Sam Mitchell or Daniel Harris?

[PHX]

Funny Poll. Sam Mitchell by far.

 

[TipTruck]

but I believe Mitchell is in the Top 20 players in the competition.

Mitchell is not in the top 20 in the league.

He is not even in the top 10 midfielders.

 

[Philhawk]

Mitchell is not in the top 20 in the league.

He is not even in the top 10 midfielders.

Top 10 in Brownlow this year.

Bookmark it.

 

[TipTruck]

Top 10 in Brownlow this year.

Bookmark it.

Don't think so but either way it still doesn't make him a top 20 player.

 

[Philhawk]

Don't think so but either way it still doesn't make him a top 20 player.

What rubbish. Name one player from the Top 10 last year who isn't in the Top 20 players in the league.

 

[buddy23]

Who the **** is Harris?

"Clearance King" Mitchell ****s all over the entire North side, cut them up last week in their pathetic display.

 

[DynamoUltra]

And Judd?

Does he need to improve his evasiveness too?
Get it up to the level of Mitchell and Hodge so he can drop his contested possession numbers?

You'll find that players like Judd draw players to tackle, and as they are being tackled release a handball to advantage. If that is not the case, Judd uses his pace to burn away from a pack after receiving a handball from Kerr or Cousins. That's why these three work so well together as they are stars at both bursting away from packs and also moving the ball to a runner.

 

[half time raffle]

Mitchell is as good now as he will ever be. He is a great clearance player, but that's it, he wont get any quicker and will never be a devastatingly damaging midfielder in the mould of Judd or Cousins. For that reason you would have to think that Harris is going to be a better player - he is also a great clearnace player, he has pace and is well balanced in marking contests. Harris in the next few years will go on to be a very damaging midfielder and in my opinion one of the best in the league.

 

[Benno_900]

What is this thread trying to achieve?

Mitchell is obviously better but not by as much as you hawk supporters make it out to be.

 

[Bulldog1954]

Mitchell easily

 

[buddy23]

Anyone still to vote?

Haha.

 

[Johnny_Segment]

Top 10 in Brownlow this year.

Bookmark it.

Equal 10th in 2006 PH, nice prediction. Followed it up nicely the next year finishing 3rd, 1 vote off 2nd.

 

[go_sainters93]

for all you blokes baggin out harro how about you pull the boots on and go have a one on one with him see how long ya last.......... he might not be the most talented player but he's dam good id rather an in and under player like him than a sheepdog like mitchell.

 

[hawks_time]

By that logic 90% of people wouldn't be allowed to criticize any players.

 

[Mario the Lothario]

It's too early to tell.

There was very little between the pair at the end of 2007 before Harris's performance tapered off in 2008. If Harris were to have a blinder in 2009 he would go straight past Mitchell. Daniel is certainly the more effective player when TOG is factored in. The question is, can Daniel get on the park for longer periods of time?

 

[Mojo]

It's too early to tell.

There was very little between the pair at the end of 2007 before Harris's performance tapered off in 2008. If Harris were to have a blinder in 2009 he would go straight past Mitchell. Daniel is certainly the more effective player when TOG is factored in. The question is, can Daniel get on the park for longer periods of time?

Lol.. how long do you want to wait?

 

[Virgil]

I'd wager Harris hasn't gotten any votes in this thread for about two years?

 

[MinerBoy]

It's too early to tell.

Point 1. There was very little between the pair at the end of 2007 before Harris's performance tapered off in 2008. Point 2. If Harris were to have a blinder in 2009 he would go straight past Mitchell. Point 3. Daniel is certainly the more effective player when TOG is factored in. The question is, can Daniel get on the park for longer periods of time?

Rubbish on every point.

 

[Hard Ball Get]

Rubbish on every point.

I agree.

In terms of comparison, Harris is a spud.
I'm willing to bet if Mitchell was on the marked he would at least create some interest.

 

[TheRedPill]

for all you blokes baggin out harro how about you pull the boots on and go have a one on one with him see how long ya last.......... he might not be the most talented player but he's dam good id rather an in and under player like him than a sheepdog like mitchell.

Nope yep, if I can't beat a player then I can't discuss his weaknesses as a footballer.

 

[boozeDragon]

It's too early to tell.

There was very little between the pair at the end of 2007 before Harris's performance tapered off in 2008. If Harris were to have a blinder in 2009 he would go straight past Mitchell. Daniel is certainly the more effective player when TOG is factored in. The question is, can Daniel get on the park for longer periods of time?

You my friend are a complete idiot.

 

[happyhawkeye]

Mitchell by a long way. He is a Premiership Captain and a role model for the club and at this point in time I believe a much more accomplished footballer.

 

[Philhawk]

hey mate dont come on here bein a terry tough nut buddy. i totally agree with wat hes just said i consider harro to be the hardest workin under rated player in the roo line up he might not have the same smooth moves as some of the show ponys in the league but wat he does well week in week out is the job at hand he's givin a role and he does that to the best of he's ability now im not sayin he tears it up every week and kills it because to be honest thats far from the truth but for the short amount of time he has on the ground from every one else he still does a lot and makes a big impact now i dont know how he didnt get the 3 brownlow votes against the hawks the second time they met this year but all i know is he killed that game he shat all over the hawks did he even poll 1 vote in that game? piss poor effort by the umpys if he didnt any way even tho this is prob the worst year hes had at the club he was still up there in leading handballs over all desposals and tackles and is ranked highly in the league for hard ball gets he also done well in the club b&f considerin hes lack of form this year

Now say it all in one breath.

 

[SA HAWK]

Anyone want to guess how many north fans have voted in this poll?

I will give you a clue it's somewhere between 35 & 37.

 

[Mario the Lothario]

I ended up voting for Harris. As his terrible grand final effort confirmed, Mitchell is slowing down. His fat arse is only going to get bigger and I can see Daniel streaking past him in the coming years.