Search for a Scapegoat

Why did the Australian bid fail?

  • FIFA is inherently corrupt

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Qatar are better networkers

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • The spread of Islam in football

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • The Asian confederation didn't back Australia

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • The FFA made tactical errors with their bid

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Australian governments weren't supportive enough

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • The stories in The Age damaged the bid

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • The Australian media in general was too negative

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • The AFL's negotiations damaged the bid

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • The Australian people weren't supportive enough

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • No scapegoats. We gave it our best shot

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Munro_Mick

All Australian
Joined
Mar 15, 2007
Posts
717
Likes
26
Location
Mill Park
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Danish Vikings
#28
LIke the Republic, I liked the subjective notion, but, the objective model was......frankly,....objective, (objectionable)

and so, the WC bid has fallen flat - and from the subjective front - I feel offended that Australia was 'rejected',

from the objective perspective, it's more of an 'I told you so',

from a pragmatic perspective - well, FIFA is BIG business and it's hard to deny them to follow the money train.

And, I genuinely feel sympathy for the people who put their heart and soul into it.
 

mustapha

Club Legend
Joined
Jun 13, 2001
Posts
1,985
Likes
8
Location
Bundoora
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Melbourne Victory
#29
Qatar had 11 votes in the first round. That means that 11 members had been convinced that it was sensible to host the worlds biggest sporting event in this tiny country in sweltering in 50 degree heat. 11 members decided to completely ignore the concerns raised in FIFAs own technical report. THe amount of money that the Qataris were throwing around must be staggering.

Ben Buckley could have walked into the final presentation holding hands with Vlad, Gallop and a topless Elle Macpherson. It would not have made a difference. In hindsight we could never have won this bid. Could anyone have beaten this bid? We just don't have that amount of cash to throw around.

THe latest from Foxsports news (an emotional Andy Harper so I'm not sure of the reliability) is that Qatar are going to attempt to move the world cup to January to avoid the heat. Given the events of today, this previously unthinkable idea would not surprise me at all. Screw that I want to see them fulfil the promise to air condition open roofed stadiums.

I'm also looking forward to them bringing peace to the middle east.

What an interesting few days. At least with this bid done, the FFA can starting putting some focus on the A League (some basic promotion and a sensible fixture would be a good start).
 

Munro_Mick

All Australian
Joined
Mar 15, 2007
Posts
717
Likes
26
Location
Mill Park
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Danish Vikings
#31
Qatar had 11 votes in the first round. That means that 11 members had been convinced that it was sensible to host the worlds biggest sporting event in this tiny country in sweltering in 50 degree heat. 11 members decided to completely ignore the concerns raised in FIFAs own technical report. THe amount of money that the Qataris were throwing around must be staggering.

Ben Buckley could have walked into the final presentation holding hands with Vlad, Gallop and a topless Elle Macpherson. It would not have made a difference. In hindsight we could never have won this bid. Could anyone have beaten this bid? We just don't have that amount of cash to throw around.

THe latest from Foxsports news (an emotional Andy Harper so I'm not sure of the reliability) is that Qatar are going to attempt to move the world cup to January to avoid the heat. Given the events of today, this previously unthinkable idea would not surprise me at all. Screw that I want to see them fulfil the promise to air condition open roofed stadiums.

I'm also looking forward to them bringing peace to the middle east.

What an interesting few days. At least with this bid done, the FFA can starting putting some focus on the A League (some basic promotion and a sensible fixture would be a good start).
Given Australia came stone motherless last, knocked out in Rnd 1 with 1 vote - - - Australia was therefore beaten by the FIELD, and not just Qatar.

That Qatar got 11 votes in Rnd 1 and ultimately won illustrates rather well that :
A - 'no worries' just seriously doesn't cut it on the world stage
B - that Qatar was well 'sold' (or 'bought') from the outset
C - that when talking about a FIFA WC being worth 95% of FIFA's 4 yearly revenue, point A is reinforced
D - that whilst we may not think much of Qatar, it IS however part of the Middle EAst, and that region is MASSIVE in respect to Europe/Asia/Africa and world relations.
E - and for all that we may think it too hot there - - that region, and harsh climates are home to millions and millions,
F - and perhaps winter in Australia wasn't that appealling.

What MUST be very, very clear - - even to the mungbeans like Craig Foster - - is that the AFL and NRL will have had nothing to do with it.

Afterall, the FIFA technical report made zero mention of the Govts MOU and rival codes,

and when I say 'zero mention' - I mean it (look at the FIFA tech document and the 'current use' of stadia would mention cricket, soccer and that was it - - Australian Football and Rugby League had dropped off the face of the planet,..........which reminds me of something David Gallop said almost a year to the day ago when he rejected the FFA's resched proposals (commenting the support couldn't come at any cost).

So, from that perspective - - perhaps a lot of people got pushed to the point by the pro-soccer whining such that pleasure might (sadly) be taken in the pain of others.
 

Fastback

Premiership Player
Joined
Jun 27, 2006
Posts
4,045
Likes
427
Location
Melb
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Other Teams
Liverpool FC
#32
Paul Hogan - the tax evading wax dummy looked tired and disinterested in the pres, maybe he had just been to court?
Seriously though, this takes me back to ~1992 when Atalanta were announced for the Olympics. We are overlooked because we are such a minnow in a political/geographical/world sense, but surprisingly to some can organise the best world events, obviously not a prerequisite...
 

Munro_Mick

All Australian
Joined
Mar 15, 2007
Posts
717
Likes
26
Location
Mill Park
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Danish Vikings
#33
Clearly Australia lacked support from the Asian confederation.

At the end of the day, is that really surprising??

Australia is in Asia, no, it's in Oceania, no, it's in Asia and yet Australia was trying to promote the 'last continent' (Australasia) as the 'last frontier' when,.......we were seeking Asian support???

Do the other members of the Asian Confed really accept Australia as a full blown member of 'Asia' or was Australia just accepted as part of WC slot management??
 

mustapha

Club Legend
Joined
Jun 13, 2001
Posts
1,985
Likes
8
Location
Bundoora
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Melbourne Victory
#34
Given Australia came stone motherless last, knocked out in Rnd 1 with 1 vote - - - Australia was therefore beaten by the FIELD, and not just Qatar.

.
You don't think that part of the strategy of the other bidders was to eliminate Australia early ( i.e. eliminate a threat)? This is not just a popularity contest where the Exco members vote for their favourite bids. They have spent months agonising over voting scenarios that would see them coming out on top. The fact that we got one vote is no reflection on the quality of the bid. Qatar out negotiated/out bribed everyone. We were just the first part of their superior strategy
 

mustapha

Club Legend
Joined
Jun 13, 2001
Posts
1,985
Likes
8
Location
Bundoora
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Melbourne Victory
#35
Clearly Australia lacked support from the Asian confederation.

At the end of the day, is that really surprising??

Australia is in Asia, no, it's in Oceania, no, it's in Asia and yet Australia was trying to promote the 'last continent' (Australasia) as the 'last frontier' when,.......we were seeking Asian support???

Do the other members of the Asian Confed really accept Australia as a full blown member of 'Asia' or was Australia just accepted as part of WC slot management??
We are probably not fully accepted yet. We have only been there for a very short time.
 

Zidane98

Hall of Famer
Joined
Dec 22, 2009
Posts
34,688
Likes
14,222
Location
South End, AAMI Park
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Other Teams
Socceroos, Liverpool, Victory
#36
You don't think that part of the strategy of the other bidders was to eliminate Australia early ( i.e. eliminate a threat)? This is not just a popularity contest where the Exco members vote for their favourite bids. They have spent months agonising over voting scenarios that would see them coming out on top. The fact that we got one vote is no reflection on the quality of the bid. Qatar out negotiated/out bribed everyone. We were just the first part of their superior strategy
There were rumors going around that both of the Japanese & South Korean bids done deals via Bin Hammam to ensure they were not knocked out in round 1 so they could save face. I believe Bin Hammam promised votes from the Qatar/Latin voting bloc in the early rounds which would then be switched to Qatar in the later rounds, thus eliminating one of either Australia or the USA first up. Unfortunately the 7/8 exco members who wanted Qatar dismissed weren't strong enough and lost out in the end.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

usalion

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Oct 5, 2004
Posts
15,161
Likes
269
Location
Athens, GA
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
Other Teams
Phils, Eagles, Flyers, Sunderland
#38
I voted for fIFA being corrupt, because I truly thought that a couple weeks out from the vote when the whole mess was being picked over with the suspended delegates.

Obviously, Asia didn't support Australia, but then, the Asia representatives were South Korea, Japan and Qatar- who clearly voted for themselves. Can't remember who the other two members are, but who did they vote for?

I'm curious as to where Australia's vote actually came from- not being funny here, but which delegate do you think voted for the Aussies?

Also, Qatar clearly knew the political ropes- give credit to Bin hamman there....but then again, what happened to the Spain-Qatar alliance?

A sad day for football.....
 

stuart27

Club Legend
Joined
Jun 26, 2008
Posts
1,385
Likes
4
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
MVFC, West Ham, Rebels
#40
Alright gang, we need to get rid of all the oil by 2022 to really screw these bastards. Everyone go out to your cars, set the engines to idle. Then we play the waiting game.

Honestly, I think Asia just gamed us. They wanted their established members to save face so sacrificed the new kid. Fair enough, if we couldn't get the support from the rest of the world to force Asia behind us, why should we assume that we'd be their highest priority should it come to voting?

That and FIFA are a pack of corrupt bastards and Qataris are snakes in the grass.

God damn I hope we end up playing them in the Asian Cup Knockouts. Smash the bastards.
 
Joined
Aug 21, 2002
Posts
2,213
Likes
425
Location
oneeyed-richmond.com
AFL Club
Richmond
#41
FIFA was always corrupt but it's official now. So much for the technical and evaluation reports :rolleyes:.

Sydney-centric bid - all celebs were from NSW and mostly old hat ones and virtually all bid promotional events were held in Sydney. So typical of the FFA to think Australia ends at Picton when Soccer should not be a sport that suffers from historical interstate rivalries.

Too much messiah talk surrounding Lowy and his supposed negotiating clout. One vote FFS!

Lack of transparency and details from the FFA while the bid was being put together which caused unnecessary division and also shut out the public from truly embracing the bid along the way until the final days.

The FFA showing visiting FIFA delegates a stadium (Etihad) that wasn't part of the bid :eek:.

Soccer zealots and those in the Sydney media for mouthing off for the past year about the evil AFL. And right on cue there's another paranoid idiot who has just rang into 3aw. I didn't realise the 22 FIFA delegates were on Demetriou's payroll :rolleyes:.


Next time (2038 at the earliest) we need a stronger argument to put to FIFA than just "we haven't had it before". Obviously some BS about "world peace" needs to be in there :rolleyes:.

Trying to compete for star/celeb power doesn't work for us especially when we use 1980s and 90s has-beens :eek:.

Don't submit a bid when other Asian nations are bidding. Bloc votes are important to survive the early rounds of voting.

Make sure the Oceania confederation delegate isn't stupid enough to get himself suspended from the vote :rolleyes:.

Make sure the ASEAN delegate isn't a backstabbing weasel who voted against an ASEAN members' bid.

Make sure we check before submitting the bid that any of the bidding competitors don't have unlimited pockets to bribe and promise a fantasyland.



How about we just all agree to make Craig Foster the scapegoat for just being an utter tool and still publicly calling Australians ignorant even post the bid announcement :rolleyes:.
 

Peter Sidorkiewicz

Premiership Player
Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Posts
4,524
Likes
2,144
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Collingwood
#42
FIFA is inherently corrupt, Qatar are better networkers and the Asian confederation didn't back Australia.

Simple as that.
^ Pretty much.

Asian confederation is the big one. Australia needed them to at least get into the 2nd round of voting. Japan & Korea also bidding as separate bids stuffed things up because they were never going to get it after co-hosting in 2002.
 

Munro_Mick

All Australian
Joined
Mar 15, 2007
Posts
717
Likes
26
Location
Mill Park
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Danish Vikings
#44
The question is will we ever be?
FFA need to put in hard yards,

both domestically and within the confederation.

Australia has to convince Asia that it's not just a marriage of convenience that Australia is part of the Asian confederation.

Hosting the 2015 Asian Cup you'd have to think would be a step in the right direction.
 

TP86

All Australian
Joined
Apr 16, 2010
Posts
912
Likes
475
AFL Club
Hawthorn
#47
Qatar's investment in networking and face-to-face opportunities with voting nations - hosting the meeting of african federations in angola for instance - footing the bill on numerous occasions when they had no reason to be there other than political negotiation.

That and Bin Hammam's politcal clout leading Qatar as the strongest Asian bid among a nowhere near unified confederation.

It's safe to say that Australia were more than tens of millions short of matching Qatar on the first count, and more than hundreds of personnel in the right places short of matching them on the second count.

Bid/presentation/government/domestic codes is all superficial - but it's also what we'll hear a lot about.
 

Munro_Mick

All Australian
Joined
Mar 15, 2007
Posts
717
Likes
26
Location
Mill Park
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Danish Vikings
#49
FIFA was always corrupt but it's official now. So much for the technical and evaluation reports :rolleyes:.

Sydney-centric bid - all celebs were from NSW and mostly old hat ones and virtually all bid promotional events were held in Sydney. So typical of the FFA to think Australia ends at Picton when Soccer should not be a sport that suffers from historical interstate rivalries.

Too much messiah talk surrounding Lowy and his supposed negotiating clout. One vote FFS!

Lack of transparency ........

......How about we just all agree to make Craig Foster the scapegoat for just being an utter tool and still publicly calling Australians ignorant even post the bid announcement :rolleyes:.

Tend to agree,

but, isn't the next 'opportunity' going to be 2034. i.e. the new pseudo rotation is that a host confed can't bid in the next 2, so, Europe can't go again until 2030, and 'Asia' until 2034. Thus meaning, the 2026 will be between what's left,.....Africa and America's.

Do you reckon FIFA might just kill off the 'rotation' thing!!!
 

Joe Mama

Club Legend
Joined
Apr 5, 2001
Posts
2,455
Likes
58
Location
Everywhere you want to be
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
Other Teams
Mernda, Murchison,Man City,
#50
As the old saying goes "Money talks and bullsh!t walks", that's the reason why we lost, nothing more, nothing less, and that was the reason why Atlanta won the 1996 Olympics and not Athens & Melbourne, because we were simply out played, we were the pawn and Qatar was the king.
 
Top Bottom