-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
SC Trading Thread (Part II)
- Thread starter Cats_29
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
- Status
muttonchops
Club Legend
Re: Round 4 trades
I posted this message in the wrong thread so I will post it again here...
Could someone help me with my supercoach team for a second..
I have a problem... In my team I had Riewoldt, Tippett, Dangerfield and Bock...
I got rid of Riewoldt, so now I have 1 trade left, Dangerfield and Tippett are in doubt while Bock is gone for 2-3 weeks, what should I do?
I posted this message in the wrong thread so I will post it again here...
Could someone help me with my supercoach team for a second..
I have a problem... In my team I had Riewoldt, Tippett, Dangerfield and Bock...
I got rid of Riewoldt, so now I have 1 trade left, Dangerfield and Tippett are in doubt while Bock is gone for 2-3 weeks, what should I do?
Didakattak
Rookie
- Mar 31, 2010
- 40
- 6
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Miami Heat
Re: Round 4 trades
Hey man - firstly wait til friday morning to get clarification on injuries before making a decision. Secondly who are your bench players?
I posted this message in the wrong thread so I will post it again here...
Could someone help me with my supercoach team for a second..
I have a problem... In my team I had Riewoldt, Tippett, Dangerfield and Bock...
I got rid of Riewoldt, so now I have 1 trade left, Dangerfield and Tippett are in doubt while Bock is gone for 2-3 weeks, what should I do?
Hey man - firstly wait til friday morning to get clarification on injuries before making a decision. Secondly who are your bench players?
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Re: Round 4 trades
My 4 bench players are R Shaw, J Trengove(Melbourne), J Trengove (P.A.), L Franklin...
My 4 bench players are R Shaw, J Trengove(Melbourne), J Trengove (P.A.), L Franklin...
Re: SC Trading Thread (Part II) - PLEASE USE ROUND 4 THREAD FOR NOW
Shouldn't this thread now be locked as it has no further use!
Shouldn't this thread now be locked as it has no further use!
Didakattak
Rookie
- Mar 31, 2010
- 40
- 6
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Miami Heat
Re: Round 4 trades
If Power Trengove is on your backline I would just sub him for old mate for now.
Depending on the time length of injury for Tippett and Dangerfield and the overall strength of your team you may be better to take a zero this week rather than burn a trade. If they are only 2 week injuries then cop the zero adn buddy is back next week. I'd be hesitant to trade Tippett this week - do you have a multi position swap possible for him?
If Power Trengove is on your backline I would just sub him for old mate for now.
Depending on the time length of injury for Tippett and Dangerfield and the overall strength of your team you may be better to take a zero this week rather than burn a trade. If they are only 2 week injuries then cop the zero adn buddy is back next week. I'd be hesitant to trade Tippett this week - do you have a multi position swap possible for him?
- Moderator
- #459
Re: Round 4 trades
Considering 2 options...
Currently have 84k in the bank.
Option 1
Riewoldt > Higgins
Hooker > Gilbert
*This option will leave me with 5k at most in the bank.
Option 2
Riewoldt > Chapman/Harvey/Goodes
Hooker > Malceski
*This option will leave me with about 60/70k left in the bank.
My current back line is:
Hodge, Broughton, Enright, Gram, Hooker, Maguire, Waters. (Silvagni, Farmer)
My current forward line is:
Brown, O'Keefe, Riewoldt, Pavlich, Gray, Ballantyne, Podsiadly. (Gumbleton, Hitchcock)
What seems the better option?
Considering 2 options...
Currently have 84k in the bank.
Option 1
Riewoldt > Higgins
Hooker > Gilbert
*This option will leave me with 5k at most in the bank.
Option 2
Riewoldt > Chapman/Harvey/Goodes
Hooker > Malceski
*This option will leave me with about 60/70k left in the bank.
My current back line is:
Hodge, Broughton, Enright, Gram, Hooker, Maguire, Waters. (Silvagni, Farmer)
My current forward line is:
Brown, O'Keefe, Riewoldt, Pavlich, Gray, Ballantyne, Podsiadly. (Gumbleton, Hitchcock)
What seems the better option?
whobegotyou
Debutant
- Mar 11, 2010
- 77
- 1
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Re: Round 4 trades
I like option 1 more.
I believe Higgins is going to be more consistent over the course of the year, Malceski might get looked at more closely the way he has dominated early, also keep in mind two of those games were against hapless opposition. Having said that he may turn into a very good keeper. Depends how you assess him i guess.
Gilbert is solid and so would chappy/harvey/goodes altough i would take harvey. Chappy's hammy and goodes more forward role are a bit worrying.
I like option 1 more.
