Remove this Banner Ad

FTA-TV Scream

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

WaLkEr_ThE_StAr said:
I reckon he was either romantically involved with Piper, or is her brother and now that she is dead he is out for revenge on Emma and everyone in town. The latter would be messed up given he's slept with Emma (who would be his half-sister), but there has to be a reason as to why Piper spun the story to Emma about Brandon James' mother saying Kieran was his son. Was she actually telling the truth, was she trying to set up an innocent man, or did she try and double-cross her partner by making him the fall-guy?
Click to expand...
All of this sibling stuff is way too Harper's Island, it's pretty cliche at this point, so I hope they avoid that path.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

No on has mentioned Stavo? At the start, they showed the killer walking into Emma's house and you can see the boots he is wearing.

Now fast forward to the part in the episode where Stavo is saying goodbye to Brooke on his bike out the front of her house, he is wearing those boots, I'm sure of it, may have to have another look but either he could be the killer or is in on it.

Him or Kieran IMO, they've made it out to look like it is Eli but he just has a messed up past with other secrets IMO.
 
UnitedWarrior93 said:
No on has mentioned Stavo? At the start, they showed the killer walking into Emma's house and you can see the boots he is wearing.

Now fast forward to the part in the episode where Stavo is saying goodbye to Brooke on his bike out the front of her house, he is wearing those boots, I'm sure of it, may have to have another look but either he could be the killer or is in on it.

Him or Kieran IMO, they've made it out to look like it is Eli but he just has a messed up past with other secrets IMO.
Click to expand...

Maybe it is Stavo...that part were everyone in the room turned on him after Audrey showed them his drawings was just to throw us off?

Duo of Kieran & Stavo perhaps?
 
OhhhhhCyril said:
Reddit
Click to expand...

If you're talking about the photos that have been released of Emma and a few others holding weapons, I wouldn't be so easy to believe you can tell who the killer is from them.

I know a few are claiming they reveal the killer, but I doubt it.

Unless, it's something else I haven't seen?
 
The killer, or at least one of them HAS to come from the original Lakewood survivors. Have cut a video together which I'll post up later explaining why...

Btw I only just noticed a new clue upon re-watching Jake's death scene. When he opens the barn gate after being captured, a car's headlights turn on and the killer comes out to scare him back inside. Thing is, you can clearly make out that it is a truck's headlights. Who have we seen driving a truck multiple times? Kieran!

Also, pretty sure Stavo only rides his bike, so that could rule him out?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

WaLkEr_ThE_StAr said:
The killer, or at least one of them HAS to come from the original Lakewood survivors. Have cut a video together which I'll post up later explaining why...

Btw I only just noticed a new clue upon re-watching Jake's death scene. When he opens the barn gate after being captured, a car's headlights turn on and the killer comes out to scare him back inside. Thing is, you can clearly make out that it is a truck's headlights. Who have we seen driving a truck multiple times? Kieran!

Also, pretty sure Stavo only rides his bike, so that could rule him out?
Click to expand...
I thought it was Jake's truck that the killer used
 
With the big finale tonight, anyone willing to throw out predictions for who you suspect as the killer/s, and who will survive?

I'm 100% set on Kieran as one of two killers, as I had suspected he had to be involved in some way back in season 1. I think he was the other 'surprise' Piper was referring to, not Audrey.

The fact he has always shown up in the most convenient moments after the killer appears is too hard to ignore.

Motive? I believe he was either romantically involved with Piper or the son of Bradon James. His dark past has remained hidden unlike other characters like Stavo, Eli etc, and reckon he had involvement in his mother and step-fathers deaths.

Killer #2 I'm not too sure about, but believe it has to be an older character in order to tie it back in with the Brandon James storyline. Kieran's Aunt or Emma's dad are the two I'm picking with the latter more likely given he was directly associated with the Brandon James murders when they happened. The thinking behind this could mean Kieran's motive or involvement could be tweeked.

My theory is that he was the one who actually committed the murders back in the day and tried to frame Brandon James, as he lusted after Maggie. Emma will turn also turn out to be Brandon's daughter. Emma's 'dad' uses the photos of Emma as a child to serve as a reminder of her being the child that he could have had with Maggie.

SMOKIE...

If an older character isn't revealed as a killer, I'm starting to warm to the fact that Emma is involved - but with a twist.

She has developed a split personality due to her trauma that has seen her use it as a vehicle for expressing the anger and rage bottled inside.

We've seen Emma bring up the topic of dreams to her psych teacher early in the season, her many dream sequences about her friends dying, and the massive clue about her sleep walking into the kitchen and acting out her dream when she was found in the kitchen by Maggie holding a knife. Not to mention her 'visions' of the killer appearing and the fact she became violent towards Hayley. This part of the story had to have been written into the script for a reason this year, and stands out more than Emma just suffering from PTSD.
 
WaLkEr_ThE_StAr said:
With the big finale tonight, anyone willing to throw out predictions for who you suspect as the killer/s, and who will survive?

