Teams SC 2015 - My team (During NAB)

[Flandersss]

View attachment 112413
New revised team, only player I am iffy about is Whitecross but not sure what changes I should make to replace him.
Any thoughts?

Change WhiteX to Hamling.

Solid team.

 

[toxic]

View attachment 112413
New revised team, only player I am iffy about is Whitecross but not sure what changes I should make to replace him.
Any thoughts?

Whitx can become zac jones if not named for rd1

 

[CasuallyDressed]

My midfield premos will change.

 

[Stickers32]

Boekhorst not to flash.. with their midfielders out you'd think he would go ok tonight... if he cant get a touch tonight with murph gibbs walker out he never will

 

[Double the Fist]

Boekhorst not to flash.. with their midfielders out you'd think he would go ok tonight... if he cant get a touch tonight with murph gibbs walker out he never will

I'm stumped. Pre-season he was in. After tonight, I don't know who to pick. Dammit!

 

[CasuallyDressed]

Boekhorst not to flash.. with their midfielders out you'd think he would go ok tonight... if he cant get a touch tonight with murph gibbs walker out he never will

He's just a typical Carlton midfielder then?

 

[Krujan]

Boekhorst not to flash.. with their midfielders out you'd think he would go ok tonight... if he cant get a touch tonight with murph gibbs walker out he never will

How do you figure? He's an outside link up player. Missing our 3 best inside mids (Judd, Murph & Squibbs) means that our outside runners see less of the ball, not more. When Curnow is your best inside mid in a game, everyone else is going to struggle getting their hands on the ball.

 

[TN25]

 

[timtamWB]

View attachment 112636

That's definitely a team!

Honestly, I don't know what you want anyone to say to this sort of team. I mean all you're going to get is the standard feedback: Pretty good structure, try to get another premium in the forward line, not sure on Bontempelli or Lycett or KK, Birchall might not be a great pick.

It's a fairly stock standard team.

 

[TN25]

That's definitely a team!

Honestly, I don't know what you want anyone to say to this sort of team. I mean all you're going to get is the standard feedback: Pretty good structure, try to get another premium in the forward line, not sure on Bontempelli or Lycett or KK, Birchall might not be a great pick.

It's a fairly stock standard team.

Yeah it's pretty stock standard. Just interested in anyone's opinion on some of the riskier picks (ie. Crouch, Wines, Birchall, KK, Lycett, Bonts).

 

[Krujan]

Yeah it's pretty stock standard. Just interested in anyone's opinion on some of the riskier picks (ie. Crouch, Wines, Birchall, KK, Lycett, Bonts).

If you're going to go risky/potential they're as good as any that I've seen here. I wouldn't have a problem having those players in my team for Rd1.

 

[CasuallyDressed]

TN25 actually has a similar structure to the one I'm debating on taking in.

I'm really interested in Lycett but I'm scared to take Lycett/Mitchell into round 1.

 

[TN25]

TN25 actually has a similar structure to the one I'm debating on taking in.

I'm really interested in Lycett but I'm scared to take Lycett/Mitchell into round 1.

Lycett and Mitchell will be good selections. Both will have good years. I actually just upgraded Franklin to Goddard and downgraded Bonts to Titch.

 

[CasuallyDressed]

Lycett and Mitchell will be good selections. Both will have good years. I actually just upgraded Franklin to Goddard and downgraded Bonts to Titch.

I currently have Deledio/Swan/Lycett/Mitchell.

I'm also having a good look at Andrew Gaff in the pre-season... could be a guy to have a break out year.

 

[TN25]

I currently have Deledio/Swan/Lycett/Mitchell.

I'm also having a good look at Andrew Gaff in the pre-season... could be a guy to have a break out year.

What is Gaff priced at?

 

[CasuallyDressed]

What is Gaff priced at?

I think he's at about 470k.

 

[TN25]

I think he's at about 470k.

Hmm, to expensive. Better options for cheaper

 

[Krujan]

Lycett and Mitchell will be good selections. Both will have good years. I actually just upgraded Franklin to Goddard and downgraded Bonts to Titch.

Interesting on what other people construe as a an upgrade and downgrade. For mine, Franklin>Goddard is a downgrade & Bonts>Titch is an upgrade, unless your purely going on their starting prices...

 

[Krujan]

I think he's at about 470k.

For that price point, Jack Steven is a much better selection. Gaff is 'too outside' to ever average any more than 100

 

[TN25]

Interesting on what other people construe as a an upgrade and downgrade. For mine, Franklin>Goddard is a downgrade & Bonts>Titch is an upgrade, unless your purely going on their starting prices...

Was just going off price, but I'd call both of them an upgrade probably

 

[Hairy Lager]

How do you figure? He's an outside link up player. Missing our 3 best inside mids (Judd, Murph & Squibbs) means that our outside runners see less of the ball, not more. When Curnow is your best inside mid in a game, everyone else is going to struggle getting their hands on the ball.

Was going to post the same thing, I thought he played like he will start round 1.

 

[MightyDons4]

For that price point, Jack Steven is a much better selection. Gaff is 'too outside' to ever average any more than 100

Sam Mitchell is an even better selection IMO

 

[Kadog]

Sam Mitchell is an even better selection IMO

Steven & SMitchell are both great value under 500k.

Sammys peaking my interest if I can squeeze him in at m6.

 

[toxic]

Steven & SMitchell are both great value under 500k.

Sammys peaking my interest if I can squeeze him in at m6.

So is joey

 

[Mercuri Rising]

Reactionary NAB midprice madness team. Won't be my final one, just playing around with what the past 24-48 hrs has thrown at us (McKenzie, Libba etc). Also featuring burnman Karnezis.

$79,800 left over.