2nds SANFL FINALS QUALFICATION

[crows dude]

UPDATED AS SANFL TOP UPS ONLY HAVE TO HAVE PLAYED ONE GAME.

Thought it might be a good idea to start a thread for our SANFL side. Since they are the only ones looking at finals.

Current criteria if it hasn't changed is

Top Players must play 1 GAME
AFL listed must play more SANFL than AFL and 3 games after June 30.

So I have currently 13 top ups qualified. This includes Freeman.

SANFL TOP UP PLAYERS				AFL LISTED PLAYERS
Player	Games Played			Player	AFL Games	SANFL Games	SANFLGames after June 30
BOYLE	12​	Q		BERRY	9​	2​
HALL	9​	Q		BORLASE	0​	10​
SHARRAD	9​	Q		DAVIS	0​	10​
TEMPLETON	3​	Q		FOGARTY	8​	5​
WRIGHT	10​	Q		HAMILL	7​	4​
FREEMAN	4​	Q		HATELY	8​	3​
				MURPHY	10	1
LEWIS	5​	Q		MCADAM	9​	2​
JOHNSON	2​	Q		MCASEY	0​	10​
SMITHSON	5​	Q		MCPHERSON	1​	5​
MCKENZIE	3​	Q		MILERA	4​	7​
HUTCHENS	2​	Q		MURRAY	7​	6​
MARSHMAN	2​	Q		NANKERVIS	0​	9​
CLAMP	2​	Q		NEWCHURCH	0​	10​
				PARNELL	2​	8​
				PEDLAR	3​	7​
				SCHOENBERG	8​	6​
				SOLIGO	7​	4​
				STRACHAN	2​	9​
				TAYLOR	0​	6​
				THILTHORPE	4​	4​
				WORRELL	0​	11​
				ROWE	11​	2​
				HINGE	10​	1​
				CROUCH	9​	3​
				O'BRIEN	11​	1​
				GOLLANT	7​	5​
				FRAMPTON	6​	5​
				COOK	7​	5​
				HIMMELBERG	9​	4​
				SHOLL	10​	4​
				JONES	12​	2​
				BROWN	11​	2​

 

[Ciao Giacomo]

Great work!

I touched on this in another thread. We are not winning the SANFL flag even if we have no injuries. We might struggle to have 21 players eligible .

Lots of top ups I expect.

 

[StonesThrow]

Not gonna have many players qualify especially if we start rotating more younger players they the afl team for the rest of the season.

 

[Scorpus]

There are seven matches after June 30 in case anyone was wondering, and eight more matches in total.

Quite a few players will fail to qualify when we need more SANFL than AFL matches

 

[crows dude]

Permits will need to be given.

 

[beagle2]

There are seven matches after June 30 in case anyone was wondering, and eight more matches in total.

Quite a few players will fail to qualify when we need more SANFL than AFL matches

The rules are carefully constructed to make sure Adelaide can’t field a competitive team in the finals

 

[CrowinNT]

Thankyou for this informative thread posted - appreciated

 

[walterhobbs]

There are seven matches after June 30 in case anyone was wondering, and eight more matches in total.

Quite a few players will fail to qualify when we need more SANFL than AFL matches

Time to start getting Crouch and Murphy qualified

 

[crows dude]

I wonder if we can get Freeman back to play in finals

 

[Ciao Giacomo]

Time to start getting Crouch and Murphy qualified

It’s too late to qualify Crouch or Murphy. Even if they play no more AFL and all 7 remaining SANFL games, they will not meet the more SANFL than AFL benchmark.

Similar story for Rowe, Hinge, Sholl and Brown. Berry and McAdam will join the list next week.

 

[walterhobbs]

It’s too late to qualify Crouch or Murphy. Even if they play no more AFL and all 7 remaining SANFL games, they will not meet the more SANFL than AFL benchmark.

Similar story for Rowe, Hinge, Sholl and Brown. Berry and McAdam will join the list next week.

Well that just sucks. Tell em to rest up for the post season break

 

[radiojake]

What a crock that qualification process is

 

[crows dude]

Original Post updated

 

[DJ75]

What a crock that qualification process is

Designed with one purpose only.
We will qualify for finals well placed, only to flame out quickly.