I'm 100% set on Kieran as one of two killers, as I had suspected he had to be involved in some way back in season 1. I think he was the other 'surprise' Piper was referring to, not Audrey.

The fact he has always shown up in the most convenient moments after the killer appears is too hard to ignore.

Motive? I believe he was either romantically involved with Piper or the son of Bradon James. His dark past has remained hidden unlike other characters like Stavo, Eli etc, and reckon he had involvement in his mother and step-fathers deaths.

Killer #2 I'm not too sure about, but believe it has to be an older character in order to tie it back in with the Brandon James storyline. Kieran's Aunt or Emma's dad are the two I'm picking with the latter more likely given he was directly associated with the Brandon James murders when they happened. The thinking behind this could mean Kieran's motive or involvement could be tweeked.

My theory is that he was the one who actually committed the murders back in the day and tried to frame Brandon James, as he lusted after Maggie. Emma will turn also turn out to be Brandon's daughter. Emma's 'dad' uses the photos of Emma as a child to serve as a reminder of her being the child that he could have had with Maggie.

SMOKIE...

If an older character isn't revealed as a killer, I'm starting to warm to the fact that Emma is involved - but with a twist.

She has developed a split personality due to her trauma that has seen her use it as a vehicle for expressing the anger and rage bottled inside.

We've seen Emma bring up the topic of dreams to her psych teacher early in the season, her many dream sequences about her friends dying, and the massive clue about her sleep walking into the kitchen and acting out her dream when she was found in the kitchen by Maggie holding a knife. Not to mention her 'visions' of the killer appearing and the fact she became violent towards Hayley. This part of the story had to have been written into the script for a reason this year, and stands out more than Emma just suffering from PTSD.
Click to expand...

I think Eli will get the flick. He'll be a hero that saves somebody.
 
AusHorrorStory said:
I think Eli will get the flick. He'll be a hero that saves somebody.
Click to expand...
Agree with this.

I pretty much agree with the theory above.. Kerien is a James. Don't mind the idea of Emma's mum (think Scream 2 Billy's mum was the killer) but I'am still keen on Audrey totally bullshitting this entire series, and she is behind most of it (has motive)

Or Noah.., his own sick twisted little horror movie.
 
OhhhhhCyril said:
Agree with this.

I pretty much agree with the theory above.. Kerien is a James. Don't mind the idea of Emma's mum (think Scream 2 Billy's mum was the killer) but I'am still keen on Audrey totally bullshitting this entire series, and she is behind most of it (has motive)

Or Noah.., his own sick twisted little horror movie.
Click to expand...

Would be cool if Audrey was Piper's accomplice still killing in S2, and there was another new killer that has been trying to undermine her and get her caught.

Would love for Noah to be the killer, that would totally throw me as he is on the bottom of my suspect list.

Also agree that Eli will be the hero.

Apparently only 3 of the Lakewood Six survive. If so, my tip is Noah, Brooke and Emma will survive.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Killer spoiled below:

Well just as we all expected, Kieran! The finale was intense, and I knew Eli was going to get the flick but I'm kind of sad that he did now. Interesting ending with Kieran being in jail and getting that phone call at the very end. And it looks like Gustavo and Brooke are together now.

Now let's all just cross our fingers and hope that it gets continued in one way or another instead of being cancelled altogether
 
Ugh that was terrible. His motive was so weak and the actor is so bad, I was cringing at his acting during the reveal scene. The boyfriend being the killer is so cliche, can't believe they did it again especially since scream 1 did it. I have rewatched season 1 a couple of times but don't think I can get through that again.

On a positive note that last scene gave me chills, gives me hope if there is another season. Hopefully the original killer is still alive (maggie/kevin/brandon) and is going to come back for the last season to kill everyone. I can dream...
 
I have 3 candidates:

1. Emma's mum.

I feel this would be a huge twist. The mum, the protector of her daughter. She has a past with Brandon James.

2. Keiran.

As WTS touched on, he has shown up at all sorts of time during this season, trying to play the "good guy" and boyfriend. Has a past we know nothing about and always gets touchy whenever Eli says something to Emma, Eli obviously knows a thing or two. And also a connection with Piper is a nice twist too, trying to get Emma back.

3. Stavo.

Now I don't think he'll be the number 1 killer but I think he may be a part of it somehow. Strange boy who is obsessed with killing, we saw him get bullied and that turned many people away from him being in on it or the killer. Draws pictures of everything and everyone, and I swear he was wearing those boots that the killer was wearing while breaking into Emma's house last episode.

Can't wait for tonight.
 
Trent1 said:
Ugh that was terrible. His motive was so weak and the actor is so bad, I was cringing at his acting during the reveal scene. The boyfriend being the killer is so cliche, can't believe they did it again especially since scream 1 did it. I have rewatched season 1 a couple of times but don't think I can get through that again.

On a positive note that last scene gave me chills, gives me hope if there is another season. Hopefully the original killer is still alive (maggie/kevin/brandon) and is going to come back for the last season to kill everyone. I can dream...
Click to expand...

Im still not sure the point of the whole farm house and why Eli's mother skipped town too
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom