Saints - Ins and Outs

[big_bad_blue]

All I can say is this competition for spots is GREAT
It's hard to remember such tough competition and still have a few players on the sideline - bring in Army, Hoops, Hammer, Banno, Harts


FWIW
In: Judd, Walker
Out: Anderson, Edwards

 

[BlueWorld]

http://carltonfc.com.au/tabid/4311/Default.aspx?newsid=62880

CARLTON coach Brett Ratten says captain Chris Judd will "play for sure" this Friday night against St Kilda, while midfielder Andrew Walker is in the mix for a return to the seniors.

 

[theduke37]

Just the 2 changes;

IN: Judd, Walker
OUT: Browne, Anderson

Match Ups:

Kosi - O'halpin
Riewoldt - Waite
Gardiner - Thornton
Milne - Grigg
Montagna - Gibbs



* Walker will play as the lead up CHF
* Edwards will start in the square with Fev
* Harvery dominates against Carlton everytime, maybe Gibbs to get him
* Judd, Stevens, Murphy, Bentick to go head to head with Hayes, Dal Santo, Baker, Harvey

 

[The Coach]

Edwards must stay in. Brought in for Freo game and did alright but dropped. Brought in last week and did alright - MC can't do it to him again

 

[Juddy Blue Blue]

FB: Carrazzo Thornton Jamison

HB: Walker Waite Scotland

C: Gibbs Stevens Murphy

HF: Grigg Kreuzer Simpson

FF: Fisher Fevola Betts

RR: Cloke Judd Bentick

Bench: Hampson, Browne, O'Alphin, Edwards

did you watch the richmond game? wiggins was very good and could never be dropped after that performance. wheres your head at?

 

[Shambolic]

Judd and Walker pick themselves. They will take the spots of someone in midfield and someone up forward or more general running roles. Browney has had a good go and done very well for a first year. He doesnt deserve to be dropped but he is expendable given those ins.

Anderson I really rate so id like to think he would stay in.

Im thinking with the weather we may lose a tall like Setanta.

 

[DaveyBlues]

Austin's gotta be premoted sometime, he must be feeling like he can't do anything to get a shot.

 

[Ole Gill]

Austin's gotta be premoted sometime, he must be feeling like he can't do anything to get a shot.

Not sure that the season defining game where he'll have to play on Riewolt is the best time to blood him

 

[BlueYoss]

My Ins would be

(INS)
Judd, Walker, Hartlett

(OUTS)
Edwards, Browne, Anderson.

I'd have to adopt Mentallo's rationale here:

Whats the point in dropping Jake after just 1 game?
No good at all for the kids confidence, and lets face it Russell has had plenty of opportunities and still continues to struggle at the top level.

 

[Mike_blues]

o hailpin dropped small for tall

 

[Shambolic]

o hailpin dropped small for tall

1. Gonna be wet and cold.
2. They only have 2 good bigmen
3. Their good big men havent always hurt us.
4. Their little fellows and mids have always hurt us - Hayes, Milne, Harvey
5. Matchups

I think its good and I called it above.