Saints V Crows - Votes

[schells_hunny27]

woops forgot team man and rookie

Best Team Man
3...Jason Torney
2...Mark Bickley
1...Nathan Bassett

dont have any votes for rookie!!

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Updated Votes

Keep them coming in! 18 voters so far...

Best on Ground
66 McLeod (5)
50 Torney (4)
43 Goodwin (3)
40 Edwards (2)
26 Johncôck (1)
10 Biglands
10 Bickley
8 Hart
5 Smart
4 Burton
4 Clarke
2 Bassett
2 Abstained
270 Total

Best Team Man
36 Bickley (3)
20 Biglands (2)
19 Torney (1)
9 Edwards
8 Clarke
5 Bassett
2 Johncôck
1 McLeod
1 Ricciuto
1 Smart
6 Abstained
108 Total

Best Rookie
3 Reilly
1 Mattner
14 Abstained
18 Total

Most people would prefer that we don't give a vote to the rookies this week, given that most have abstained. Unless I get quite a few disagreeing with this, I will not be giving a rookie vote this week.

PS Next week, someone else will need to tally the votes as I will be in NSW, including the Swans game. Hopefully I can get on the net for my votes though!

 

[Blues_Girl]

I refuse to vote. None of them were worthy of votes in my opinion.

 

[sapaul]

Re: Updated Votes

Originally posted by Kane McGoodwin

PS Next week, someone else will need to tally the votes as I will be in NSW, including the Swans game.

I'll do it if no body else wants to.

 

[macca23]

Re: Re: Updated Votes

Originally posted by sapaul
I'll do it if no body else wants to.

No one else wants to!!!

Congratulations on your new acting role!!

 

[ScottWelshLuva]

Originally posted by dyertribe
But he didn't.

The one that hit the post from that set shot from 40 out was dreadfully unlucky, but the one he missed on the run was unforgivable.

He'll learn from that and will improve as a result, which is a lot better option than working on ifs, buts and maybes.

geez im just trying to be positive

 

[ScottWelshLuva]

Originally posted by macca23
I'm not sure you understood Kane's suggestion. Of those people who actually vote, at least 50% must vote for the rookie to get a vote. E.g., if only 4 people vote for best players , rookie etc, then at least 2 have to give a rookie vote for it to count.

If there was a standout rookie as you nominated above then surely 2 of the 4 people would give him a vote.

There were no standouts yesterday.

I did understand him, i just dont like the idea.

But if majority rules, than i will just have to go with it

 

[crowsfan]

Late I know, but:

BOG:
5 - Edwards
4 - Torney
3 - McLeod
2 - Goodwin
1 - Riccuito

BTM:
3 - Edwards
2 - Torney
1 - Riccuito

Rookie
No votes

 

[Jars458]

Watched the game last night - we were nowhere near as bad as people were saying. Perhaps it feels better when you alreday know the result. Anyway my votes

5 A McLeod - tried hard all day
4 T Edwards
3 S Goodwin
2 J Torney
1 N Bassett

Team man

3 M Bickley
2 J Torney
1 A McLeod


Rookie

B Reilly - did enough IMO. CErtainly more than doughty did last year to get some of his votes.

Gallagher was ok as well I thought.

Only difference was the forward lines. They got goalcickers and we did not.

 

[Jars458]

Originally posted by Blues_Girl
I refuse to vote. None of them were worthy of votes in my opinion.

Rubbish

What an over reaction

Lets not jump off so soon shall we

Saints intensity and pace was excellent. We had no forwards and still only lost by eight

We WILL bounce back this week.

 

[Crow54]

Hmmm. I watched the replay yesterday, and thought, to start with anyway, that it didn't look as bad on TV as it did at the actual game. But as things went on it got worse

Do you think some of the players got the guernseys mixed up??? Clarkey tapping directly down a Saints player's throat? Handballs directly to an opposition player? Seemed to happen quite a bit.

Did someone here give Clarkey some votes? He had one handball, and a bad one at that, no kicks or marks at all. One of his poorer games (and that's being nice!)

 

[Jars458]

Do you think some of the players got the guernseys mixed up??? Clarkey tapping directly down a Saints player's throat? [/B]

Good call

that happened a fair bit in both directions.

Pretty fast game may have been a reason too.

 

[Nige_Bix]

Originally posted by Kane McGoodwin
The coaching was not impressive yesterday. They should get a wake-up call just like the players.

Yep - had the same mental state as the players!

If it's not too late

5. McCleod
4. Edwards
3. Goodwin
2. John****
1. Torney

Team
3. Biglands
2. pass
1. pass

Rookie
pass

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Final Votes

21 votes this week.

Best on Ground
79 McLeod (5)
56 Torney (4)
53 Edwards (3)
52 Goodwin (2)
28 Johncôck (1)
10 Biglands
10 Bickley
8 Hart
5 Smart
4 Burton
4 Clarke
3 Bassett
1 Ricciuto
2 Abstained
315 Total

Best Team Man
39 Bickley (3)
23 Biglands (2)
23 Torney (2)
12 Edwards
8 Clarke
5 Bassett
2 Johncôck
2 Ricciuto
2 McLeod
1 Smart
9 Abstained
126 Total

Best Rookie
4 Reilly
1 Mattner
16 Abstained (1)
21 Total

 

[DaveW]

Re: Final Votes

Originally posted by Kane McGoodwin
21 votes this week.
Best Team Man
128 Total

How did we get 128 when 21 * 6 = 126?

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Re: Re: Final Votes

Originally posted by DaveW
How did we get 128 when 21 * 6 = 126?

Hmmm, buggar - does someone want to do an audit.

 

[sapaul]

Give me 10 minutes to add it all up.

 

[DaveW]

Re: Re: Re: Final Votes

Originally posted by Kane McGoodwin
Hmmm, buggar - does someone want to do an audit.

Just worked it out. Nothing to worry about - only 9 abstained votes, not 11.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Re: Re: Re: Re: Final Votes

Originally posted by DaveW
Just worked it out. Nothing to worry about - only 9 abstained votes, not 11.

Yeah, just worked that out too. All the abstainers this week confused me.