Remove this Banner Ad

FTA-TV Scream

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

AusHorrorStory said:
I'm convinced it's Kieran. I'm picturing the unmasking scene in the season finale where it's him revealing his identity to Emma, Audrey, Brooke and Noah. Another thing, not many people are too attached to Emma, why not throw in a huge twist and get rid of her? Make any future seasons revolve around Audrey, or even Brooke, as they're better characters.
Click to expand...
I'm all for killing Emma, she's probably the most beige character on the show!
 
AusHorrorStory said:
I can also see Brooke being a 'Jill' like killer from Scream 4. Jealous that it's not her getting all the attention and sympathy.

But of course she'd need an accomplice, she couldn't have lifted and thrown Ms Lang down the staircase.
Click to expand...

Just saw the newest episode and came to post the same thing.

Spoilers for those who haven't seen episode 11 yet.
They obviously made it out to look like it was Gustavo that hacked into Noahs computer but hadn't Brooke and him been staying together? She could have easily been following the orders of the accomplice who I'm thinking has to either be Eli or Kieran. Leaning towards Kieran as I think Eli is an obvious choice, but he'll some how be the savior of the day.

How ever I'm thinking she hasn't been in on it the whole time. I'm thinking not long after Jakes death. I mean isn't it odd she hasn't exactly been singled out or attacked this season. What happened after the credits rolled when she was screaming in that pool after the reveal of Jakes death.
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Still convinced it's Kieran - closer to 100% now. Not sure on the second killer, though.

He shows up after an attack and made to look like a hero AGAIN! In fact, he does it twice in this ep - rocking up to her house after Emma is visited by the killer whilst she slept, and then again jumping out of his car after Emma and Audrey are being led away by the cops.

He has done this way too often across the entire season, and his character has been lurking in the shadows way too much.

Also, wasn't Kieran the only other person who knew that Emma and Audrey were heading to the farm? Was an easy way to lure Brooke's dad and have Emma and Audrey at the scene of the crime to frame.

Plus, the scene of Kieran 'finding' the Piper letters behind Eli's bed screams out like a red herring to me. Am convinced Kieran hid them there beforehand and deliberately FaceTimed himself 'finding' them to solidify in Emma and Audrey's minds that he himself couldn't be the killer. Classic move.

Also, if Eli was the killer, why in order to get Brooke's dad off him and his Aunt's back, did he resort to blackmailing him instead of just killing him? Not a suspect for mine, way too obvious.

And the question as to why the killer is trying so hard to frame both Emma and Audrey has to be brought into question. Obviously he/she has no intention of killing them, otherwise they would have done so. All part of his/her plan in getting away with it all I guess after they kill all of the intended victims - Billy and Stu style.

Perhaps it has a link back to Brandon James and how he was supposedly framed for the murders he was accused of committing back in the day.

Also, how fishy was it that when the psych teacher was being interviewed by Stavo's dad that she didn't elaborate as to why she screamed when she saw Emma visit her at the hospital a few episode's ago. Or (if she is somehow involved) was she screaming at her partner Kieran being there, fearing he was there to finish her off?
 
Last edited:
Yeah looking more and more like Kieran. Thought he was the red herring early doing the Billy Loomis "show up after an attack," but considering how overt the actual red herrings have been it's looking like it might not have meant to be so obvious.
 
Kickpuncher said:
Just saw the newest episode and came to post the same thing.

Spoilers for those who haven't seen episode 11 yet.
They obviously made it out to look like it was Gustavo that hacked into Noahs computer but hadn't Brooke and him been staying together? She could have easily been following the orders of the accomplice who I'm thinking has to either be Eli or Kieran. Leaning towards Kieran as I think Eli is an obvious choice, but he'll some how be the savior of the day.

How ever I'm thinking she hasn't been in on it the whole time. I'm thinking not long after Jakes death. I mean isn't it odd she hasn't exactly been singled out or attacked this season. What happened after the credits rolled when she was screaming in that pool after the reveal of Jakes death.
Click to expand...

How about the duo of Kieran & Brooke?

EDIT: Then again, I'm not sure Brooke would go as far as having her father killed.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

SugarShane said:
Yeah I don't like the idea of it being Brooke. Weren't there shots of her trying to contact Jake when she was alone? No reason to do that when not in public if you were involved in his murder.
Click to expand...

That's why I'm thinking she may have gotten in on it after the reveal of Jake and the Brookes blood bath. There's a gap between her screaming under water at the end of the episode and the following one. I think it's somewhere in there she became involved. She may not be 100% committed but I still somehow think shes involved.

Isnt it weird how shes pretty much one of the only people that hasn't been singled out yet as a target?
 
Carbine Chaos said:
Just watched the latest ep, so good and intense!

I can't figure out who it is - they've done a fantastic job of this season.
Click to expand...
I'm still in the Kieran camp purely because of his knack to be in the most convenient place at the most convenient time but it's anyone's game now.
 
Someone online picked up on this from the previous episode. A hint, perhaps?

1ce1ba046cf54ac4a5f4d84d678b0c5a
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

If it's Kieran why would he be working with Piper in season 1?

I could understand if he had no relation to the Season 1 killings and him being the killer this season is some twisted way to protect Emma by getting back at Audrey for bringing Piper to town, but if he was the accomplice in Season 1 why would he be harassing Emma back then?
 
Carbine Chaos said:
What would Kieran's motive be?
Click to expand...

I reckon he was either romantically involved with Piper, or is her brother and now that she is dead he is out for revenge on Emma and everyone in town. The latter would be messed up given he's slept with Emma (who would be his half-sister), but there has to be a reason as to why Piper spun the story to Emma about Brandon James' mother saying Kieran was his son. Was she actually telling the truth, was she trying to set up an innocent man, or did she try and double-cross her partner by making him the fall-guy?

As for his 'tragic' background - i'd say it would have to be something twisted. Eli has mentioned how Kieran has a temper, so was he actually the cause of his mother and step-dad dying in the car accident (cut their brake line or something to that effect). Did he also have a frosty relationship with his father who may have suspected him of being involved in the Lakewood murders, so he killed him out of hatred and to help get the heat off his back as a potential suspect?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom