Re: Round 4 trades
how long is shuey out for?
how long is shuey out for?
-
-
If you are seeing this notice, posts and uploads you make now may be lost when we cut over to the upgraded system. This should only last a few hours.
Post feedback, issues, errors and omissions here. Read the OP first, please.
-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
SC Trading Thread (Part II)
- Thread starter Cats_29
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
- Status
Re: Round 4 trades
With a forward line of: Roo, ROK, Pav, Harvey, Hall, Ziebell, Warren (Peterson, Gumbleton) I need to replace Roo, and Brown looks the obvious option. However I think there might be better options because I highly doubt Brown can keep it up and he's already increased in price. I wouldn't be gaining anything on my opponents as everyone aready has him.
Seriously considering Chappman, i'll keep Gumby all season so cover won't be a problem if he misses a game. Higgins also looks appealing and gives me an extra 100k which means I could go Ziebell -> Didak in a couple of weeks with one trade. So basically Chapman v Higgins + 100k which could allow meto upgrade a to a premium later on in one trade. Or maybe I should just take Brown. Any thoughts?
I'd take Moles. Picken is out for at least 6 weeks so his job security looks pretty good. Named on the wing this weekend so that's promising. Not sure if Colyer will keep his place in the team for the next 5 or so weeks. The Bombers have made some very suprising selections so far this year which makes me think Colyer isn't safe.
With a forward line of: Roo, ROK, Pav, Harvey, Hall, Ziebell, Warren (Peterson, Gumbleton) I need to replace Roo, and Brown looks the obvious option. However I think there might be better options because I highly doubt Brown can keep it up and he's already increased in price. I wouldn't be gaining anything on my opponents as everyone aready has him.
Seriously considering Chappman, i'll keep Gumby all season so cover won't be a problem if he misses a game. Higgins also looks appealing and gives me an extra 100k which means I could go Ziebell -> Didak in a couple of weeks with one trade. So basically Chapman v Higgins + 100k which could allow meto upgrade a to a premium later on in one trade. Or maybe I should just take Brown. Any thoughts?
douls
Club Legend
rhaz
Cancelled
- Jun 30, 2008
- 8,490
- 6,819
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
Re: Round 4 trades
OKAY-
I have $211k in the bank. I have Shuey/Howlett on my bench in the midfield - one isnt getting games, the other is out for 3-6.
My plan is to get Judd using one of my midfield rookies (Martin/Trengove) in a few weeks... should I get rid of Shuey THIS WEEK for Moles to pocket the $50-60k, and hope Trengove or Martin go up enough that ill be able to afford Judd or another premium with my $260~K in the bank?
OKAY-
I have $211k in the bank. I have Shuey/Howlett on my bench in the midfield - one isnt getting games, the other is out for 3-6.
My plan is to get Judd using one of my midfield rookies (Martin/Trengove) in a few weeks... should I get rid of Shuey THIS WEEK for Moles to pocket the $50-60k, and hope Trengove or Martin go up enough that ill be able to afford Judd or another premium with my $260~K in the bank?
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Re: Round 4 trades
Is it worth jumping on the bastinac train now?
I thought he would only be out for a couple?
Is it worth jumping on the bastinac train now?
Re: Round 4 trades
It's a hard one with Bastinac. Maybe wait another week and then access where Shuey (supposing your thinking of trading him out) is at as we should have more information by then. There will still be other options available to trade down to and it'll make you a little bit of cash.
Re: Round 4 trades
So that article about Rioli has thrown me right off him. So now 2 hours before lockout Im desperately trying to find a replacement. Im wondering if Heath Grundy is looking amazing to me right now because he's all thats left or becasue its his breakout year that all sc'ers dream of stumbling upon for a cheap price. What are our thoughts feelings and emotions on Grundy?
So that article about Rioli has thrown me right off him. So now 2 hours before lockout Im desperately trying to find a replacement. Im wondering if Heath Grundy is looking amazing to me right now because he's all thats left or becasue its his breakout year that all sc'ers dream of stumbling upon for a cheap price. What are our thoughts feelings and emotions on Grundy?
Re: Round 4 trades
go chapman if you want the best scorer, go higgins if you want a player who's body won't fail him (as much)
i'm playing 2 rookies, 2 risky players (hall, medhurst) and a low scoring gia in my forward line, so i went for the safety of roo -> brown
go chapman if you want the best scorer, go higgins if you want a player who's body won't fail him (as much)
i'm playing 2 rookies, 2 risky players (hall, medhurst) and a low scoring gia in my forward line, so i went for the safety of roo -> brown
Re: Round 4 trades
EDIT: probably Higgins in option 1.
I like option 1 quite a lot. Safer than option 2 imo. However whilst option 2 is more risky, it probably has greater possible benifts if both Chappy and Rioli stay injury free, but that's pretty unlikely. So if you want consistency i'd take 1, but if your looking to make up ground on others and happy to take a risk then maybe 2. But I like option 1 better.
EDIT: probably Higgins in option 1.
Re: Round 4 trades
So what I would do in your situation, (I actually have done it lol) I would just trade in Roo for Brown, his scores could be the difference in you winning or losing in your league games, when your opponent has him..
You could pick up Higgins another week as his BE is just under 100, whereas Browns is 35..
