Remove this Banner Ad

Player Watch Scott Pendlebury

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

What is wrong with saying "That's a matter between me and the club, as it should be." Why does this have to be aired in public at all? If you want to put some feelers out quietly that's what managers are for, but why in effect stick a for sale sign on your head with flashing lights at all? What does it achieve, beyond coming across as woefully tacky?
I suspect he's been given a contract offer from us that he is pissed off with.
 
It would be the dumbest move all on the back of a coaching offer.
He will get coaching offers whenever he finishes up.
Finishing as a one club player....at his age and standing is priceless

Nah. Do you think Mitchell or Hodge damaged their brand in the slightest by spending the final couple of years at another club?
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

It won’t happen (Pendles leaving). But imagine the embarrassment our President, Coach and Captain all in one year.

And no, no one can unequivocally say he’s not leaving until the contract is signed. But even Pendles says contracts aren’t worth the paper they’re written on.
 
Nah. Do you think Mitchell or Hodge damaged their brand in the slightest by spending the final couple of years at another club?

If they had their time again....yes they wouldn’t do it.
I think it also damaged the culture at hawthorn. it serves no purpose.
Jordan Lewis definitely agrees with this too.
 
As a payed with his standing in the game...to him.
If I were a player with his CV...finishing my career for 12 months elsewhere would look back on it with regret.

He won’t have shortage of offers for coaching gigs post retirement
So to you not him then
 
If they had their time again....yes they wouldn’t do it.
I think it also damaged the culture at hawthorn. it serves no purpose.
Jordan Lewis definitely agrees with this too.

Lewis is different in that he felt pushed. What makes you think Mitchell wouldn't do it? He's become head coach much quicker than he otherwise would.
 
"Pendlebury confirmed that a one-year offer has been tabled by Collingwood, but he'd look at rival offers if they included a coaching component."


If this is truem then I would do to Pendles what Leigh Matthews did to Mark Williams who was captain at the end of 1986 and was talking to other clubs to try to bump up his price with Collingwood.

Lethal told him if you as captain are touting offers from other clubs for whatever reason, then see you later.

Bye Pendles - enjoy the Gold Coast.
 
The difference with the Hawthorn guys is they were pushed out when they had a year left in them.

Pendles isn’t being pushed out, the way he played this year he’s probably got 2yrs left in him. But at his age a 1yr deal is pretty standard across the comp.

As for getting a longer term deal that includes an assistant coaching role I don’t really see why he needs to do that this year. Whenever he finishes he’s not going to struggle to find a coaching/development role at another club.
 
Lewis is different in that he felt pushed. What makes you think Mitchell wouldn't do it? He's become head coach much quicker than he otherwise would.

He went for one year....do you think it impacted his prospects of coaching?
he went straight back to hawthorn on the first flight out of Perth
 

Remove this Banner Ad

He went for one year....do you think it impacted his prospects of coaching?
he went straight back to hawthorn on the first flight out of Perth
I think being a Premiership winning assistant coach is pretty significant on his resume. Particularly as he got a fair bit of credit for their midfield set up. It would have also changed the relationship with the coach and playing group to one where he was seen as a coach rather than a player. I think it matters.
 
It would be the dumbest move all on the back of a coaching offer.
He will get coaching offers whenever he finishes up.
Finishing as a one club player....at his age and standing is priceless
Was going to post the same thing. Makes zero sense. He wants more than what we are offering or a second year- or both. Which means to me that GWbhas offered a modest amount compared to previous generosities
 
I think being a Premiership winning assistant coach is pretty significant on his resume. Particularly as he got a fair bit of credit for their midfield set up. It would have also changed the relationship with the coach and playing group to one where he was seen as a coach rather than a player. I think it matters.

I think It’s vastly overrated.
Playing days are different to post playing days.
If he wants to coach then retire.

As a player...to finish up elsewhere....when you’re also the games record holder and captain of the club...makes little sense
 
Maybe the Eddie and bucks departures and salary cap debacle and now the ongoing board disgrace have loosened Pendles commitment.

Definitely still feels toxic to me.
Thats the thing. In a normal happy working environment, you’re willing to stay on for less.

But when you’re dealing with turmoil and the village idiots are running the show, it takes a toll on you and can get to the stage where you contemplate leaving.

There’s plenty of supporters who have had enough of the club because of the whats happened with the muppets running the show, it will be no different to some of the players.

As someone already mentioned, no way would Pendles have even thought about a statement like this before. Obviously behind the scenes its getting to him.
 
Pendles is contract negotiating through the media whilst club captain you think? Alternatively, maybe it's already been decided. Maybe Pendles got a tap on the shoulder. GW and Gold Coast guy meeting recently remember. GW was the guy when Mitchell, Hodge, Lewis et all were shipped out yeah. Perhaps this is the charade that has to play out before it's announced. It's a crazy world.
It makes sense, another theory hypothetically speaking, several weeks ago a caller on SEN to have seen Clarko & Pendles having a coffee(believable??)
Could they unite at the Suns next year?
 
It makes sense, another theory hypothetically speaking, several weeks ago a caller on SEN claims to have seen Clarko & Pendles having a coffee...Could they unite at the Suns next year?
It’s the Pies next Succession plan!
Pendles plays two years under Clarko, retired, assistant coach at another club for 3 years, coaches a VFL side for 2 years, in the box with Clarko for 2 years. Collingwood premiership coach
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

To who? Him or you?
I think from Scott Pendlebury's perspective - in terms of viewing himself as a potential career coach going forward - I think it makes a lot of sense. I saw him play his Ist game against Brisbane in 2006 at the MCG. If I recall accurately, he kicked a goal with his Ist kick in AFL football at the Richmond End after receiving a pass from Buckley. After 16 years & all of his achievements, he owes the club nothing at this point in his career. In terms of his own development, I think that experiencing a different culture & a totally different work environment can only enhance his development. Good luck to him. Goodnight & good luck.
 
I think It’s vastly overrated.
Playing days are different to post playing days.
If he wants to coach then retire.

As a player...to finish up elsewhere....when you’re also the games record holder and captain of the club...makes little sense
Times have changed... it's a legit career move. The assistant coach world is fairly cutthroat... it's best to build up your resume while you've still got a couple years left in your legs. Being a legend gets your foot in the door, but guarantees very little. It's a professional move, and he is a professional guy. Leaving behind sentiment is part of that.
 
Times have changed... it's a legit career move. The assistant coach world is fairly cutthroat... it's best to build upon your resume while you've still got a couple years' play left in your legs. Being a legend gets your foot in the door, but guarantees very little. It's a professional move, and he is a professional guy. Leaving behind sentiment is part of that.

Professionalism....choose what you want to do.
play football or coach?
Luckily for us and for him he seems smart enough to continue Playing
 
Professionalism....choose what you want to do.
play football or coach?
Luckily for us and for him he seems smart enough to continue Playing
There's been captain/coaches before...they weren't unprofessional. All teams value onfield experience. The onfield coach / playing old legend model can work fine.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Player Watch Scott Pendlebury

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top