 

[crows dude]

Updated based on this weeks selection. Will update if names change. Based on Sholl, Crouch and Gollant playing SANFL and Newchurch as sub.

SANFL TOP UP PLAYERS

AFL LISTED PLAYERS

QUALIFIED AFL

QUALFIED TOP UPS

Only 17 AFL allowed to play including Wright

Player

Games Played

Player

AFL Games

SANFL Games

SANFLGames after June 30

BOYLE

BOYLE

12​

Q

BERRY

10​

2​

CLAMP

CLAMP

2​

Q

BORLASE

0​

12​

1​

FREEMAN

FREEMAN

4​

Q

BROWN

11​

3​

1​

HALL

HALL

9​

Q

COOK

7​

6​

1​

HUTCHENS

HUTCHENS

3​

Q

CROUCH

10​

4​

1​

JOHNSON

JOHNSON

2​

Q

DAVIS

0​

11​

1​

LEWIS

LEWIS

5​

Q

FOGARTY

9​

5​

MARSHMAN

MARSHMAN

2​

Q

FRAMPTON

6​

6​

1​

MCKENZIE

MCKENZIE

4​

Q

GOLLANT

7​

6​

1​

SHARRAD

SHARRAD

9​

Q

HAMILL

7​

4​

SMITHSON

SMITHSON

5​

Q

HATELY

8​

3​

TEMPLETON

TEMPLETON

2​

Q

HIMMELBERG

9​

5​

WRIGHT

WRIGHT

10​

Q

HINGE

10​

2​

JONES

12​

2​

MCADAM

8​

2​

MCASEY

0​

11​

1

MCPHERSON

1​

6​

1​

MILERA

4​

7​

MURRAY

7​

6​

NANKERVIS

0​

10​

1​

NEWCHURCH

0​

11​

O'BRIEN

11​

1​

PARNELL

3​

8​

PEDLAR

3​

7​

ROWE

11​

2​

SCHOENBERG

8​

6​

SHOLL

10​

5​

1​

SOLIGO

7​

5​

STRACHAN

2​

11​

TAYLOR

0​

8​

1​

THILTHORPE

5​

4​

WORRELL

0​

12​

1​

MURPHY

10​

1​

TURNER

1​

1​

 

[Golumless]

I think we could get Matt Crouch

5

Matt Crouch

Age

30

Ht

181cm

Wt

85kg

Pos.

Mid

Career

Season

Last 5

D

28.4

5star

K

12.0

4star

HB

16.4

5star

M

3.3

3star

T

3.9

5star

CL

4.8

5star

D

24.9

5star

K

9.7

4star

HB

15.1

5star

M

2.4

3star

T

2.4

3star

CL

4.4

5star

D

21.2

5star

K

10.4

4star

HB

10.8

5star

M

4.4

4star

T

3.4

5star

CL

2.0

4star

to qualify with the proper coaching

 

[crows dude]

Based on selections this week. Borlase, McAsey, McPherson, newchurch, Strachan, taylor, Worrell and Turner to qualify next week if they play SANFL

SANFL TOP UP PLAYERS				AFL LISTED PLAYERS						QUALIFIED AFL	QUALFIED TOP UPS	Only 17 AFL allowed to play including Wright
Player	Games Played			Player	AFL Games	SANFL Games	SANFLGames after June 30			WRIGHT	BOYLE
BOYLE	13	Q		BERRY	10	2					CLAMP
CLAMP	3	Q		BORLASE	0	13	2				FREEMAN
FREEMAN	4	Q		BROWN	11	4	2				HALL
HALL	9	Q		COOK	7	7	2				HUTCHENS
HUTCHENS	3	Q		CROUCH	10	5	2				JOHNSON
JOHNSON	2	Q		DAVIS	0	11	1				LEWIS
LEWIS	6	Q		FOGARTY	9	5					MARSHMAN
MARSHMAN	2	Q		FRAMPTON	6	7	2				MCKENZIE
MCKENZIE	5	Q		GOLLANT	8	6	2				SHARRAD
SHARRAD	10	Q		HAMILL	7	4					SMITHSON
SMITHSON	5	Q		HATELY	8	3					TEMPLETON
TEMPLETON	2	Q		HIMMELBERG	9	5
WRIGHT	11	Q		HINGE	10	2
				JONES	12	2
				MCADAM	8	2
				MCASEY	0	11	2​
				MCPHERSON	1	8	2
				MILERA	4	7
				MURRAY	7	6
				NANKERVIS	0	11	2
				NEWCHURCH	0	12	2​
				O'BRIEN	11	1
				PARNELL	3	8
				PEDLAR	3	7
				ROWE	11	2
				SCHOENBERG	8	6
				SHOLL	10	6	2
				SOLIGO	7	5
				STRACHAN	2	12	2​
				TAYLOR	0	10	2
				THILTHORPE	5	4
				WORRELL	0	13	2
				MURPHY	10	1	​
				TURNER		2	2

 

[crows dude]

What team could look like in finals. Gives us 16 and 6 so meets SANFL qualification rules

F GOLLANT FRAMPTON WRIGHT
HF PEDLAR MCASEY NANKERVIS
C COOK TAYLOR NEWCHURCH
HB DAVIS WORRELL MCPHERSON
B PARNELL BORLASE SHARRAD
R STRACHAN BOYLE TURNER
I SHARRAD HALL TEMPLETON LEWIS

 

[Peter Doherty]

Still no Cook or Gollant in the AFL this week. Have they decided they want both for SANFL finals?

If this is the case, I gotta say I'm surprised. I thought the club would have zero interest in winning an SANFL flag.

Personally, I would find an SANFL flag embarrassing.

 

[crows dude]

Still no Cook or Gollant in the AFL this week. Have they decided they want both for SANFL finals?

If this is the case, I gotta say I'm surprised. I thought the club would have zero interest in winning an SANFL flag.

Personally, I would find an SANFL flag embarrassing.

Stuff that. Any flag even an Sanfl flag can only help these players. What would be embarrassing is forfeiting due to not having g enough qualified players.

 

[FR0GGY]

Stuff that. Any flag even an Sanfl flag can only help these players. What would be embarrassing is forfeiting due to not having g enough qualified players.

That would only be embarrassing for the SANFL not the club.
The embarrassing thing for the club would be not playing some of our future in the afl earlier.
But the rules are ridiculous, especially the after June 30 bit.

 

[Peter Doherty]

Stuff that. Any flag even an Sanfl flag can only help these players. What would be embarrassing is forfeiting due to not having g enough qualified players.

The SANFL salary cap is 200k? How much would the projected AFC finals team be on? Full time professional footballers.

You can't see how that might be a tad embarrassing?

Helping the younger guys by winning the SANFL flag? They will get more out of being exposed to the speed of AFL in the remaining games is my view.

 

[crows dude]

With Rowe as sub and Berg, Davis , Hately into SANFL side I have the below 21 players now qualified. Note that Brown not named in ANFL Side. Neither is McAdam this week

SANFL TOP UP PLAYERS				AFL LISTED PLAYERS						QUALIFIED AFL	QUALFIED TOP UPS	Only 17 AFL allowed to play including Wright
Player	Games Played			Player	AFL Games	SANFL Games	SANFLGames after June 30			WRIGHT	BOYLE
BOYLE	14	Q		BERRY	10	2				MCASEY	CLAMP
CLAMP	4	Q		BORLASE	0	14	3			TAYLOR	FREEMAN
FREEMAN	4	Q		BROWN	11	4	2			NANKERVIS	HALL
HALL	9	Q		COOK	7	8	3			WORRELL	HUTCHENS
HUTCHENS	4	Q		CROUCH	10	5	2			MCPHERSON	JOHNSON
JOHNSON	2	Q		DAVIS	0	12	2			BORLASE	LEWIS
LEWIS	6	Q		FOGARTY	9	5				STRACHAN	MARSHMAN
MARSHMAN	2	Q		FRAMPTON	6	8	3			NEWCHURCH	MCKENZIE
MCKENZIE	6	Q		GOLLANT	8	7	3				SHARRAD
SHARRAD	10	Q		HAMILL	7	4					SMITHSON
SMITHSON	5	Q		HATELY	8	4					TEMPLETON
TEMPLETON	3	Q		HIMMELBERG	9	6	2
WRIGHT	12	Q		HINGE	10	2
				JONES	12	2
				MCADAM	8	2
				MCASEY	0	12	3
				MCPHERSON	1	9	3
				MILERA	4	7
				MURRAY	7	6
				NANKERVIS	0	12	3
				NEWCHURCH	0	13	3
				O'BRIEN	11	1
				PARNELL	3	8
				PEDLAR	3	8	1
				ROWE	11	2
				SCHOENBERG	8	6
				SHOLL	10	7	3
				SOLIGO	7	5
				STRACHAN	2	13	3
				TAYLOR	0	11	3
				THILTHORPE	5	4
				WORRELL	0	14	3
				MURPHY	10	1
				TURNER		3	3

