Scotland?

[Bronx Bomber]

With Scotland wanting to come to Carlton..would you entertain trading him there???? If so what would you ask for?

 

[CaptnCarlton]

I believe the woods want a 2nd round pick. I suppose if we offer our 3rd round pick which is really like a late round 2 pick they may accept the deal at 1:45pm tomorrow.

 

[Nic]

I'd rather keep him, considering he's still contracted for a year, but that's probably not going to happen. Hopefully whatever we get for him can be used in a deal to get someone good (ie. not a Calrton player).

 

[Joel]

Apparently, he might be going to North for Pick 24. Can Carlton do better than that?

 

[labrooy]

To beat that Carlton would have to offer a player. I don't believe they have anyone capable of matching Scotland for value so would need to offer their third round pick and a player (remember they don't have any first or second round picks). I think the Roos would be a better trade but then Scotland apparently wants to go to Carlton.

 

[Kooley]

You can keep Scotland. Gets on the juice too much. We have too many of those at Carlton.

 

[Rival_V]

Originally posted by Kooley
You can keep Scotland. Gets on the juice too much. We have too many of those at Carlton.

Yeah, but he is quality. You don't have many of that at Carlton.

 

[Dane Swan Fan]

I'd want Scotland for Laurance Angwin or Brad Fisher.

Angwin has his problems but would be a great backup for Fraser.

 

[guess_who]

I want Scotland to stay so damn hard, but wouldn't blame him if he left because of lack of game time, he should get more respect from the coach.

I'd take Angwin for Scotland considering that he wats to leave.

 

[NICK THE PIE MAN]

Umm I'm just guessing but for some reason I don't think that Angwin would pass the Malthouse character test.

 

[rockdog]

Heath Scotland, will never ever be a dominant midfielder, he will always be a mediocre one.

 

[guess_who]

Originally posted by rockdog
Heath Scotland, will never ever be a dominant midfielder, he will always be a mediocre one.

You nob!!!

I tell you fellas what i will get the game statistics from everygame that he plays next year an prove to you that he is a star player.