray when the team wasn't a premiership threat is awful list management.

Hinkley must have been worried about his job to rely on mature players so often. The selected round 22 team was the epitome of short term decision making. We must have been very close to sacking him and whoever/whatever stopped that sacking needs to be removed from the decision making process.

This is such a poor and weak attitude to have. We beat West coast and Geelong and barely lost to GWS (and we should've won). Our best WAS good enough. We should have been playing the best team to get us the result every week - not gifting youth games. If the youth was the best available then they play, but Farrell wasnt better than S Gray, Garner wasnt better than Broadbent and Frampton wasn't better than Ryder.

In fact you could easily make the argument that playing youth cost us making finals after playing Ladhams over Lycett backfired so spectacularly against North.

 

[Papa G]

So you’re not a boomer, you just sound like one

I always assumed the 66 was his birth year.

 

[El Zorro]

I always assumed the 66 was his birth year.

Which would make him a Gen X...

 

[Papa G]

Which would make him a Gen X...

I get that but it seems boomers now incorporate anyone over 40.

 

[Ilias M]

View attachment 806304

He’s absolutely correct!

 

[Sleezy]

This is such a poor and weak attitude to have. We beat West coast and Geelong and barely lost to GWS (and we should've won). Our best WAS good enough. We should have been playing the best team to get us the result every week - not gifting youth games. If the youth was the best available then they play, but Farrell wasnt better than S Gray, Garner wasnt better than Broadbent and Frampton wasn't better than Ryder.

In fact you could easily make the argument that playing youth cost us making finals after playing Ladhams over Lycett backfired so spectacularly against North.

What'll really bake your noodle? The wins against West Coast (6th place) & Geelong (3rd place) were our 7th and 6th youngest teams we presented all year.

 

[philthy05]

If the youth was the best available then they play, but Farrell wasnt better than S Gray, Garner wasnt better than Broadbent and Frampton wasn't better than Ryder.

That’s a bad call. Broady was well cooked, and Sam Gray had his chance.

 

[Willsy10]

View attachment 806304

A flurry of what from mark williams?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Forzaport]

* even old man Cornes can see it

 

[Duckimus Prime]

While many codes show accountability PAFC are and have always been in the AFL an amateur mentality

News

All the latest news from across the A-Leagues including, A-League Men, A-League Women, Australia Cup, A-League Youth, AFC Champions League and more!

www.a-league.com.au

This is an interesting one. Melbourne Victory sit in 6th place after 13 rounds.
In the 2015-16 A League season, Marco Kurz's previous employer Adelaide United sat in 7th place, with even less wins on record than Melbourne Victory currently do. Adelaide United did not sack Guillermo Amor when the club was winless holding up the bottom of the ladder after the first 8 rounds.

They ended up lifting the toilet seat that season.

Adelaide United even struggled in the first half of Kurz's initial season, they then improved in the second half, and the next year. This is Melbourne Victory making a premature call.

The thing is, those are examples of coaches in their first year, not their 7th... so sack Hinkley.

 

[Forzaport]

This is such a poor and weak attitude to have. We beat West coast and Geelong and barely lost to GWS (and we should've won). Our best WAS good enough. We should have been playing the best team to get us the result every week - not gifting youth games. If the youth was the best available then they play, but Farrell wasnt better than S Gray, Garner wasnt better than Broadbent and Frampton wasn't better than Ryder.

In fact you could easily make the argument that playing youth cost us making finals after playing Ladhams over Lycett backfired so spectacularly against North.

The club signalled that we were going the youth route but what Koch/KT were saying and what Ken was fielding were at odds. Was the North game the one Lycett was infamously dropped for because he gave an opinion?

 

[Enviable Tradition]

Brave eagle

a lightweight compared to the 2 clear cut outriders
connections are training him for a withering burst from the lesser lights near the 100 mark, but expected too far back in the field to close the gap
an eye catcher in the parade ring with 3 white patches near the hooves and a blazing white on the snout.
has been described as all show and no substance, but ye never know.
the bookies have taken a set against and offering double figure odds
as they say follow the money, but most have sacked this 4 year old entire from being in the winners circle.

Sack Hinkley

On SM-G960F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Enviable Tradition]

Against everybodymoan

a dour stayer, was tried on the flat and as a last resort before sacking to the knackery was tried over the jumps.
can make up position in the field by a sequence of short, repetitious spurts
when given a spell has to be placed in a paddock by self as has one anti social habit.
also shows jealously towards the resident head stud stallion.

has been a consistent performer and has a dogged determination shown throughout his 8 years on the provincial turf tracks. The one to beat and will strive to hold position right to the 100 post mark.

been strong betting support as punters know what they get with this performer.

Sack Hinkley

On SM-G960F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Jojay]

So Melbourne Victory have poached a rival coach and sacked him after 13 games, but we’re stuck with smooth brain.

We don't exist to win premierships.

 

[PAFC66]

So you’re not a boomer, you just sound like one

Pretty much.