 

[jo172]

Needs to be carefully balanced, but don't hate a few blokes being given the chance to play SANFL finals ahead of some futile AFL games.

Looking back I tend to think those early SANFL finals blokes like Tex and Gunston played were of significant assistance to them.

 

[crows dude]

Currently 21 players qualified. Davis to qualify if he plays SANFL this week. Crouch will have to play the remaing matches in SANFL to qualify. Himmelberg needs 4 more SANFl games to qualify. Milera and Murray would need to play 3 more games in SANFL. I am assuming all of Pedlar, Davis, Frampton and Gollant will qualify.

Possible Team 13 AND 9 Spread of AFL to top ups.

F JOHNSON MCASEY PEDLAR
HF WRIGHT GOLLANT NANKERVIS
C TEMPLETON TAYLOR NEWCHURCH
HB DAVIS WORRELL MCPHERSON
B SHARRAD BORLASE FRAMPTON
R STRACHAN BOYLE CLAMP
I SMITHSON HALL MARSHMAN HUTCHENS

										*NOT QUALIFIED YET BUT LIKELY TO
SANFL TOP UP PLAYERS				AFL LISTED PLAYERS						QUALIFIED AFL	QUALFIED TOP UPS	Only 17 AFL allowed to play including Wright
Player	Games Played			Player	AFL Games	SANFL Games	SANFLGames after June 30			WRIGHT	BOYLE
BOYLE	14	Q		BERRY	13	2				MCASEY	CLAMP
CLAMP	4	Q		BORLASE	0	14	3			TAYLOR	FREEMAN
FREEMAN	4	Q		BROWN	11	3	1			NANKERVIS	HALL
HALL	9	Q		COOK	7	8	3			WORRELL	HUTCHENS
HUTCHENS	3	Q		CROUCH	10	5	2			MCPHERSON	JOHNSON
JOHNSON	2	Q		DAVIS	0	12	2			BORLASE	LEWIS
LEWIS	6	Q		FOGARTY	9	5				STRACHAN	MARSHMAN
MARSHMAN	2	Q		FRAMPTON	6	8	3			NEWCHURCH	MCKENZIE
MCKENZIE	6	Q		GOLLANT	8	7	3			DAVIS*	SHARRAD
SHARRAD	10	Q		HAMILL	7	4				GOLLANT*	SMITHSON
SMITHSON	5	Q		HATELY	8	4				FRAMPTON*	TEMPLETON
TEMPLETON	5	Q		HIMMELBERG	9	6	2			PEDLAR*
WRIGHT	12	Q		HINGE	10	2
				JONES	12	2
				MCADAM	8	2
				MCASEY	0	12	3
				MCPHERSON	1	9	3
				MILERA	4	7
				MURRAY	7	6
				NANKERVIS	0	12	3
				NEWCHURCH	0	13	3
				O'BRIEN	11	1
				PARNELL	3	8
				PEDLAR	3	8	1
				ROWE	11	2
				SCHOENBERG	8	6
				SHOLL	10	7	3
				SOLIGO	7	5
				STRACHAN	2	13	3
				TAYLOR	0	11	3
				THILTHORPE	5	4
				WORRELL	0	14	3
				MURPHY	10	1
				TURNER		3	3