Roo > Brown.. Thats all you should be doing this week.
To be honest bomber, you should have had Higgins in your starting line up.. You could get him now and pocket the $100k, but you do need Brown in your team and this week is the only time that you can really get him.. He is a SC god, just like ablett, he scores well even if he has a quiter game than usual..
So what I would do in your situation, (I actually have done it lol) I would just trade in Roo for Brown, his scores could be the difference in you winning or losing in your league games, when your opponent has him..
You could pick up Higgins another week as his BE is just under 100, whereas Browns is 35..
Roo > Brown.. Thats all you should be doing this week.
Sunday Red
Club Legend
Re: Round 4 trades
Do we know the prognosis on Chris Newman?
It could just be a week, but it could also be one of those "unknown" injuries that has him sidelined for a month.
Do we know the prognosis on Chris Newman?
It could just be a week, but it could also be one of those "unknown" injuries that has him sidelined for a month.
Re: Round 4 trades
Do I keep Shuey and maybe trade in JKT for Moles this week? JKT will have limited game time with Young back in the team and the hawks will be making big changes in the next feww weeks with Burgoyne, Sewell, Shiels and Buddy to come back in. Thoughts?
If I get Bastinac now, it will make my life easier for when I bring Judd into my team (Judd is a must have).. Keeping Shuey will make it hard, not making any money, especially with JKT the other player on my bench..
Do I keep Shuey and maybe trade in JKT for Moles this week? JKT will have limited game time with Young back in the team and the hawks will be making big changes in the next feww weeks with Burgoyne, Sewell, Shiels and Buddy to come back in. Thoughts?
MattBrads14
Debutant
- Feb 3, 2010
- 69
- 0
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Arsenal
Re: Round 4 trades
Alright guys, been thinkin bout this all week,
As most do got the reiwoldt problem and i want to get rid of meds,
So im thinkin,
Roo > ROK
Meds > Rioli
6,000 left over if i do that trade
What do you think, think there are any other options out there?
Thanks.
Alright guys, been thinkin bout this all week,
As most do got the reiwoldt problem and i want to get rid of meds,
So im thinkin,
Roo > ROK
Meds > Rioli
6,000 left over if i do that trade
What do you think, think there are any other options out there?
Thanks.
Re: Round 4 trades
I'm now uncertain on Rioli after hearing he didn't train. I'm leaning towards getting Michael Hurley. Any advice?
I'm now uncertain on Rioli after hearing he didn't train. I'm leaning towards getting Michael Hurley. Any advice?
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
- May 27, 2006
- 51,562
- 103,160
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- I'm aware of and love the Miami Dolphins
- Moderator
- #645
Re: Round 4 trades
Hmm. After talking myself into Riewoldt > Pavlich and Tippett > Rioli all week, I think I'll just go Riewoldt > Brown and stick with Kurtley.
Hmm. After talking myself into Riewoldt > Pavlich and Tippett > Rioli all week, I think I'll just go Riewoldt > Brown and stick with Kurtley.
Re: Round 4 trades
IMO though after watching Cyril very closely over the last 2 weeks, if he has a groin problem, god help the competition when he is 100% fit... He seems fine to me when on the park.. Also with Cyril, he is one of those players that doesnt need to spend much time on the track, his natural ability gets him through a game..
If you have got too many Hawk players in your team, I would certainly be looking at him before Hurley, if he scores well again this week, which I think he will because the pies have no one to go with him, he could be the Leon Davis of 2010..
Rioli hasnt trained much recently and he is still tearing it up.. If you are not confident with Rioli maybe wait another week and see how he goes on the weekend, you have 3 weeks to pick up Hurley if you opt to have him..
IMO though after watching Cyril very closely over the last 2 weeks, if he has a groin problem, god help the competition when he is 100% fit... He seems fine to me when on the park.. Also with Cyril, he is one of those players that doesnt need to spend much time on the track, his natural ability gets him through a game..
If you have got too many Hawk players in your team, I would certainly be looking at him before Hurley, if he scores well again this week, which I think he will because the pies have no one to go with him, he could be the Leon Davis of 2010..
Re: Round 4 trades
I've got Shuey and Howlett both on my bench. I've made up my mind that I'm gonna trade one of them (I set aside a couple of trades for this sort of thing) for Moles this week:
Howlett: Not playing at the moment but may come back later, will lose 9k
Shuey: Injured unsure how long, could also come back soon, will gain 60k for me.
So which one should I trade? Shuey could be back in a few weeks anyway and continue to make money (therefore I would have culled a cash cow early) while Howlett might not get a game any time soon.
I've got Shuey and Howlett both on my bench. I've made up my mind that I'm gonna trade one of them (I set aside a couple of trades for this sort of thing) for Moles this week:
Howlett: Not playing at the moment but may come back later, will lose 9k
Shuey: Injured unsure how long, could also come back soon, will gain 60k for me.
So which one should I trade? Shuey could be back in a few weeks anyway and continue to make money (therefore I would have culled a cash cow early) while Howlett might not get a game any time soon.
Re: Round 4 trades
If I was in your situation I would go higgins as well, but Rioli could be the next big SC prince...
Like I told another poster earlier, you should have had Higgins in your starting line up..
If I was in your situation I would go higgins as well, but Rioli could be the next big SC prince...
- Status
