Scarlett out...Callan in?

[BlueNWhite]

What are the board's thoughts on young Callan coming back into the side this week to bolster our defensive stocks?

 

[costanza23]

This would be Callan's big chance to come into the side. But how did he go in the VFL last week , is he good enough because I know he hasn't played for ages.

 

[Unwritten_Law]

I think it would be a good move, he will be required versus the bulldogs mosquito fleet next week.

OUT: Scarlett Gardiner
IN: Callan Byrnes

We have enough talls for Hawthorn and the Bulldogs so no point bringing in Lonergan, Spencer or Nathan.

 

[Scarlett30]

He was one of the better players in the twos last week, but I only saw the second half, he did however take a nasty hit to the head and might have some slight concussion.

I feel we have enough small defenders to cover the hawk’s small forwards; my concern is if they try and stretch us by throwing a number of talls forward.

 

[Ricketts]

I'd love Callan to get in the side.

 

[camo123]

is wojinski ready? i would bring him in have a game before we play the bullies

 

[cats2rise]

is wojinski ready? i would bring him in have a game before we play the bullies

Unwritten_law, Gardiner will stay in.
Kelly is due to return soon isnt he? Apart from the fact that int he Herald sun today they said Geelong had 2 Kellys, one will be ready in a week, the other will be readt in 1-2...?!?
OUT: Scarlo Slade
In: Either Callan, , Byrnes, Wojja, Kelly or RIcco..?!?

 

[Champ39]

Unwritten_law, Gardiner will stay in.
Kelly is due to return soon isnt he? Apart from the fact that int he Herald sun today they said Geelong had 2 Kellys, one will be ready in a week, the other will be readt in 1-2...?!?
OUT: Scarlo Slade
In: Either Callan, , Byrnes, Wojja, Kelly or RIcco..?!?

Haha yeah I saw that too!
I was like what the? Is it 1 or 2?
Hahaha

 

[Champ39]

Unwritten_law, Gardiner will stay in.
Kelly is due to return soon isnt he? Apart from the fact that int he Herald sun today they said Geelong had 2 Kellys, one will be ready in a week, the other will be readt in 1-2...?!?
OUT: Scarlo Slade
In: Either Callan, , Byrnes, Wojja, Kelly or RIcco..?!?

Haha yeah I saw that too!
I was like what the? Is it 1 or 2?
Hahaha

 

[Champ39]

Unwritten_law, Gardiner will stay in.
Kelly is due to return soon isnt he? Apart from the fact that int he Herald sun today they said Geelong had 2 Kellys, one will be ready in a week, the other will be readt in 1-2...?!?
OUT: Scarlo Slade
In: Either Callan, , Byrnes, Wojja, Kelly or RIcco..?!?

Haha yeah I saw that too!
I was like what the? Is it 1 or 2?
Hahaha

 

[Champ39]

Unwritten_law, Gardiner will stay in.
Kelly is due to return soon isnt he? Apart from the fact that int he Herald sun today they said Geelong had 2 Kellys, one will be ready in a week, the other will be readt in 1-2...?!?
OUT: Scarlo Slade
In: Either Callan, , Byrnes, Wojja, Kelly or RIcco..?!?

Haha yeah I saw that too!
I was like what the? Is it 1 or 2?
Hahaha

 

[Champ39]

Unwritten_law, Gardiner will stay in.
Kelly is due to return soon isnt he? Apart from the fact that int he Herald sun today they said Geelong had 2 Kellys, one will be ready in a week, the other will be readt in 1-2...?!?
OUT: Scarlo Slade
In: Either Callan, , Byrnes, Wojja, Kelly or RIcco..?!?

Hahaha
I saw that too!
I was like WHAT THE?!?

 

[jess_555]

NO, Slade wont go! Well I hope he doesn't!