I believe Higgins is going to be more consistent over the course of the year, Malceski might get looked at more closely the way he has dominated early, also keep in mind two of those games were against hapless opposition. Having said that he may turn into a very good keeper. Depends how you assess him i guess.
Gilbert is solid and so would chappy/harvey/goodes altough i would take harvey. Chappy's hammy and goodes more forward role are a bit worrying.
Spartans FC
Debutant
Re: Round 4 trades
Hurley or Reimers in this week for Medhurst? What do you guys reckon
Hurley or Reimers in this week for Medhurst? What do you guys reckon
Didakattak
Rookie
- Mar 31, 2010
- 40
- 6
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Miami Heat
Re: Round 4 trades
Lots of people trading Riewoldt and somebody else at the moment. not sure if that necessary - would have thought just Riewoldt at this stage
Lots of people trading Riewoldt and somebody else at the moment. not sure if that necessary - would have thought just Riewoldt at this stage
richomania
Debutant
Re: Round 4 trades
I'm going for the Reiwoldt > Brown trade
but also thinking of swapping either Hunt or Ladson for Waters.
looks like Waters will end up doing a lot better than either of those two..
Or is that just a waste of a trade?
I'm going for the Reiwoldt > Brown trade
but also thinking of swapping either Hunt or Ladson for Waters.
looks like Waters will end up doing a lot better than either of those two..
Or is that just a waste of a trade?
Re: Round 4 trades
depends, lots of people are dumping tippett due to injury and poor form which i think is a pretty reasonable trade. but yeah, a lot of people seem to be jumping on the bandwagon of last weeks hottest player in the hope they will keep going. its a risk, but it could pay off too.... its all part of the fun
depends, lots of people are dumping tippett due to injury and poor form which i think is a pretty reasonable trade. but yeah, a lot of people seem to be jumping on the bandwagon of last weeks hottest player in the hope they will keep going. its a risk, but it could pay off too.... its all part of the fun
Re: Round 4 trades
What was your initial reason for taking medhurst? Did you view him as a keeper? did you view him as someone you were hoping to appreciate to say, 400-450k and then 1-trade him up to a prem?
He may not be outplaying his price too much at the moment, but surely there are more pressing issues in your team than someone who is scoring approximately what he is priced at?
What was your initial reason for taking medhurst? Did you view him as a keeper? did you view him as someone you were hoping to appreciate to say, 400-450k and then 1-trade him up to a prem?
He may not be outplaying his price too much at the moment, but surely there are more pressing issues in your team than someone who is scoring approximately what he is priced at?
Re: Round 4 trades
agreed...only have riewoldt as my must trade, will wait a little for the other cows to blossom...
Re: Round 4 trades
Too sideways, and I'm not sure Reimers and Hurley are necessarily better prospects than Medhurst. I've got Medhurst and he hasn't set the world on fire, but he's pretty much my 7th forward and has been OK. Not worth a trade at this stage, even if someone like Hurley comes in and does well.
Re: Round 4 trades
If Shaw is set to miss gain this week should he be looked at for replacement?
Had hurn + shaw on bench last week (thankfully had the cover) but not overly keen on pushing my luck again this week by having so many starting rookies on the field as i have enough in the mid, will be running one in the forwards and have a starting one in the backline as it is normally.
I see both as keepers and had factored them in as keepers when i made my side, but truth be told, i am a bit concerned about any injury listed as 'back' as in heaters case.
If Shaw is set to miss gain this week should he be looked at for replacement?
Had hurn + shaw on bench last week (thankfully had the cover) but not overly keen on pushing my luck again this week by having so many starting rookies on the field as i have enough in the mid, will be running one in the forwards and have a starting one in the backline as it is normally.
I see both as keepers and had factored them in as keepers when i made my side, but truth be told, i am a bit concerned about any injury listed as 'back' as in heaters case.
LukeParkerno1
Post-Human
Re: Round 4 trades
Wait 2 weeks for Hurley- he is playing forward this year, his scores could suffer. Wait and see. Reimers has been in and out of Esendon's side and with McVeigh to come back into the best 22, I would stay away from him.
Wait 2 weeks for Hurley- he is playing forward this year, his scores could suffer. Wait and see. Reimers has been in and out of Esendon's side and with McVeigh to come back into the best 22, I would stay away from him.
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
richomania
Debutant
Re: Round 4 trades
If he misses again you'd start to worry.. has had issues in the past
thinking maybe Grundy or gilbee?
really hope it doesn't come to that tho
If he misses again you'd start to worry.. has had issues in the past
thinking maybe Grundy or gilbee?
really hope it doesn't come to that tho
rocker_oz33
Make me an Admin!
