Analysis SANFL Club Contribution to the Crows

[Kane McGoodwin]

Just some missing players

Nick Pesch

John Klug

Bruce Lindsay

Romano Negri

Wayne Weidemann

Got Pesch, but missed the rest.

Will update as some major misses!

You are aptly named.

 

[dogs105]

South Adelaide

B: Powell, Smart, Elliott
HB: Doughty, Groom, Torney
C: B Cook, Goodwin, Sampson
HF: J Turner, Fitzgerald, n/a
F: Archard, P McIntyre, n/a
R: Bone, Koster, Bickley

Coach: Bickley

Matthew Clarke over Bone

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Sure, but he wasn't originally West Adelaide.

got it …. clubs of origin, no draftee

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

got it …. clubs of origin, no draftee

Yep, otherwise Gunston would be Bulldogs, Kane Johnson Glenelg, etc.

 

[crows dude]

Port Adelaide

B: Johncock, Hughes, D Wakelin
HB: Symes, Chalmers, Ormond-Allen
C: Tregenza, Anderson, Warrior
HF: Bond, D Smith, O'Loughlin
F: D Brown, Hodges, Beinke
R: Downsborough, Bode, McLeod
I: S Pedler, Higgins,

Coach: Walsh

Now... which is the best team?

Na Bodes SANFL club was Glenelg and Downsborough was Norwood. If we are including him I need to add him and Walker to mine then and Massie and Theissen. Crap

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Na Bodes SANFL club was Glenelg

Yes, I know... which is why he is also in the Bays team.

He went from Glenelg to Port Power to Crows.

 

[crows dude]

Yes, I know... which is why he is also in the Bays team.

He went from Glenelg to Port Power to Crows.

Yes but isnt this supposed to be based on where they played SANFL. He never played at the magpies so cant be in ports SANFL crows team.

 

[crows dude]

Is Bode Glenelg or Port?

Glenelg. And Symes is Centrals.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Yes but isnt this supposed to be based on where they played SANFL. He never played at the magpies so cant be in ports SANFL crows team.

My thread, my rules.

Port = Power & Magpies.

Hence included likes of Downsborough.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Glenelg. And Symes is Centrals.

Symes is in the Centrals team already.

 

[crows dude]

Symes is in the Centrals team already.

Yes but should not be included in Ports as didnt play for the magpies

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Yes but should not be included in Ports as didnt play for the magpies

I named Port team not Port Magpies team.

 

[crows dude]

My thread, my rules.

Port = Power & Magpies.

Hence included likes of Downsborough.

LOL OK agree to disagree. Maybe change title to

SANFL Clubs Contribution to the Crows and Port Adelaides Club contribution to the crows (Power and Magpies)​

 

[footy4ever]

South Adelaide

B: Powell, Smart, Elliott
HB: Doughty, Groom, Torney
C: B Cook, Goodwin, Sampson
HF: J Turner, Fitzgerald, n/a
F: Archard, P McIntyre, Bone
R: Clarke, Koster, Bickley

Coach: Bickley

Edit for Clarke.

2x premiership captain and 5 premiership players in that lot...

Aaron Keating? was originally from South - would make 6 premiership players...7 if you included Shane Ellen

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

2x premiership captain and 5 premiership players in that lot...

Aaron Keating? was originally from South - would make 6 premiership players...7 if you included Shane Ellen

Aaron Keating was Norwood... as he won 2 flags in 2 weeks.

 

[spenze]

Which is the best looking Crows team from a SANFL club.

I'll kick it off with Glenelg...

B: Jamison, Bartlett, Rouvray
HB: Viska, Murphy, M Hinge
C: Marshall, McDermott, Gibbs
HF: Pedlar, Fogarty, Hall
F: Bode, West, Sellar
R: Golding, Liptak, McGuiness
I: J Hinge, Krueger, J Hocking, Lamb
Sub J Edwards
E: B Sugars, T Redden

Coach: Cornes

Think West Adelaide will have the Bays easily covered...

/thread

 

[1990crow]

West Adelaide comfortably

West Adelaide

B: Beech, Rutten, Schmidt
HB: Howard, Burgess, Jericho
C: Fielke, Ricciuto, Lamb
HF: Welsh, Thilthorpe, Porplyzia
F: Rankine, Modra, Marsh
R: Rehn, T Edwards, Laird
I: Micken, Lindner, Godden, Dempsey
Sub: Singh
E: Bartsch, Fogden, Coghill, Dabrowski

Coach: Micken

Edit: Forgot the President!

 

[Grenville]

West Adelaide comfortably

Agree the bloods would win it, but think North would give them a good run.

 

[footy4ever]

Aaron Keating was Norwood... as he won 2 flags in 2 weeks.

He played for South before he went to Norwood.

 

[119others]

/thread

Viska, aka “white death” was the most brutal player we have ever had on our list IMO. His ability to viciously bump (smash) opponents when bumping was like nothing else we have ever seen. Our own Byron Pickett clone. I liked him as a player but unfortunately only played a few dozens games. These days his style of play would have not held up.

My mate, a Byron Chiro, treated him as a one off patient a few years ago when Viska was on holidays and said he was the nicest bloke. No sign of the mongrel he displayed on he field.

 

[119others]

Which is the best looking Crows team from a SANFL club.

I'll kick it off with Glenelg...

B: Jamison, Bartlett, Rouvray
HB: Viska, Murphy, M Hinge
C: Marshall, McDermott, Gibbs
HF: Pedlar, Fogarty, Hall
F: Bode, West, Sellar
R: Golding, Liptak, McGuiness
I: J Hinge, Krueger, J Hocking, Lamb
Sub J Edwards
E: B Sugars, T Redden

Coach: Cornes

Think West Adelaide will have the Bays easily covered...

Ok Kane, are you going to do a top 5 finals play off?

My gut feel is that Westies have always had both the quality and quantity to be our best feeder club. Would love them to beat Poort by a huge margin (perhaps around the 20 goal mark) in an elimination or semi final

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

He played for South before he went to Norwood.

Thanks - wasn't aware.

Will update.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Ok Kane, are you going to do a top 5 finals play off?

My gut feel is that Westies have always had both the quality and quantity to be our best feeder club. Would love them to beat Poort by a huge margin (perhaps around the 20 goal mark) in an elimination or semi final

I'll leave that to dogs105

Agree with most West Adelaide clear winner, but after then it gets harder.

Probably something like this...

1 West Adelaide
2 Woodvill West Torrens
3 Norwood
4 Glenelg
5 North Adelaide
6 Port Adelaide
7 South Adelaide
8 Centrals
9 Sturt

 

[Scorpus]

Adelaide (SANFL)

B: --- --- ---
HB: --- --- ---
C: --- --- ---
HF: --- --- ---
F: --- --- ---
R: --- --- ---
I: Murphy --- --- ---

 

[cm_perfect]

Viska, aka “white death” was the most brutal player we have ever had on our list IMO. His ability to viciously bump (smash) opponents when bumping was like nothing else we have ever seen. Our own Byron Pickett clone. I liked him as a player but unfortunately only played a few dozens games. These days his style of play would have not held up.

My mate, a Byron Chiro, treated him as a one off patient a few years ago when Viska was on holidays and said he was the nicest bloke. No sign of the mongrel he displayed on he field.

School footy was not fun if on the opposing side to Mark.
Very strong lad that didn’t mind going the tonk!!