Injury list as of the 11th of April.
Nick Batchelor—hamstring rehab—6 weeks
Tom Harley---progressing well---4-5-weeks

zMSgetJS('adsize=300x250&position=island');​

James Kelly--- test
Matt McCarthy---back—1-2 weeks
Stephen Owen—conditioning program—1-2 weeks
Travis Varcoe--- foot—1-2 weeks
Henry Playfair—shoulder—2-3 weeks
Peter Riccardi --- hamstring—1-2 weeks

OUT: Scarlo, Mackie
IN: Byrnes, Kelly (depending on test), Callan or Spencer

*Actually I'm not so sure about Spencer. Also maybe they should give Kelly another week off just so he really is right. We need him for the Bulldoggies so I wouldn't wanna risk him.

 

[Champ39]

How long is Tom Harley not going to play for?
At the start of the season the said by about Round 3 or 4
Now it's 3 to 4 games from Round 3....
Is he ever going play?

 

[carn_the_cattas]

This board also says we have 5 Champ39s except they all say the same thing.

 

[Champ39]

This board also says we have 5 Champ39s except they all say the same thing.

Hahha that was my fault.
I am impatient and clicked the button ten times
Sorry.

 

[catempire]

Gardiner will play. Slade will play. Scarlett won't play. In Byrnes.

 

[costanza23]

NO, Slade wont go! Well I hope he doesn't!

Injury list as of the 11th of April.
Nick Batchelor—hamstring rehab—6 weeks
Tom Harley---progressing well---4-5-weeks

zMSgetJS('adsize=300x250&position=island');​

James Kelly--- test
Matt McCarthy---back—1-2 weeks
Stephen Owen—conditioning program—1-2 weeks
Travis Varcoe--- foot—1-2 weeks
Henry Playfair—shoulder—2-3 weeks
Peter Riccardi --- hamstring—1-2 weeks

OUT: Scarlo, Mackie
IN: Byrnes, Kelly (depending on test), Callan or Spencer

*Actually I'm not so sure about Spencer. Also maybe they should give Kelly another week off just so he really is right. We need him for the Bulldoggies so I wouldn't wanna risk him.

Mackie wont be dropped. He had 20 possesions and kicked 2 goals. Gardiner had 13 possesions and kicked 0 goals. Mackie's done enough to stay in the side.
IN: Byrnes and Prismall (give him a run, he played well in the VFL last week)
OUT: Scarlett and Gardiner.

 

[Partridge]

Mackie wont be dropped. He had 20 possesions and kicked 2 goals. Gardiner had 13 possesions and kicked 0 goals. Mackie's done enough to stay in the side.
IN: Byrnes and Prismall (give him a run, he played well in the VFL last week)
OUT: Scarlett and Gardiner.

Gardiner won't get dropped. We don't have anyone else who can fill those big floppy shoes.

 

[Ricketts]

I'd love Callan to get in the side.

But not at Slade's expense... I'd like Slade to play on Williams this week and then one of the dogs forwards the week after.

 

[costanza23]

Gardiner won't get dropped. We don't have anyone else who can fill those big floppy shoes.

Maybe Lonergan can play for Charlie. Didn't Lonergan kick 8 goals in his past two VFL matches?

 

[catempire]

Maybe Lonergan can play for Charlie. Didn't Lonergan kick 8 goals in his past two VFL matches?

I just can't see Charlie being dropped. I'm far from his biggest fan but Bomber seems to love him. Perhaps Charlie saved his life or something

 

[thehoff]

I just can't see Charlie being dropped. I'm far from his biggest fan but Bomber seems to love him. Perhaps Charlie saved his life or something

Surely bomber will finally come to his senses and drop him for the sake of the team?

 

[Mr Sensitive]

Surely bomber will finally come to his senses and drop him for the sake of the team?

Not likely... Gardiner is Bomber's secret love child... i'd tip mackie to be given the boot this week, even though he doesn't deserve it based on last weeks effort..

---------------
Lem... Lem I'm sorry, but I had to right? Lem you know I'm sorry.. I am so sorry man... oh God--- Shane Vendrell

R.I.P Curtis Lemansky