Re: Round 4 trades
l read in the paper super coach guru sheady said rioli price will most likely go up after this week.can that be right because the players prices have already gone up or do the players price go up/down after every 3rd game the players play or just every 3th week??
l read in the paper super coach guru sheady said rioli price will most likely go up after this week.can that be right because the players prices have already gone up or do the players price go up/down after every 3rd game the players play or just every 3th week??
GotTheGoodes
Bloods
- Moderator
- #472
Re: Round 4 trades
Hahaha... Just heard someone saying they are cashing in on Barlow this week & trading out Roo to get in Gablett........... Why oh why would you
a) trade out Barlow this early on
b) Not have Ablett already
c) tell people you have already completed 6 trades..........
RIDICULOUS!! Please people, don't get dizzy trading your team away so early!! You picked these players for a reason... only LTI or consistent poor form should determine their tradablity.
*** I do confess, having watched Tippett's poor start I am on the verge of trading him 2 but maybe just Roo this week... I have cover on the bench for Danger & Tippett (who mite even play anyway!) and at worst will miss a week or two. You can't use up your trades on every minor injury or reason for not playing one week... thats what you're bench cover is for!!! If I had Franklin I certainly wouldn't be trading him off having probably picked him as a keeper from the start!!
Please... stop the crazy talk & think before you go and get your trade high...
Hahaha... Just heard someone saying they are cashing in on Barlow this week & trading out Roo to get in Gablett........... Why oh why would you
a) trade out Barlow this early on
b) Not have Ablett already
c) tell people you have already completed 6 trades..........
RIDICULOUS!! Please people, don't get dizzy trading your team away so early!! You picked these players for a reason... only LTI or consistent poor form should determine their tradablity.
*** I do confess, having watched Tippett's poor start I am on the verge of trading him 2 but maybe just Roo this week... I have cover on the bench for Danger & Tippett (who mite even play anyway!) and at worst will miss a week or two. You can't use up your trades on every minor injury or reason for not playing one week... thats what you're bench cover is for!!! If I had Franklin I certainly wouldn't be trading him off having probably picked him as a keeper from the start!!
Please... stop the crazy talk & think before you go and get your trade high...
Axe
Norm Smith Medallist
- May 27, 2008
- 8,144
- 1,964
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- San Francisco 49ers
Re: SC Trading Thread (Part II) - PLEASE USE ROUND 4 THREAD FOR NOW
It will be back after this week.
It will be back after this week.
reddahaydn
Senior List
Re: Round 4 trades
haha i agree gotthegoodes....
I have tippet, Bock, Roo and franklin all out this week....a lot of people in my league are in the same situation.
Roo > brown is a sure thing. was a tough pick over brown and ROK however I plan on gettin ROK in later and he should be cheaper in a few rounds than brown will be.
I cant find any info on Bocks injury except that it might be 2-3 weeks but nothing for sure. im tempted to trade him for gilbee who will go up lots this week, because a remember last year bock was meant to be coming abck each week and it ended up being ages with him sitting on my bench....
i think i will sit on tippet as there is noone to swap him to but seaby and nic nat. im hoping they rest him this week so he can get better before he plays next. if he has another poor week he will drop another 60k. i dont wanna swap my rucks till i know if tippet, clarke or cox are gunna fire up. im just spewing i have to cover him with warnock.
Do you guys think i should swap bock for gilbee? i have 85ish k in the bank after the roo-brown trade.
(bock was a shocking choice at from the start,, i shoulda learnt better last year when i had to swap him out for gilbee)
haha i agree gotthegoodes....
I have tippet, Bock, Roo and franklin all out this week....a lot of people in my league are in the same situation.
Roo > brown is a sure thing. was a tough pick over brown and ROK however I plan on gettin ROK in later and he should be cheaper in a few rounds than brown will be.
I cant find any info on Bocks injury except that it might be 2-3 weeks but nothing for sure. im tempted to trade him for gilbee who will go up lots this week, because a remember last year bock was meant to be coming abck each week and it ended up being ages with him sitting on my bench....
i think i will sit on tippet as there is noone to swap him to but seaby and nic nat. im hoping they rest him this week so he can get better before he plays next. if he has another poor week he will drop another 60k. i dont wanna swap my rucks till i know if tippet, clarke or cox are gunna fire up. im just spewing i have to cover him with warnock.
Do you guys think i should swap bock for gilbee? i have 85ish k in the bank after the roo-brown trade.
(bock was a shocking choice at from the start,, i shoulda learnt better last year when i had to swap him out for gilbee)
Re: Round 4 trades
They go up/down after a player plays their third game of the season, and every game that the player plays after that. Not every third week or every third game, EVERY game that the player plays from their third game onwards.
They go up/down after a player plays their third game of the season, and every game that the player plays after that. Not every third week or every third game, EVERY game that the player plays from their third game onwards.
- Status
